A 12-year-old Dallas middle-schooler ended up on the streets where a pimp discovered her. For as little as $50, he sold her for sex. He withheld food unless she worked. She later disappeared into the state’s foster care system after suffering from depression. She attempted suicide.

A 13-year-old seventh- grader was forced to have sex with men in Houston by a pimp who hooked her on drugs. She died shortly after turning 18 from a fentanyl overdose — a few months before her abuser was sentenced to prison.

A 17-year-old Lubbock runaway was required to have sex with men in hotels and truck stops until she earned her pimp $1,000 daily. That quota meant seeing up to 20 “clients” per day. She spiraled into drug addiction.

These children have more in common than the abuse they endured — and the lifelong trauma that comes with it. Each was mandated by federal law to receive financial compensation from the pimps and pedophiles who abused them.

Article continues below this ad

Like the vast majority of survivors of childhood sexual abuse, they never received a dime. A Dallas Morning News investigation reveals that from 2015 to 2024, only 21% of federal child sex trafficking cases nationwide resulted in an order of restitution — and no place in the U.S. has more uncompensated victims than the Dallas-Fort Worth region.

The News’ analysis of federal data shows that in only 6% of such cases in the Northern District of Texas — 11 cases out of 184 — were abusers ordered to provide restitution to the children they abused. That is the lowest restitution rate over the past decade among U.S. federal districts with 100 or more child sex trafficking cases.

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

Article continues below this ad

In Texas, comparable restitution data is not available for child human trafficking cases prosecuted by the state because no one keeps track. Most sex trafficking cases are prosecuted in state courts. The News could not find a single state criminal case in Dallas in which a convicted sex trafficker was ordered to pay restitution to their child victim, after searching news releases, news reports, district attorney annual reports, and other material.

The low restitution rate is particularly troubling because the Northern District of Texas, which includes Dallas, leads the nation in the number of child sex trafficking cases over the past decade.

Most of the North Texas federal sex trafficking victims were young, according to federal sentencing data. Cases with child victims made up 85% of all such cases filed in North Texas during the past decade.

Many sex traffickers rape their victims as punishment and also use them to make pornographic images, sometimes for commercial sex advertisements. As a result, child sex traffickers can also face federal child pornography charges — another charge that mandates restitution that is rarely ordered.

Article continues below this ad

For its yearlong investigation, The News examined hundreds of cases filed in federal and state courts in Texas since 2010, as well as data kept by the U.S. Sentencing Commission, which tracks nationwide sentencing trends in federal criminal cases. The News also interviewed more than 60 people, including victims, victim advocates, lawyers, judges and former prosecutors.

The News’ investigation revealed a number of factors that explain why the system so often fails to make good on its promise to childhood sexual abuse survivors:

Sex trafficking victims rarely have a legal advocate and often are not aware of their right to restitution. Instead, the system relies heavily on federal and local prosecutors to pursue restitution — and they represent the government, not the survivors.

Although restitution is mandated by law, there are no consequences for ignoring that law, and enforcement is left to individual judges.

The government has a vast array of powerful tools to force criminals to pay restitution — especially in federal cases — but those resources are far more likely to be used to benefit the victims of financial crimes, such as fraud or identity theft, than sexual crimes. This is especially so when the victim is a government agency such as the IRS.

Article continues below this ad

Because prosecutors represent the government, when confronted with abusers with deep pockets and assets, they often seize those assets for the benefit of law enforcement, not survivors.

Prosecutors often assume abusers have no means to provide restitution without taking into consideration future wages or financial windfall.

Federal judges, in failing to order restitution for sex trafficking victims, cite various reasons including that it was not applicable or not requested – despite its mandatory nature.

“It’s not acceptable. As in so many things right now, they’re not following the law. And there’s no accountability for it,” said Jean Bruggeman, co-executive director of Freedom Network USA, a national coalition of human trafficking service providers and advocates based in Washington, D.C.

Bruggeman said the low restitution numbers for trafficking survivors illustrate how the criminal justice system was not designed to serve survivors.

Article continues below this ad

“It’s not built for that,” she said. “It’s about what’s good for the state.”

Some trafficking survivors rely on the promise of restitution, Bruggeman said. They give testimony to support criminal investigations and prosecutions.

