FILE - Cleveland Browns defensive end Myles Garrett celebrates with fans after an NFL football game against the Cincinnati Bengals in Cincinnati, Jan. 4, 2026.

FILE – Cleveland Browns defensive end Myles Garrett celebrates with fans after an NFL football game against the Cincinnati Bengals in Cincinnati, Jan. 4, 2026.

David Dermer/AP Photo/David Dermer

Before he became one of the best defenders in the NFL, Myles Garrett had a request. He pleaded to Cowboys owner Jerry Jones to trade up from the back of the first round of the 2017 draft to the top, where they would be in position to select the former Arlington Martin and Texas A&M star. 

“I’m pleading to you, Jerry,” he said in a video posted on ESPN. “Mr. [Jason] Garrett, make it happen. Dak Prescott is leading our team right now. I need you to take Tony Romo, a couple picks, and give them to Cleveland so you could pick me up. Please. I’d love to play in Dallas. Just make it happen.”

Garrett was selected first overall by the Browns and played there for nine years. And despite some fans pleading for Jones and the Cowboys to make a move for Garrett, who was reportedly available via trade, again he landed elsewhere. 

Article continues below this ad

In a blockbuster move that rattled the NFC, the Browns traded Garrett to the Los Angeles Rams. They dealt the seven-time All-Pro and the two-time Defensive Player of the Year for a first-round pick in 2027, a second-round pick in 2028 and a third-round pick in 2029. The Rams also sent defensive end Jared Verse in the trade. Verse, a former first-round pick, made the Pro Bowl in each of his first two NFL seasons.

In the wake of the deal, some Cowboys fans wondered why their team didn’t swing a trade for the Arlington native. The better question is whether they could. 

The answer: Likely not. 

The main reasoning goes back to the trade itself. ESPN and NFL Network reported after Monday’s trade that the Rams had been interested in a trade for Garrett for some time. Their interest was to no avail, until the Rams decided to include Verse in the discussion. Verse is not Garrett, but he’s 25 and a proven piece on a rookie deal. Verse will have a cap hit of roughly $5 million the next two seasons combined. Garrett, 30, will have a cap hit of more than $24 million the next two seasons. That’s before a combined cap hit of roughly $113 million over the following three seasons. 

Article continues below this ad

Browns general manager Andrew Berry told ESPN on Tuesday that they only would’ve traded Garrett for premium picks and a “young, cost-controlled star at a premium position.”

Even if they wanted to pursue Garrett, the Cowboys likely couldn’t offer a player like Verse in a package back to Cleveland. Pro Bowl defensive tackle Quinnen Williams likely would be the only player who would intrigue the Browns, but he’s 28 years old and not exactly cheap.

The Cowboys have some young, cost-controlled options at premium positions, but they aren’t proven players like Verse. Former second-round pick Donovan Ezeiruaku, for example, had two sacks and nine tackles for loss his rookie season. Verse has 12 sacks and 22 tackles for loss in his first two seasons. 

But why not then add more picks to the pot? The Cowboys likely wouldn’t be willing to mortgage that much of their future. They drew a line in the sand when it came to their pursuit of Las Vegas defensive end Maxx Crosby. Before the draft, and before Crosby’s failed physical with the Baltimore Ravens, they were willing to part with one of their two first-round picks in 2026 and a second-round pick in 2027. Acquiring Garrett would’ve cost more than that. 

The Cowboys could’ve included a first-round pick in 2027 in the discussion, however. That’s true, even if they don’t know which pick will be theirs. 

Article continues below this ad

The Cowboys already have agreed to send the better of their first-round pick in 2027 and the first-round pick they acquired for Micah Parsons from Green Bay to the New York Jets. That was a part of the Williams trade. That doesn’t mean their 2027 first-round capital is frozen. The Cowboys would have to stipulate in any deal involving their 2027 first-round assets that the pick would be the lower of theirs and Green Bay’s, based on 2026 records. 

The Cowboys have also made it known that they’re comfortable with the current state of their roster. There’s optimism over the plethora of moves they made on defense, along with the hiring of new defensive coordinator Christian Parker. They have two open roster spots, as of Tuesday, and have yet to show urgency to fulfill them. 

Bringing Garrett back to the Dallas area would’ve been a huge move for the Cowboys. It just wasn’t one they could’ve swung this time around.