The trial of Anthony, accused of killing Austin Metcalf, is expected to last two weeks. He faces up to life in prison if convicted. He has pleaded not guilty.

MCKINNEY, Texas — The trial of 18-year-old Karmelo Anthony continues today in Collin County, after last year’s fatal stabbing of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during a Frisco ISD track meet. 

Jury selection began Monday, June 1. A jury was seated Wednesday, June 3. Opening statements begin this morning. The trial is expected to last about two weeks. 

New to the case? Watch this overview.

WFAA will stream updates with analysis after the trial each day at 8 p.m. on our free streaming app WFAA+. Here’s how to download it for free. 


Frisco track meet stabbing trial: Timeline of the case

The timeline of the case begins April 2, 2025. See a full timeline of the case here.

Anthony, a former student at Frisco Centennial High School, is charged with murder in the April 2, 2025, killing of Metcalf, a student-athlete at Frisco Memorial High School.

Background: Who is Austin Metcalf? Who is Karmelo Anthony?

Investigators say that morning, at a track meet at Kuykendall Stadium, a confrontation began under a team tent where athletes gathered during inclement weather. It ended when Metcalf was stabbed in the chest. Anthony was arrested and has claimed self-defense.

The case quickly drew intense national attention, fueled by social media debate centered on the races of the two young men, public protests, online threats and allegations of doxxing involving people connected to the proceedings.  

Because Anthony was 17 at the time of the incident, Texas law allows him to be tried as an adult, and he faces a possible sentence ranging from five years to life in prison if convicted. Because the death did not meet the qualifications to be charged as a capital murder, and because of Anthony’s age, the death penalty was never an option in the case. 

Background: An explanation of Anthony’s possible sentence if convicted.


Trial rules

Security at the courthouse will be tight.

Judge John Roach Jr. has banned cameras, livestreams and audio recording inside the courtroom. He also designated a security perimeter around parts of the courthouse grounds barring the public — and potential demonstrators — from gathering in those areas. The judge has also issued a gag order limiting public comments about the case from attorneys, witnesses, investigators and others directly involved in the proceedings. 

With public seating limited, developments in the case will come from live reporting from inside the courtroom. WFAA has a team covering the case. Collin County reporter Jobin Panicker will be inside the courtroom each day, alongside a courtroom sketch artist. Senior crime and justice reporter Rebecca Lopez will also be at the courthouse each day, both in and out of the courtroom, chronicling case developments. WFAA has also arranged for a legal expert to sit in on the proceedings each day to help provide context and analysis on the WFAA+ daily evening wrap-up.

Background: A visual tour of the actual courtroom.

Day One: June 1, 2026 – jury selection begins

Day Two: June 3, 2026 – jury is selected


Day Three: June 4, 2026 – opening statements and testimony begins

Court has ended for the day. Testimony resumes tomorrow morning at 9 a.m.

The state’s next witness is Joshua Rebmann, Liberty High School football coach. 

He was helping at the track meet that day. His school, he said, had two tents ups, one for boys and one for girls. 

Coach Rebmann said he was about 20 feet from the Memorial tent, and didn’t see or hear anything before “he saw kids panicking and scattering.” Kids were running down the aluminum bleachers, he told jurors.

He went over and found Austin Metcalf with his back to the fence, holding his abdomen. Coach Rebmann, who told jurors he had military combat experience, said he took off his jacket and put pressure on the wound and yelled for someone to call 911. Coach Rebmann said he he had to push Metcalf’s brother off of him so he could put pressure on the wound. 

Coach Rebmann described watching Austin Metcalf die as he and others tried to stop the bleeding and perform CPR. Metcalf’s parents cried as they listened to the coach describe their son’s “last breaths.”

Prosecutors played the 911 recording for jurors.

“I need paramedics right away. I have an athlete that was stabbed.” In the background are a confusion of voices, yelling, crying. “Stay with me Austin. Stay with me Austin. Stay with me Austin,” a male voice says on the emergency recording.

Several people in the courtroom audience cried as they listened to the call, grabbing and using tissues. Karmelo Anthony has his head down.