“They go through this grueling process. Only for nothing,” she said. “It’s almost worse to have this false promise. It’s such a betrayal.”

Some in Congress want to change that.

“Unfortunately, victims of human trafficking have been historically underserved by our judicial system,” said U.S. Rep Chris Smith of New Jersey, in a statement about The News’ findings. “Trafficking survivors need Congress’ support and oversight to ensure that the law is being correctly interpreted and applied by the courts.”

Article continues below this ad

Smith authored the original landmark 2000 human trafficking legislation that made restitution mandatory. He introduced a new bill last year to “address the many injustices endured by survivors of human trafficking — especially and including the lacking victim restitution in sex trafficking cases.”

The Frederick Douglass Trafficking Victims Prevention and Protection Reauthorization Act of 2025 would, among other things, provide $31 million annually to the Department of Health and Human Services up to 2029 to pay for benefits and services to trafficking victims, according to the Congressional Budget Office.

The bill has stalled in the House of Representatives.

Two teens, two moms, no restitution

Two Texas mothers whose teen daughters were trafficked understand what can happen when young survivors are left without the resources to lift themselves out of destitution and despair.

The News does not identify victims of sexual assault.

“She’ll never have a normal life again,” said the mother of the Lubbock teen who was trafficked in Dallas and across the state. “We didn’t get any help.”

Her daughter descended into drug addiction, petty crime and poverty.

Now 28, the daughter is a single mother working multiple jobs to survive. She said in an interview with The News that she didn’t know she was entitled to restitution. No one asked her.

“I should have got at least something, some help,” she told The News, “and I didn’t.”

She described how her abuser drove her on cross-country road trips while forcing her to have sex with men, she says. Along the way, he would make her find customers at truck stops.

“I’m really traumatized, even to this day. I cannot go to a truck stop,” she said. “I will run out of gas before going to a truck stop.”

Tanja Spottswood speaks with investigative reporter Kevin Krause in The Dallas Morning News newsroom, Thursday, Feb. 26, 2026, in Dallas.

Tanja Spottswood speaks with investigative reporter Kevin Krause in The Dallas Morning News newsroom, Thursday, Feb. 26, 2026, in Dallas.

Elias Valverde II/Dallas Morning News

Tanja Spottswood, the mother of the Houston girl who was trafficked beginning at age 13, said she and her family burned through their savings to try to get her counseling and substance abuse treatment.

“I was trying to save my daughter’s life. That was my priority,” she said. “I want some kind of justice. My family has not had closure.”

Spottswood said the detective in the case mentioned compensation at one point, as did the prosecutor, but that “nothing ever came of it.”

“We spent a lot of money, and we would do it again. And probably spend more if we could have Madison,” she said. “Anything would have been better than nothing.”

Madison died from an overdose at age 18. Her mother said she doesn’t want her daughter to be another anonymous victim. She wants her memory and name to live on and serve as a warning.

“She was my baby and I don’t have her anymore…I’m heartbroken and it’s never going to change,” she said. “It’s a slap in the face.”

The two girls’ convicted sex traffickers are seemingly capable of earning money at some point to pay restitution. The man who trafficked the Lubbock teen is already out of prison. Neither was forced to compensate their victims for the harm they caused.

Three attempts to reach U.S. Attorney Ryan Raybould in Dallas by phone and email were unsuccessful.

At a restitution rate of just 6%, his district is an outlier, but few districts in the U.S. are especially successful in compensating victims of child sex trafficking. The News’ analysis reveals that just eight judicial districts in the nation had a restitution rate of over 50% from 2015 to 2024. And just a few excelled in awarding restitution.

Still, there are exceptions that suggest restitution can be made. In the Northern District of California, based in San Francisco, the restitution rate is 75%. In the Northern District of Illinois, based in Chicago, it’s 77%.

And then there is the Middle District of Alabama. This federal district, based in Montgomery, had the nation’s highest rate of restitution for child sex trafficking victims at 83%.

“It goes to the mandate that we gave the prosecutors to always seek restitution,” said Louis Franklin, who served as U.S. attorney from 2017 to 2021 after working in the office for three decades. “The judges were on board with granting that. It was just a matter of making sure we were asking for it.”

Scott Jones, an emergency medicine physician at the University of Virginia and a former federal prosecutor, called the low restitution rates in Dallas and across much of the nation “morally wrong.”

