An exterior view of Dallas City Hall at sunset in downtown Dallas, November 4, 2025.

An exterior view of Dallas City Hall at sunset in downtown Dallas, November 4, 2025.

Tom Fox/Dallas Morning News

The Dallas City Council has a monumental decision to make this week. 

Should City Hall remain at 1500 Marilla St. or move elsewhere, making way for the demolition of I.M. Pei’s important, if divisive, building?

A few things bear saying as we consider our opinion on this difficult question.

Article continues below this ad

First, we can think of no city that would have approached a decision of this importance the way Dallas has. There should be accountability for what has happened. 

Second, City Hall does have massive maintenance needs that cannot be ignored as they have been, irresponsibly, for decades.

Third, the way city leadership has represented the cost and timeline of repairing the building appears heavily weighted toward leaving City Hall.

Fourth, there is no clear opportunity presented to the public for what to do with the building should the city abandon the site. 

Article continues below this ad

The first problem is how we got here. No one should pretend this decision would have been so urgent had it not been for the opportunity to build a new Dallas Mavericks arena where City Hall now stands. That’s the part you aren’t supposed to say out loud at City Hall, but it’s the truth. That opportunity should have been discussed years ago, not on a timeline of months and in a shroud of secrecy. 

We have said from the beginning that the chance to keep the Mavericks downtown was so important that it was worth considering trading City Hall for an arena and ancillary development. That would have represented an instant economic revival at a time when corporations are leaving the central business district. It would have created jobs close to southern Dallas and reaped a host of other benefits.

But that opportunity was never clearly identified, either by city leadership or the Mavericks. It was the elephant in the room we couldn’t name. Had it been public, we believe it would have had widespread support. 

The Mavericks have now announced they are heading to Valley View. We are sad to see the downtown opportunity go, even as we are eager to see an amazing development take shape on one of Dallas’ most important pieces of vacant land.

Absent what seems like a distant chance to revive the Mavericks opportunity, it’s not clear why there is still so much urgency over holding a vote on leaving City Hall. 

Article continues below this ad

The council is set to vote to authorize City Manager Kimberly Bizor Tolbert to negotiate a deal for a new site for City Hall. (A second vote would authorize moving 911 and other emergency services. We urge all council members to vote in favor of that; 911 workers toil in a dank basement that isn’t secure for their work.) 
 
We cannot, however, endorse a plan to move all city workers from City Hall absent a real opportunity for what happens next. That risks leaving an empty and undevelopable hulk of a building squatting in the center of downtown. Just keeping it secure would cost millions even as the vacant building repelled development around it. And that’s to say nothing of the tens of millions in rent the city would pay as City Hall sat. 

Unless the public is made aware of a real development opportunity for the City Hall site, abandoning the building would be irresponsible. 

That brings us to the second problem: fixing City Hall. Opponents of moving on from City Hall have been dismissive of repair estimates for the building. Reputable firms like AECOM have been insulted for supposedly being part of some teardown conspiracy where the costs of repairs are falsely inflated.

Fixing City Hall will take hundreds of millions of dollars the city doesn’t have. That has been confirmed now by multiple reputable estimates. Its major systems are antiquated. Its electrical system is genuinely dangerous. There are leaks just about everywhere. From the roof to the sub-sub-basement, there are problems. The building’s formed concrete structure only makes those repairs more complex and expensive.

A decision to remain in City Hall is a decision to commit massive city resources over a long period of time. And even then, the building itself — because of its unusual architecture — all but ensures maintenance will always be difficult and costly. 

Article continues below this ad

A majority of the council rejected a phased repair plan for the building last week. That rejection paved the way for leaving the building. We hope the council will consider a third option: if there is no opportunity for redevelopment of the site, city workers should remain at City Hall with a longer-term repair plan that would ease costs over time.

We don’t believe the plan Tolbert’s team presented fairly represented all options for remaining in City Hall. 

A 59-page repair briefing released last week laid out what we read as a doomsday scenario for repairs. The details are technical, but they ranged from raising the property tax rate by 6.9 cents or cutting parks, libraries and arts services by 86%. There was also the idea of floating pension obligation bonds, which are like the payday lending of municipalities. 

Yes, City Hall is broken. But it’s been broken for a long time, and repairing it over a long time need not bankrupt the city. That scenario wasn’t offered by city management. 

So how should the council vote? 

Article continues below this ad

We think the best vote is this: Support moving 911 and other emergency operations. Oppose authorizing Tolbert to seek a new space to move for all city workers.

If a real development opportunity materializes that would boost downtown, come back and vote to leave with the public informed about what that opportunity is. Meanwhile, the city manager should also be instructed to return to council with a longer-range repair plan for major systems. 

We want the ability to pursue new opportunities for the City Hall site. If, somehow, that still included an arena, so much the better. But we also must be good fiscal stewards of this city’s assets.

And right now, given what we know, remaining in City Hall is the right call.

Article continues below this ad

Have thoughts about this? Send a letter to the editor using our letters form or email letters@dallasnews.com. Letters should be no more than 200 words and include the first and last name of the writer and city of residence.