The former Memorial Hermann surgeon remains scheduled to stand trial June 22 as the judge weighs a motion to dismiss the indictment.

HOUSTON — A federal judge is considering whether to dismiss a high-profile criminal case against a former Houston transplant surgeon accused of altering medical records and jeopardizing patients awaiting organ transplants.

Dr. John Stevenson Bynon, 66, appeared in federal court Monday as his attorneys argued that the allegations against him do not amount to a federal crime, despite acknowledging that patient records were altered.

RELATED: Houston doctor indicted for allegedly altering medical records, making patients ineligible for organ transplants

Bynon, the former surgical director of liver transplantation at Memorial Hermann, is accused of falsifying medical records for some of his patients who were on the United Network for Organ Sharing liver transplant waitlist to make them “functionally ineligible for a donation.”

Federal prosecutors allege his actions manipulated transplant eligibility and put lives at risk.

During the hearing, Bynon’s defense team argued that he altered records to keep patients active on transplant waitlists until their health conditions improved enough to withstand surgery. Attorneys also contended that Bynon was operating under transplant guidelines established during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Prosecutors countered that those arguments should be presented to a jury at trial rather than serve as grounds for dismissing the indictment.

A federal grand jury indicted Bynon in January on charges related to the alleged manipulation of transplant records. He then pleaded not guilty. 

Throughout the hearing, the judge sharply questioned both prosecutors and defense attorneys. At one point, she acknowledged the case was unusual but stopped short of issuing an immediate ruling on the defense’s motion to dismiss.

However, the judge did rule to keep certain evidence out of the trial, including medical information beyond Bynon’s care about the five patients mentioned in the indictment.

Bynon’s attorneys declined to comment after the hearing.

The trial remains scheduled to begin June 22 unless the judge rules otherwise. If convicted, Bynon could face up to 25 years in federal prison.

Got a news tip or story idea? Email us at newstips@khou.com or call 713-521-4310 and include your name and the best way to reach you.