Jones said it is particularly important for children to receive restitution from their abusers — many of whom have the means to provide compensation. Justice Department officials say sex trafficking is among the three most profitable crimes in the U.S.

Jones noted studies indicate childhood trauma shortens life expectancy. Cancer and heart disease rates go up — perhaps, he said, as the result of stress response. For those who can afford it, many require decades of counseling. Child sexual victims often spiral into substance addiction and are at greater risk of dropping out of school and becoming homeless.

The government is well aware.

“Financial restitution may be the most important aspect of justice for some victims,” the DOJ said in a 2023 report to Congress on child sexual exploitation. “Many of these victims will find themselves penniless and in need of medical and mental health care, adequate and safe housing, job training, and other resources.”

Bianca Davis, CEO of New Friends New Life, a Dallas-based nonprofit that helps sex trafficking victims, said restitution is important beyond its financial support.

“It is evidence that they are believed and heard,” she said, “more than it is the dollar amount.”

It’s not just the survivors who lose out when restitution is not provided.

When criminals don’t pay, taxpayers do. Child victims often become wards of the state after support from local charities is exhausted. A 2016 study by the Institute on Domestic Violence & Sexual Assault at the University of Texas at Austin found “minor and youth sex trafficking” cost the state about $6.6 billion.

How the process works

“

“He bullied and manipulated women into selling their bodies for him…taking the money they earned from these encounters. He threatened me as well as physically, mentally, and emotionally abused me into helping him despite me begging him to stop.”

— Trafficking victim’s statement read aloud at 2017 Dallas sentencing.

Children are especially vulnerable and among the most sympathetic victims. To understand why so few receive the restitution that law requires, it’s helpful to understand how the system is supposed to work.

Child sex trafficking is both a federal and state crime — and charges can be filed in federal or state court, or both. Typically, though not always, federal prosecutors focus on the most egregious cases. Those convicted on federal charges face much stiffer sentences such as 20 years to life. Also, probation is not an option in federal court.

Regardless of who brings the charges, victims are entitled to compensation.

The Trafficking Victims Protection Act of 2000 states that restitution is mandatory and shall be ordered in every federal sex trafficking and labor trafficking case involving child or adult victims, regardless of the offender’s ability to pay.

Texas in 2003 became one of the first two states in the nation to pass a human trafficking law. Article 42 in the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure states restitution is mandatory for child sex trafficking victims. The law says the court “shall order” a convicted sex trafficker to pay restitution for “the cost of necessary rehabilitation, including medical, psychiatric, and psychological care and treatment.”

Congress beginning in 2000 recognized, Bruggeman said, what sets apart trafficking from sexual assault is the financial element.

“People are being forced to engage in work for which they are not being compensated. And someone is making money off it. And we should reroute that financial benefit to the victims,” she said. “Theoretically, this [restitution] rights a wrong. This is a form of justice. And yet even when we write it into the law, it doesn’t happen.”

Under federal and Texas law, the requirement to seek restitution falls to the prosecutor, who is expected to consult with victims and detail their losses. Prosecutors also are responsible for asking judges to order restitution.

In federal cases, prosecutors are expected to meet with victim advocates in the U.S. Attorney’s office.

As part of the process, victims — or a surviving family member in the event the victim has died — are supposed to be asked to complete an impact statement and to detail their losses.

Covered losses include lost income, counseling, medical and mental health expenses (current and future), transportation, temporary housing, childcare and funeral costs.

The value of the victim’s forced services or labor while trafficked also is covered. In other words, victims are entitled to the money they were forced to earn for their pimps.

The prosecutor is supposed to present evidence of loss to a judge. The judge considers the request and will sometimes, though rarely in North Texas, hold a restitution hearing. The judge then makes a determination that becomes part of the convicted trafficker’s sentence.

The judge has discretion over how much restitution is awarded. It is based on the victim’s statement of loss as well as other case evidence, including cellphone and bank records that document transactions.

No victim statement is required. Victims do not even have to be aware of the process or cooperate. The law doesn’t say what should happen if a victim doesn’t request it, but DOJ literature indicates prosecutors should seek restitution at sentencing even if the victim is silent on the issue. A 2018 survey of sex trafficking survivors said most want restitution.