Prosecutor Bill Wirskye shows jurors the jacket that Coach Rebmann used to stop Austin Metcalf’s bleeding. Wirskye put on gloves, opens an evidence bag and pulled the jacket out. It appeared to have blood on it. 

“How much blood was there externally on Austin Metcalf?”  Wirskye asked. “Quite a bit,” the coach told jurors. He testified he did everything he could to save the young man’s life. 

On cross examination, defense lawyer Toby Shook asked the witness if he was aware that Centennial did not have a tent at the track meet that day. He said he was not.

The state’s next witness is Coach Vincent Hooper, track and football coach at Heritage High School.

Asked about track culture and use of the tent, he said “You want your kids in your camp.”

He said after the stabbing, another coach asked him to hold Anthony, so he said he put his arms around him and asked, “What did you do?” Coach Hooper said Anthony answered: “He put his hands on me. I stabbed him.” 

Coach Hooper told Anthony that this could change his entire life if Metcalf died. Hooper testified that Anthony told him: “He’s not going to die.” Metcalf’s mother, who is in the courtroom, began crying. 

Hooper described Metcalf after he had been stabbed: “He was pale white and there was a puddle of blood.” 

Defense lawyer Toby Shook asked Hooper whether he agreed that Anthony genuinely felt upset about the incident. Hooper said he did.

Jobin Panicker reports on the next witness:

The prosecution next called Tiffany Whiteaker, Memorial HS’s athletic trainer.

She told jurors the track tent is “is like a locker room. The visiting team does not go to the home team,” which she called an unwritten rule in track culture. 

She was working the district meet at Kuykendall Stadium in Frisco on April 2, 2026. She said there was a lot of confusion on that day because of the rain. Some athletes were on the field, some were on the bus, some were under the tent. 

At one point, she said she “heard screaming.” She said a student pointed out Anthony as the person involved. She said she told another coach that Anthony “stabbed someone” and to get in front of him to prevent him from walking further. 

Whiteaker testified she tended to Austin Metcalf, performing CPR until paramedics arrived. “I am in autopilot. You just keep going until help arrives,” she told jurors. She said she was not hopeful when she saw the wound. 

Jobin Panicker continues his account of the prosecution’s second witness, track coach Robert Starr:

Starr testified that kids have to sign a code of conduct that includes a prohibition on bringing weapons to a school event. He said kids bringing weapons may happen in some inner city districts. 

He said Memorial was hosting the track meet, and he asked several of his upperclassmen to be “leaders” on that day. He said he sent a text to Austin Metcalf to step up and be a leader that day. 

He said there was no official rain delay during that district meet. 

The coach testified that when he went over to check on the commotion at his team’s tent, “I see Austin on the ground and his face is purple and there’s a big hole in his chest.” 

“Coach, do something!” the coach said Hunter Metcalf told him. He said students pointed to Anthony as he was walking to the track. The coach said he approached Anthony. “He was walking very calmly and I asked him what the hell did you do?” He said Anthony responded, “He put his hands on me.” The coach told jurors he threw his hat and put his hands in the air as he was overcome by frustration and emotion. 

“Everybody was praying,” the coach testified, becoming emotional. During this testimony, Jeff Metcalf is doubled over in his seat and crying quietly, shaking his head as the coach also cries on the stand. “I just knew Austin was gone,” the coach told jurors.

The coach identifies Anthony in the courtroom, saying he looks different now. “He’s clean cut today.”

Coach Starr, who is Black, testified he threatened to kick Austin Metcalf off the track team because he decided to go fishing and leave early from a school event. Starr said he let him back on the team for this district meet because he was a captain of the football team and wanted him to learn a lesson. Prosecutor Bill Wirskye showed a text exchange between the coach and Metcalf. 

“Be a leader” “I’m going to lean on my older guys” “For sure Coach. I gotchu”

The day after the stabbing, the coach said he texted Metcalf’s phone, even though he knew the young man was gone: “Love you man. Sorry I didn’t say enough.” He cried in court as he read the words aloud.

