Houston Police Chief Noe Diaz and Mayor John Whitmire have done little to rein in overtime spending.
Brett Coomer/Houston Chronicle
For all of John Whitmire’s focus on belt-tightening and slashing “waste, fraud and corruption” from city government, at least one agency is routinely exempt from his fiscal responsibility edict: the Houston Police Department.
Under Whitmire’s watch, HPD’s operating budget has ballooned to more than $1 billion, and his proposed budget would boost their funding by another $100 million in the next fiscal year. Last year, Whitmire negotiated a new contract with HPD officers giving them 36.5% raises that will cost the city $832 million over five years.
And that’s just the money we know taxpayers will spend on HPD. We won’t know until a year from now how many millions of extra dollars the department will spend on overtime.
Article continues below this ad
HPD, along with the city’s fire and solid waste departments, routinely blow past what they budget for overtime. In 2025, these three agencies spent a combined $134 million on overtime, which is $71 million more than what was budgeted for. The police department was the worst offender. Its adopted budget accounted for $13 million in overtime spending. It ended the fiscal year having spent nearly $40 million on overtime. City Controller Chris Hollins found that the ten highest overtime earners in the police department essentially doubled their income.
Last year wasn’t some sort of outlier. This year Hollins projected the city would again blow past its overtime budget by $54 million. Every year, Houston struggles to balance its budget in part because it seemingly lets officers write their own checks for overtime hours, without consistent record-keeping on what officers are doing with their extra time.
It’s all well and good for Whitmire to boast that police staffing is at a 20-year high, and claim that directly correlates with a 36% decline in violent crime so far this year. Though the drop likely has multiple causes, we’ll take the win. But why haven’t all those extra officers led to fewer overtime hours?
We’ve credited the mayor for finally taking real steps in the proposed budget towards eliminating structural deficits and establishing new revenue streams. But if that extra cash ends up subsidizing unregulated overtime for police, that’s a poor return on investment for taxpayers.
Article continues below this ad
Whitmire has defended overtime spending as “kind of a norm” – a byproduct of living in a major city with lots of activities, natural disasters and events that require a police presence. On an April episode of his podcast, Whitmire rattled off several major events, from “pop-up protests” to the World Baseball Classic that required extra policing.
“Most of the criticism came from critics who don’t want to look at reality,” Whitmire said. “If they want to defund police, which is what we’re talking about, they can be critical. But I’m very comfortable giving fire and police the resources they need to make not only Houstonians safe, but people that travel to our great city. So it’s working.”
Whitmire’s “defund the police” retort is emblematic of how politically loaded it’s become in Texas to even dare raise an eyebrow at soaring police budgets. Increases in government spending in areas such as public education are frowned upon by conservatives, yet it’s become political orthodoxy for elected officials in both parties that police spending is sacrosanct.
Whitmire has argued that showering the cops with cash and raises are what’s driving improved morale in the department. Indeed, every Houstonian should want a police department that attracts the best and brightest. But do we really need to include language in the police contract that gives officers even more guaranteed overtime?
HPD already has trouble explaining how officers are spending their time. A Chronicle analysis of overtime spending from 2020 through 2025 found that a relatively small group of 129 officers took home a combined $37 million, with some collecting between $316,000 and $712,000 in overtime pay during that five-year period. These aren’t homicide detectives working high-profile cases. The officer who raked in $712,000 did so by picking up extra shifts escorting crime victims to court and working security at Covid testing sites, among other routine duties.
Article continues below this ad
Even more alarming is that an audit from 2022 found that HPD divisions record overtime differently and don’t share data with each other. At best these breakdowns reflect poor clerical work, but it could be malfeasance. Police officers do some of the toughest, most important jobs in our city, and Houstonians shouldn’t have to worry that bad actors in blue are borrowing accounting practices from white collar crooks. That HPD didn’t respond to the Chronicle’s request for comment on its analysis and the internal audit suggests that accountability and transparency is lacking.
The audit made several recommendations, including establishing uniform systems for logging overtime and ensuring that supervisors and officers are filing overtime slips with accurate information. At minimum, the city could also stop under-budgeting for overtime spending. These kinds of inaccuracies are inexcusable when natural disasters should be anticipated given our geography and we know well in advance when we’re hosting major events such as the World Cup.
The public has a right to know how officers are spending their time. Having more officers on the payroll should enable the department to be more efficient with officers’ time. But that requires a concerted top-down edict from Whitmire and Chief Noe Diaz to stop wasting money. A $1.2 billion budget should be more than enough to deliver positive public safety outcomes without officers raking in additional cash on the taxpayers’ dime.
As the city nears the end of its budget negotiations, we hope City Council members will hold Whitmire and HPD’s feet to the fire on costs before voting for it. The city is finally moving in the right direction on reducing the deficit. It would be a shame to sully those efforts by continuing to hand a blank check to the police department for overtime.
Article continues below this ad