Offenders send payments to the Clerk of the Court, which then forwards the money to the survivors. It’s not clear if that part of the process is effectively communicated to survivors. Some young sex trafficking survivors contacted by The News were under the mistaken impression their abuser could use restitution payments to track their current and future whereabouts.

Dallas County District Attorney spokeswoman Claire Crouch acknowledged her office does not typically pursue restitution in sex trafficking cases.

“Our primary focus is on securing prison sentences. In those circumstances, defendants generally do not have the ability to earn income to pay restitution, making it largely a formality,” she said in a statement. “It can be difficult to quantify and assign a dollar amount to losses such as lost wages or other damages in these cases.”

Cara Foos Pierce worked as a federal prosecutor in Dallas from 2008 to 2020 and was the office’s human trafficking coordinator. She also acknowledged prosecutors rarely sought restitution — and provided some insight into why.

For one, she said it was often difficult to identify a sex trafficker’s assets. They don’t leave a paper trail like those who commit fraud. They operate a cash business, she said.

“It’s hard to track it,” Pierce said. “They didn’t use bank accounts.”

She said she didn’t seek restitution in cases with no assets, “especially if the defendant was facing a long sentence.” Pierce said she could tell what street pimps were spending their money on by looking at the photos they posted on social media, like diamond watches and cars. If the car wasn’t mostly paid off, they wouldn’t seize it. It’s not worth the government’s time, she said, to seize a Jaguar with a $30,000 lien.

Another challenge related to resources, Pierce said. The U.S. attorney’s financial investigators were adept at unraveling Ponzi schemes and other fraud, she said, but not sex trafficking operations. ATF agents and Homeland Security street cops tended to be good at busting pimps and rescuing victims from sleazy motels in the middle of the night. The agents who are good at tracking down money are “FBI suit-wearing types,” she said, who don’t typically work sex trafficking cases.

Another issue is strategic.

In the Northern District of Texas as well as other federal districts, standard plea agreements have a boilerplate paragraph on restitution. One version states in part that the defendant “agrees that the Court is authorized to order, and the defendant agrees to pay, restitution for all loss resulting from the offense(s) of conviction…in an amount to be determined by the Court.”

As such, restitution can become enmeshed with the plea negotiation process.

Pierce said calculating restitution while in the midst of plea negotiations can trigger a back-and-forth debate with the defendant’s counsel that risks derailing a plea agreement.

“If you’re willing to stipulate, great,” she said. “But you wouldn’t want that to hold up a plea.”

A similar scenario plays out in state court.

“When restitution orders happen, they almost always happen as part of a plea bargain,” said Kerri New, a former state prosecutor in Rockwall and Dallas counties and now an attorney adviser for Aequitas, a Washington, D.C., nonprofit that provides training and resources for prosecutors on sex trafficking cases and other sex crimes. “It’s negotiated just like any other aspect of the plea bargain.”

No legal advocate

“

“Every morning when most girls my age are looking at the mirror and critiquing their outfit for school, I stand in the mirror and look at the tattoos that cover me. They tell a story of constant pain and abuse…Finding friends with people in my same age group seems to be pointless, because it seems that because of me being forced into adulthood weeks after my 16th birthday, it makes it hard to find things that we have in common.”

— Child trafficking victim statement read at 2011 sentencing in Dallas.  

Negotiations illustrate an inherent problem with the restitution system: Prosecutors represent the government and its interests — that means convictions — and not the victim.

Jones, the ER doctor and former federal prosecutor, said the federal bureaucracy is obsessed with numbers and metrics — total annual prosecutions and convictions, and lengthy prison sentences. During his six years as a federal prosecutor, one metric was never brought up or tracked.

“At no point in time during any of my performance reviews,” Jones said, “was the quantity of restitution that victims received part of my review.”

Martina Vandenberg, a lawyer and founder and president of the Human Trafficking Legal Center, said every U.S. attorney’s office should have to report detailed restitution numbers because it’s the prosecutors’ responsibility and they should be held accountable.

Her organization once recommended victim restitution be part of the prosecutors’ performance reviews. She said it wouldn’t hurt to require the same of federal agents. Because right now, Vandenberg said, restitution does not factor into the government’s definition of success.

“It’s an utter afterthought.”

There is no legal advocate for the victim in court unless the judge appoints one, which is rare. Or they hire one — even rarer.