On cross examination, defense attorney Toby Shook asks the coach about track culture. 

Shook asks if buddies ever go and talk to someone in another team’s tent. It’s not common and not part of his team’s policy, the coach answered, because of security, people’s personal belongings, etc. 

The coach testified he did not know that Centennial, Anthony’s school, did not have a tent that day.

Senior crime and justice reporter Rebecca Lopez filed these notes from this morning’s proceedings:

Before the courtroom doors opened Karmelo Anthony’s family and friends formed a circle, held hands and prayed. 

More than 100 people waited to get a seat inside the courtroom but there were only 27 open spots.

Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis sat on the front row.  

“We are here because this young man, Karmelo Anthony, decided to to take a knife to a high school track meet,” Prosecutor Bill Wirskye told jurors during his opening.

“This case has nothing to do with race and it has nothing to do with self defense,” Wirskye said.

Wirskye told the jury Austin Metcalf shoved Anthony and so he launched a “sneak attack.”

He said Anthony goaded Austin when he was asked to leave. “You have to make me.” 

Wirskye said that Austin had only been in the stadium about six minutes when he was stabbed to death. Two minutes after Austin got to the tent, Anthony “enters the picture.” 

Metcalf told Anthony to leave, Anthony said “touch me again and see what happens,” Metcalf “took the bait,” and Anthony “swiftly and suddenly” stabbed him, Wirskye told jurors.

Coaches stopped Anthony, who told them “he touched me, he touched me — as if somehow that fact justifies this act. As if somehow that fact justifies murder,” Wirskye said.

Defense attorney Mike Howard told jurors in his opening that they should “believe less than half of what you see. There is a lot of completely false information.”

He said Anthony, trying to get out of the rain, goes under the other team’s tent because he sees someone he knows and goes to talk to him.

“He doesn’t slip in like some thief in the night,” Howard said, who added that there were about 10-15 students under the tent.

He said Metcalf and his brother “confront” Anthony and tell him to leave. “As long as you don’t touch me we are cool” Howard said his client told the boys.

He said Anthony was seated and Austin was being aggressive.

The prosecution’s next witness is Robert Starr, head track coach for Memorial High School. He’s also the strength and conditioning coach for the football team.

He coached Austin Metcalf and his brother, both linebackers for Memorial.

As prosecutor Bill Wirskye shows jurors pictures of the Metcalf brothers, their mother wipes her eyes. 

Coach Starr told jurors about the importance of these team tents at track meets. He said they are “meant specifically for [students of the school].” 

Wirskye: “Do they have a policy on bringing weapons?” 

Wtiness: “Weapons are not allowed in any shape, form, or fashion.”

Prosecutor Dewey Mitchell ends his examination of the forensic video witness by saying 15 minutes elapsed from the time Austin Metcalf and his twin brother walk into stadium, to the time that Anthony is led away under arrest.

Defense attorney Toby Shook cross examines  Mark Porter. Shook gets Porter to admit that the video doesn’t definitively show know when the argument between Anthony and Metcalf begins or ends.

Porter testifies that there appears to be some shoving on the video. Porter said it is possible the person being pushed may have been sitting down. Porter says it “appears to be a shove,” and when asked by Shook “could it have been a punch?” Porter answers “that’s a possibility.” Porter testified he cannot tell with certainty whether what is shown is a “shove” or a “punch.”

After the incident, the video appears to show Anthony walking on the track. He is met by a coach who has his arms over him in what looks like some form of embrace. It appears Anthony is squatting on the track and grabbing his head. Shook appears to be trying to make the point that Anthony did not run away from the scene and “hide” like the state said he did.

Prosecution witness Mark Porter testified that after the altercation, he believes it is Karmelo Anthony seen “running or perhaps jogging” away from tent. There are two individuals behind what is believed to be Anthony pointing in his direction. Anthony appears to be moving toward the entrance of the stadium.

Jurors appear to be intently watching the videos. Half of the courtroom cannot even see the tv screen facing the jurors. There is only one video screen and it is facing jurors. People on left side of courtroom can see the video play out. The video continues to spotlight Anthony’s movements away from the Memorial tent, to the entrance where he is then met by officers and escorted out by them. 

