SAN ANTONIO — Members of San Antonio’s Jewish community, along with civic and interfaith leaders, are calling on city officials and Alamodome management to decline use of the taxpayer-supported venue for a scheduled July 4 concert by Ye (Kanye West).
City leaders, including Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones, alongside Jewish community leaders gathered at press conference Tuesday at the Holocaust Memorial Museum of San Antonio.
City leaders have said they are concerned about Ye’s past statements and believe Military City USA should not host him in a city-funded facility. At the same time, city leaders have said they cannot cancel the Fourth of July concert without risking a First Amendment violation.
RELATED: POLL: Should city leaders cancel concerts over a performer’s personal statement?
Mayor Jones said the city does not have the votes needed to stop the show.
“Not all money is good money,” the mayor said during the news conference.
Mayor Jones said canceling the concert would require a public vote by City Council, but support is not there. “The only way to cancel this concert is to have a public vote, and we don’t have the votes. We don’t have the votes,” he said.
In a joint statement, council members Teri Castillo, Jalen McKee-Rodriguez, Misty Spears, Marc Whyte, Sukh Kaur, and Marina Alderete Gavito Conde condemned antisemitism and hate, but argued canceling the concert would be censorship. They pointed to a projected $1.7 million economic impact and gains for San Antonio workers and businesses.
Mayor Jones questioned what message the city sends by allowing the concert to proceed. “I think there is a responsibility as leaders for us to be thoughtful about, what message are we sending as a result of allowing this to happen? When some people’s best argument is it’s going to be good for the small businesses.,” he said.
With the show expected to move forward, leaders shifted their focus to what happens next, including a review of how events are booked at the Alamodome. The chief executive officer of the Jewish Federation of San Antonio said, “The city and the Alamodome must undertake a serious review of the policies, procedures, and standards that allow the publicly funded venue to book a performer who has repeatedly profited from hate speech and division,”
The city said the Alamodome reviews events based on factors including demand, economic impact and tourism, and estimated more than 60,000 people will attend Ye’s concert.
Bexar County Commissioner Grant Moody said the issue goes beyond attendance. “Kanye West has the right to free speech. Yes, he does, but I have an obligation to denounce his outrageous and hate-filled rants,” he said.
Mayor Jones echoed her sentiments on social media, citing concerns for the location of the concert at the city-funded Alamodome.
“When we are thinking and using the people’s resources… I think it’s extremely important that we are much more thoughtful about the message that we send when we invest their time, their energy, their resources into providing somebody a platform who has years worth, years worth of hate speech and anti-Semitic rhetoric as an Air Force, and as an Iraq War veteran, I understand the importance of the First Amendment,” Mayor Jones said.
Statements sent from city councilmembers, including District 9 Councilwoman Misty Spears and District 10 Councilman Marc K. Whyte, condemned Ye’s antisemitic remarks.
“Ye’s anti-Semitism isn’t a matter of interpretation. He said what he said, sold what he sold, and no apology changes that record, San Antonio is one of the most diverse and patriotic cities in this country. It’s home to one of the largest military communities in the world. Families of every background and a Jewish community that deserves to know their elected leaders support them,” Whyte’s statement read in part.
Councilwoman Spears emphasized the importance of protecting San Antonio’s Jewish community saying in part, “District nine is home to a robust Jewish community, and I will always ensure their safety and well-being is valued and protected. Let me be clear, anti-Semitism is evil, it’s hateful, divisive, and has no place in our community.”
State Sen. José Menéndez and Bexar County Commissioner Grant Moody were also in attendance.
City and faith leaders said they want transparency and accountability, and that the broader goal is ensuring San Antonio does not become a platform for hate.
A statement written by City Council says:
We strongly condemn antisemitism, hate, and any ideology that seeks to divide or intimidate members of our community. Many residents have expressed legitimate concerns about Ye’s scheduled July 4th concert, and we take those concerns seriously. We can condemn hate without resorting to censorship, which could set a precedent toward limiting expression based on objectionable viewpoints. The City does not endorse his rhetoric by allowing use of a public venue, just as a public library does not endorse every book’s viewpoint simply by carrying it. This event also matters economically. It is projected to generate roughly $1.7 million for the Alamodome, and hotel reservations are already up 22% since the concert was announced meaning real benefits for our local businesses, restaurants, and workers. These considerations do not diminish our opposition to hate in any form. We remain committed to ensuring that all communities feel welcome and safe in our city. San Antonio stands united against antisemitism and all forms of hatred, and we remain committed to fostering a community where everyone feels safe, welcome, and respected.