“If we actually cared about victims, we would be getting them independent lawyers to protect their interests, period,” said Bridgette Carr, a University of Michigan law professor who advocates for human trafficking victims and policies.

With no legal advocate, many survivors are unaware they are entitled to compensation, much less have the ability to put up a legal fight for it. The News reached out to a number of survivors who said they had never been informed.

One of those girls, now an adult, was a 17-year-old runaway when she met Darrius Ferguson, a violent North Texas gang member and felon who forced underaged girls into sex work.

“When it happened, I just forgot about it,” she said when reached by phone. “I haven’t even tried to get money for this. I didn’t even think that was a thing.”

Ferguson was sentenced to over 15 years in prison in Fort Worth federal court in 2022, court records show. He was not forced to pay restitution.

Judges may appoint an attorney or other representative for child victims, known as a guardian ad litem, to advocate for their interests in a sex trafficking case, including seeking restitution. The U.S. Attorney General’s guidelines under Merrick Garland said prosecutors were “strongly encouraged” to ask judges for the appointment of a guardian ad litem in cases involving child victims.

Victims, however, are generally not entitled to legal representation in the criminal justice system. And although authorized under the law, guardian ad litem appointments are not funded by Congress. As a result, appointed lawyers often must agree to represent the survivors pro bono.

That means pimps and pedophiles most often face a singular legal adversary — the prosecutor, who has little incentive to seek restitution for victims but a very strong one to seek forfeiture judgments for their employer, the government.

The case involving the 17-year-old Lubbock runaway is one example.

Henry David Jackson, who called himself “King Mac Hennessy,” made the girl earn $1,000 a day for him, prosecutors said. Federal prosecutors in Dallas put a stop to Jackson’s reign of terror when they arrested him in 2016. They also seized three vehicles, as well as $30,000, court records show.

When sentencing came around, the prosecutor did not request victim restitution. The victim received none of the money she had been forced to earn for her sexual enslavement.

The government kept Jackson’s seized money and assets.

The list of North Texas victims deprived of restitution — children and adult teenagers alike — is long. Their stories test the bounds of humanity:

One 15-year-old girl was “sleep- and food-deprived and in a near-constant state of drug intoxication during the ordeal,” court records show. Her pimp gave her ecstasy pills and alcohol while forcing her to have sex with multiple men. He threatened violence if she didn’t continue taking drugs, authorities said.

An 18-year-old developmentally disabled woman was kidnapped, beaten, deprived of food and forced to have sex with men in motel rooms. Her pimp raped her and gave her chlamydia, a sexually transmitted disease, court records show.

Another 18-year-old was viciously attacked by a customer in his car. The man stabbed her 22 times, requiring emergency surgery. After three days of treatment, she signed herself out of the hospital against medical advice. She was escorted out by her pimp.

Other victims were beaten, branded with tattoos to depict which pimp “owned” them, drugged so they would stay awake and forced to have sex without condoms. Some were impregnated by customers. Some were forced to undergo abortions.

While the system didn’t ultimately support them, they were forced to support the system, often required to testify against their abusers and traffickers in public trials and/or at sentencing hearings. On the stand, they not only had to recount their experiences in excruciating and humiliating detail but faced scathing cross-examination by their abusers’ attorneys.

One of those survivors who testified was the 12-year-old Dallas middle schooler who was sold by her pimp for as little as $50. During testimony, the girl recounted one time when she tried to protect two other girls being trafficked — by volunteering herself for sex.

“I thought, I’m not going to let my sister do it,” she testified, referring to a girl she viewed as her sister, “and I’m sure as hell not going to let my girlfriend do it. So I did it.”

“

“I think it is safe to say the devil lives in him. I was only 17 years of age when my life was changed forever…I ask for nothing more from the Court but justice in sentencing; justice for the screams of terror and pain RJ cried out that morning before we all got arrested when he beat her senseless to show me a lesson for not asking permission to go to sleep that night.”

— Victim statement at 2018 Dallas sentencing. 

The government often seizes criminal assets as punishment — to deprive criminals of the spoils of their offenses. That process is called forfeiture. Restitution, while also punitive, is primarily about compensating crime victims for their losses.

The two can be entwined. In federal criminal cases, forfeited property can be used to pay restitution — a process called restoration — but only if the government is willing to share.

