Dallas City Hall (right) and its plaza can be seen from Reunion Tower in downtown Dallas, March 19, 2026.
Tom Fox/Dallas Morning News
A lot of us who love Dallas believed that seeing the Mavericks build a new arena in the center of downtown represented the best hope for a massive development win that could have anchored our central city and the region for decades to come.
We believed a development like that could flip the narrative of a fading downtown, create jobs, promote a walkable city and help build prosperity broadly.
That propelled us to encourage city leaders to pursue the opportunity, even at the risk of division over preserving or tearing down a building that some love and some love to hate.
Article continues below this ad
Looking back now, with the Mavericks committed to remaining in Dallas at Valley View, it’s clear the hurdles to keeping the team downtown were just too high.
First, we should say that Valley View will be a great site, and the Mavericks’ ownership has been true to the pledge to stay in the city. That’s laudable.
But a chance to re-envision downtown was so important, it had to be pursued.
City Manager Kimberly Bizor Tolbert was right to do all she could to push the City Council to consider moving out of a badly neglected City Hall. But Tolbert’s efforts, which until recently she seemed to shoulder alone, were probably doomed before they began.
Article continues below this ad
City leaders needed to be prepared years ago, as part of a broader vision for downtown, for what to do when the Mavericks’ lease came up on the American Airlines Center. A lack of vision has been emblematic of council leadership under Mayor Eric Johnson, but the fault is broader than that. No one anticipated what now seems obvious: that a new arena would be demanded, and it couldn’t be where the American Airlines Center stands.
What we got was an 11th-hour scramble with no real vision behind it. The plan to offer up City Hall, under the pretense of it being too expensive to repair, was too little, too late.
A decision of that magnitude required a years-long public discussion. And it required something it never got — city leadership stating out loud that the plan was to trade a building that, yes, has architectural significance for billions of dollars in economic development because that’s what’s best economically for downtown, for Dallas and for North Texas.
We never really got to have that public conversation. Tolbert’s strategy was to focus on the cost of repairing City Hall, a building that no council has invested significantly in for two generations.
That was never going to stir public support. Had there been a clear debate earlier about the economic opportunity versus the preservation of City Hall, the broader public would have been more invested in trading City Hall for an arena and surrounding development.
Article continues below this ad
Now, we need a new vision, both for downtown and Valley View.
The Mavericks’ ownership has given Dallas a great opportunity for the redevelopment of one of the most valuable pieces of vacant land in the city. That’s something to celebrate.
But everyone who cares about this city should think about how all of this came about.
Dallas wasn’t ready when opportunity came because our leadership wasn’t focused on the big picture.
Article continues below this ad
Have thoughts about this? Send a letter to the editor using our letters form or email letters@dallasnews.com. Letters should be no more than 200 words and include the first and last name of the writer and city of residence.