Aerial view of Dallas City Hall on Friday, Sept. 12, 2025, in Dallas
Smiley N. Pool/Dallas Morning News
Repairing Dallas City Hall could cost more than half a billion dollars, and city leaders acknowledged Wednesday they do not have a clear way to pay for it.
Consultants told council members that repairing and modernizing the aging downtown building would cost between $532 million and $611 million over the next decade.
They said the building’s aging infrastructure and code deficiencies make a limited repair strategy unrealistic.
The estimate leaves city leaders facing a costly choice: spend hundreds of millions to remain in the building or continue exploring alternatives, including relocating city operations elsewhere.
“How are we supposed to pay for all this?” council member Lorie Blair asked City Manager Kimberly Bizor Tolbert.
Tolbert said the city has no dedicated funding source for the work. Paying for it, she said, might include issuing debt, an approach typically used for new construction projects, or diverting money from the city’s budget.
“There are no free options,” Tolbert said.
The latest repair projections have intensified a long-running debate over City Hall’s future.
Article continues below this ad
One consulting team, Gresham Smith, estimated repairs would cost $531.6 million if completed over roughly six years or $556.8 million if spread over 10 years. The proposed work included crucial repairs to the roof, generators and other major building components in the first phase and addressing others in risk-based phases.
WM2, the other firm, recommended resealing windows, concrete walls, and the pool that’s leaking water into the parking garage in the first phase and a stacked, silo approach for other equipment. Their costs ranged from $591.2 million to $610.8 million.
Some business and civic leaders have said the city should explore other locations, while preservationists and neighborhood advocates want to keep the I.M. Pei-designed building in public use.
Core concerns
The discussion came as downtown Dallas faces renewed scrutiny. Over the past two days, Neiman Marcus said it is leaving its flagship store, the Mavericks announced plans for a new arena district in North Dallas and the Stars said they potentially are headed to Plano.
Article continues below this ad
Mayor Eric Johnson said the “knives are out” for the city amid growing competition from the suburbs. “The wolf is not in this room, the wolf is up the tollway,” he said.
Council member Cara Mendelsohn said the estimates appeared to assume wholesale replacement of building systems rather than fixing specific problems.
Consultants countered that the city’s systems were so complex and dated that they would have to make necessary upgrades to pass regulatory tests.
Currently, the building does not have fire sprinklers above floor one in a seven-storied building. It doesn’t have a smoke evacuation system, and electrical systems like generators are on their last legs.
“I would not even want my code director in the department to actually do a code evaluation of this City Hall in its current state,” Tolbert said, adding that some stairwells effectively function as chimneys during a fire.
Article continues below this ad
Mendelsohn also questioned whether the estimates remained reliable because she said they were based on an earlier facility assessment conducted by the consulting firm AECOM.
Council member Adam Bazaldua said council members are right to closely examine the consultants’ work before deciding the future of City Hall.
Council member Jaime Resendez said the latest estimates largely validated AECOM’s earlier work and that the firm’s projections may have actually understated the cost of repairs.Will Mundinger, one of the new consultants, said the city couldn’t patch their way into modernity.
“If you have a home today and they come in, and you need a loan or purchase, and you have a federal Pacific panel in your house, you can’t get insurance for it,” Mundinger said. “That’s the situation. You can’t repair that, no way.”