A 2015 federal law requires the Justice Department to use available forfeited assets to satisfy any victim restitution orders in a sex trafficking case. The government, for example, can seize any vehicle used to transport a child for sex.

Forfeiture is perhaps the easiest way to satisfy a restitution order. The government can simply seize, freeze and liquidate a defendant’s assets.

The News found ample examples of cases where traffickers had sizable assets but North Texas prosecutors failed to seek a restitution order. Without that order of restitution, the 2015 law doesn’t apply — and the government is free to seek those assets for itself.

Even when prosecutors do seek an order of restitution, they routinely do not use forfeiture. The News identified just one case in the Northern District of Texas with both a restitution order and forfeiture action. It involved three watches, some necklaces and other jewelry.

During congressional debate over the 2015 law, Vandenberg, of the Human Trafficking Legal Center, said she “begged” and lobbied the Senate Judiciary Committee to make restitution payable immediately with available forfeiture money.

Government forfeitures, she explained, deplete all the criminal assets in a case — leaving nothing for victims, thus eliminating even the option of seeking damages in a lawsuit.

“My concern was that they were doing forfeiture without restitution,” she said, “which meant there was no way to get a civil damages award because there was no money left.”

When the law she fought for finally passed, with help from its key sponsor, Texas Sen. John Cornyn, Vandenberg was elated.

That joy turned to dismay when it became apparent — as The News analysis confirms — prosecutors were not seeking both forfeiture and restitution in every sex trafficking case.

“It’s shocking to me,” she said, “how every time we innovate, it continues to go wrong in a different way.”

The News reached out to Cornyn for his reaction to what advocates describe as a law with good intentions that has largely failed. A Cornyn spokesperson issued the following statement:

“Congress has spoken clearly on this issue through Sen. Cornyn’s Justice for Victims of Trafficking Act, and it is the prosecutor and judges’ responsibility to properly pursue court-ordered victim restitution.”

Meg Garvin, executive director of the National Crime Victim Law Institute and a professor at Lewis & Clark Law School, said U.S. attorneys should make better use of their financial litigation units to dig into sex traffickers’ finances early on — for possible victim compensation on the back end of a case.

“That’s a resource that exists,” she said, “and it should be deployed for human trafficking as well as for financial crime victims.”

Garvin said she has noticed a “reticence to invest a lot of time” in doing the work needed to obtain restitution orders. The unstated feeling among prosecutors, she said, is that those who’ve suffered damages should “go to civil court” to get financial compensation.

Forfeiture money was applied toward restitution orders in only a tiny fraction of federal sex trafficking cases nationwide from 2014 to 2025, according to forfeiture data obtained from the DOJ by The News in a Freedom of Information Act request.

For example, three federal fraud statutes, including health care fraud, accounted for $1.2 billion in forfeiture money applied toward restitution during that decade, federal data show. The amount applied toward sex trafficking restitution during that same period? About $137,000.

Even when forfeited assets are applied toward restitution, it can be a lengthy and frustrating process. Jose Alfaro knows this too well.

Jose Lewis Alfaro was 16 when he was sexually abused and trafficked by a man in Houston. Alfaro now serves as a public advocate for victims of sexual exploitation. 

Jose Lewis Alfaro was 16 when he was sexually abused and trafficked by a man in Houston. Alfaro now serves as a public advocate for victims of sexual exploitation. 

REBA SALDANHA/Reba Saldanha for The Rappaport Center for Law and Public Policy

Alfaro was 16 when he was sexually abused and trafficked by a man in Houston.

His abuser, Jason Daniel Gandy, owned a massage therapy business. Following his convictions for sex trafficking of minors, sexual exploitation of children, transportation of child pornography and transportation of minors, he forfeited an RV, a car and some real estate property to the government, court records show.

Alfaro said he didn’t receive the help he needed to properly request restitution from his abuser but eventually sought legal assistance — from the Human Trafficking Legal Center. He successfully won a restitution order for more than $25,000.

Alfaro said he did some research and learned Gandy’s seized assets sold for about $250,000. Trying to get some of that money to pay his $25,000 restitution, he said, became a lengthy and frustrating process marked by delays and excuses from the government.

Gandy was sentenced in 2018 to 30 years in prison. Alfaro said his first check arrived in 2021.

“This is years of me constantly calling, trying to figure out where the money is,” he said.

