SAN ANTONIO – The city and SAWS abandoned plans to relocate the water chilling plant downtown to make room for a new convention center hotel.
As we previously reported, a consultant found moving the plant would cost more than $300 million.
But now they have to figure out how to air condition the new Spurs arena and other Project Marvel buildings.
Now SAWS is looking at building a smaller, satellite chiller station to help air condition the new Spurs arena, like the one that sits next to the Alamodome. It would be less expensive than relocating the main chiller station as originally planned.
For decades that main chiller station has provided chilled water to large downtown buildings.
The water is pumped through underground pipes, which is more efficient than having the convention center, Alamodome and downtown hotels each install their own air conditioning systems.
“We feel like the chilled water solution is much easier, we centralize everything, it’s cheaper for them, and we maintain everything,” said Jaime Castillo of SAWS.
A feasibility study by Jacobs Engineering estimates the new Spurs arena could require between three to five thousand tons of chilled water at peak times.
But the main chiller station only has the available capacity to provide about four thousand tons.
So, the engineering firm is studying whether SAWS should try to expand the output of the main plant or build a satellite plant near the arena site.
“Who pays for these changes to the chiller system?” asked the News 4 I-Team’s Jaie Avila.
“Soley the customers of our chilled water business. Our water and wastewater business are separate from our chilled water business, so, the rate increase talks that are going on about our water and wastewater side have nothing to do with this,” Castillo said.
When city leaders first unveiled plans for a Downtown Sports and Entertainment District, they included a one thousand room hotel on the site where the main chiller plant now sits.
The city says dropping that idea will not impact how the other components of the district are funded.
Critics have said there was never enough demand for more hotel rooms anyway and that the chiller plant episode proves local leaders are moving too fast and should have waited for studies to be completed.
“It’s not clear that the city and the city staff did really in depth planning on all of the components of Project Marvel,” said UTSA Professor Emeritus Heywood Sanders.
SAWS is paying Jacobs Engineering $2.3 million for the feasibility study, but they say only $900,000 of that went to study relocating the chiller plant and the rest is left to study other options.