Once Anthony is arrested and escorted out, the video shows students in uniforms running, some casually walking, and exiting the stadium.  

Prosecutors continued to go over the surveillance videos with their expert for the jury.

None of the videos we’ve seen today show the altercation or the stabbing. The images in the video are not clear because they have to be magnified to see them. Also, it was raining that April day in 2025, and there are people walking and holding umbrellas as they cross the tent at the bottom of the bleachers.

Prosecutor Dewey Mitchell appears to be trying to establish how much time elapses from the time Austin Metcalf and his twin brother enter stadium and reach their team’s tent until the altercation. 

Prosecutor Dewey Mitchell showed jurors zoomed-in video from the stadium from the day of the stabbing last year. It shows the yellow Memorial HS tent, and figures under the tent. 

Mitchell and witness Mark Porter take jurors frame by frame, showing Metcalf enter the tent at 9:54 a.m. A few minutes later in the video,  Porter testifies that “it appears one person pushes” another, but it’s unclear who is shown. Someone can then seen running down the bleachers.

In another video from another camera, Metcalf and his twin brother are walking into the stadium. Jeff Metcalf, their father, has his head down, not watching. Their mother, though, appears to be watching.

Another video shown to jurors appears to show an individual getting handcuffed by an officer. Someone is shown dropping to their knees, and what appears to be staff running in and out of frame directing people with their hands. 

The judge then called a lunch break. 

Our photographers and reporters who have been at the courthouse since before dawn today report relatively little activity from demonstrators in the parking lot. 

There is a noticeable increase in security outside, they said. Two sheriff’s deputies on motorcycles are present and at least three sheriff’s vehicles are there, up from approximately one each earlier this week. 

A McKinney pastor was there this morning with a sign that said “free hugs and prayers.” He hugged and prayed with people. He said he comes out here every Thursday to pray for people going to court. He was also blowing a horn and speaking in tongues.

Witness Mark Porter testified about his analysis of the surveillance video from the track meet where Metcalf died.

There were five different videos. Prosecutors showed the first video to the jurors and courtroom. It’s a wide shot of the football stadium with only half of the field visible. It’s difficult to see, and Porter said he worked on magnification to help state review this video. 

One still images appears to show Anthony handcuffed and walking with two officers.

Now that opening statements are over, Jobin Panicker reported on how everyone was arranged in the courtroom for the start of witness testimony.

There are between 8 and 10 teenagers in the courtroom, the rest are adults. There are four rows of seats in the gallery. The media is in the fourth and back row. Pat Lopez, the sketch artist, is in the first row. WFAA’s Rebecca Lopez is in the second row. The Metcalf and Anthony families are in second row but in opposite sides of the courtroom.

Prosecutors called their first witness, Mark Porter, a forensic video analyst with the Tarrant County District Attorney’s office. Prosecutor Dewey Mitchell is questioning him.

Defense attorney Mike Howard then gave his opening statement to jurors.

“There’s been a lot of noise around this case,” Howard said. “A lot of completely false information.”

Referring to Anthony by his nickname “Melo,” he described his client as “a son. He is a brother, the oldest of four. He is a friend, boyfriend, a student who graduated with a 3.7 GPA while holding two jobs, playing football, track…” 

Howard told jurors that Anthony’s father works as a finance manager with a car dealership, and that his mother is a nurse. They are from Baton Rouge, LA, Howard said. “They wanted their family to have a better life. That’s why they came to DFW middle of freshman year,” Howard told jurors. “They came to Frisco for that better life.”

Howard described what happened on April 2, 2025 at the Frisco ISD stadium.

Every team at the track meet had a tent, except for Anthony’s school Centennial, which only had a tarp. “Melo is in a normal mood. He is relaxing with his teammates,” Howard told the jury. 

As the weather turns bad, “Melo goes to look for a place to get out of the rain,” and goes to the Memorial HS tent where Metcalf is. Howard told jurors they video they will see establishes some things but will not show everything. “Melo walks out and sees someone he recognizes” from Memorial HS, Howard said. The two were talking and “everything seemed fine,” Howard said. “Everyone there (under tent) except for Melo is from Memorial,” Howard said. 

Howard told jurors that Austin and his twin brother, Hunter, confronted Anthony, who is 5’8 and about 130 pounds.  Howard said that Metcalf and his brother are 6’1 and about 213 pounds, which is about 83 pounds heavier than his client.

Howard said Anthony told them “as long as you don’t touch me, we’re cool.” Howard said Austin Metcalf said, I know you don’t got anything in that bag.

“Austin (Metcalf) makes the first physical contact,” Howard told jurors. “Austin grabs, shoves, pushes” Anthony, the defense lawyer said. Jeff Metcalf, Austin Metcalf’s father, shook his head when Howard said this.

Howard said Anthony was forced to decide with what to do “in fear and chaos.” “After Anthony defended himself, he ran,” Howard told jurors. He dropped the knife by the bleachers, Howard said. “He left it right by the tent.” Howard said Anthony fell as he was going down the bleachers. Howard said prosecutors contention that Anthony was “slipping away” was wrong. Anthony went directly to a coach, Howard told jurors.

Prosecutors have made several pretrial motions for the judge to consider. The defense has not objected.

Everyone in the courtroom rose as the jury entered the courtroom and took their seats. 

Each side is allotted 20 minutes for opening statements. 

First Assistant District Attorney Bill Wirskye began for the prosecution.

“He plunged a knife into his heart and ran away,” Wirskye tells jurors describing what he says Anthony did to Austin Metcalf. Wirskye called the killing “an unjustified, provoked murder.”

“This case is not self-defense,” he said. “This was simply senseless.”  

Wirskye told jurors they would see surveillance video, and “that video tells the story.” He references words witnesses claim Anthony said before Metcalf was stabbed: “Touch me, see what happens.” Wirskye argues that Anthony provoked and goaded Metcalf into “touching him.” 

“This is an provoked, unjustified murder,” Wirskye said. “This killing is senseless.”

At one point, Wirskye points to Anthony, who at the time was a student at Frisco Centennial High School, attending a track meet at Metcalf’s Frisco Memorial High School. “This man,” Wirskye told jurors, made a “bee line” for the Memorial tent. Several memorial athletes told Anthony to leave, Wirskye said. The tent, he said, was their “locker room.” Wirskye said Anthony goaded and taunted and provoked Metcalf. Wirskye said Anthony produced a knife and “swiftly and plunged it into Austin.” Wirskye said Anthony than ran off and tried to “blend in.” Wirskye told jurors that students at the track meet pointed out Anthony as he “is trying to leave the track meet.”

Wirksye told jurors that when an officer who arrived on scene encountered Anthony, he radioed “I have the alleged suspect.” Wirskye said the officer reported that Anthony then told him, “I am not alleged, I did it.” 

Anthony also allegedly told the officer “he touched me first and I told him not to,” according to Wirskye. He told jurors tossed the knife and “tried to slip away from the scene.” He told jurors they will see video from the scene and that they will hear from the witnesses. 

“You cannot provoke someone and produce a knife and take a life,” Wirskye said.

Good morning. Opening statements are set to begin at 9 a.m.

Jobin Panicker, one of our reporter’s inside the 296th courtroom, filed this report a few minutes ago:

Austin Metcalf’s parents Jeff and Meghan are in the courtroom. Karmelo Anthony’s parents Andrew Anthony and Kala Hayes are also here. Sketch artist Pat Lopez is in the front row. There are more than 200 people waiting to get inside this courtroom. The 27 spots for the public filled up ten minutes after curfew lifted.

The courtroom is nearly full. The public is seated. The prosecution and defense are present. Collin County Sheriff Jim Skinner is now in the courtroom. Karmelo Anthony is the courtroom. He is wearing a suit.

Members of the public who get a seat inside the crowded courtroom are issued lanyards. Court staff made an announcement that any member of the public who leaves should drop their lanyard off so that the next person waiting in line can then get a spot inside.