Alfaro was among the small percentage who successfully navigated the system and received what was owed to him. He understands how the system is stacked against survivors, but also how not only lack of awareness and lack of advocacy but also perception can prevent survivors from even making the effort.

He has spoken to survivors who told him they did not seek restitution “because of the stigma that they only care about the money,” said Alfaro, who now serves as a public advocate for victims of sexual exploitation. “I’m trying to change that narrative and say it should be about the money and it’s okay that it’s about the money. It’s okay if justice for you means money.”

Even if a federal prosecutor secures a restitution order — and even if that prosecutor seeks to use forfeiture to satisfy it — the system can still fail the victim.

Why? The assets have already been forfeited to someone else.

Consider the case of Tremont Blakemore.

In early 2018, Dallas police began investigating Blakemore, a longtime violent pimp who trafficked his victims across the U.S. for multiple years. Blakemore, who was known to award himself “Pimp of the Year” trophies, was indicted on sex trafficking, money laundering and organized crime charges in state court in Dallas County.

In late 2019, Blakemore was also charged in federal court. Local prosecutors waited for the federal case to play out. Once he was convicted in 2022 and sentenced to 20 years in federal prison, Dallas County prosecutors dropped the state charges.

As part of his federal sentence, he was ordered to pay $618,000 restitution to his victims — one of those rare instances in the Northern District.

It would seem his victims might benefit. After all, three years prior, a federal agent testified that Blakemore owned fancy cars and other property.

“Based upon his social media, he owns a Rolls Royce, Bentley, Mercedes, other luxury vehicles,” the agent said during his testimony. He said investigators did not know the extent of Blakemore’s assets or their “true worth.”

The organized crime indictment filed by the DA’s Office against Blakemore documented deposits of more than $800,000 into multiple bank accounts from 2015 to 2018. A seized ledger showed earnings of more than $841,500 over a nine-month period in 2018. “The known financial activity and assets of Mr. Blakemore totals into the millions of dollars,” a state prosecutor wrote in a 2019 court filing.

When it came time for the feds to seize his assets to satisfy restitution, all that remained were a few pieces of jewelry – and his Pimp of the Year trophy.

Local prosecutors had decided not to pursue charges, but they had already pursued his assets — and civil forfeiture does not require a conviction. So, the state was able to keep about $57,200 seized from a bank account linked to him, court records show.

As of June, the court file did not indicate whether any restitution had been paid to Blakemore’s victims.

White-collar restitution

“

“Martavious made me feel like I was a prized possession. But very quickly I learned how cold-hearted he was by the way he fed me drugs and wouldn’t let me take breaks between tricks or clients…He wanted to be sure I would continue to make him money. He would put drugs in his hand and I would cry for them and he’d make me beg for them.”

— Victim statement at 2017 sentencing in Dallas.

There are other crime victims who routinely benefit from restitution: white-collar victims.

Restitution was ordered in 79% of fraud and theft cases in North Texas from 2015 to 2024, according to federal data. When the federal government is the victim, the chances of restitution skyrocket. In tax fraud cases where the IRS was the victim, restitution was ordered 92% of the time in the Northern District of Texas from 2015 to 2024.

“When it’s the IRS getting paid, of course, there’s a restitution order,” said Vandenberg, of the Human Trafficking Legal Center.

Two factors help explain why white-collar crime victims — as well as the government and corporations — are more likely to receive restitution. For one, the nature of the crime requires investigators to dig deep into the finances of the accused, so it’s better understood what assets are available and where they are.

For another, unlike victims of sex trafficking, white-collar crime victims are more likely to have the financial means to retain an attorney. Having that advocate makes a huge difference.

It’s not just the victim’s inadequate financial means — and thus inability to afford legal counsel — that hinders restitution. So, too, does the perceived financial means of the abuser.

One reason prosecutors often cite for not seeking restitution is sex traffickers don’t have the means to pay. That might be the case at the time of sentencing. But financial windfalls can occur at any time — from multiple sources. Offenders — in prison or on supervised release — could receive unexpected earnings such as inheritances, tax refunds, insurance payouts, divorce settlements, gifts and lawsuit settlements; all of which can be taken and applied toward restitution. That is, if the prosecutor had sought restitution.

In one local case, a windfall came from a mother’s will. Prosecutors snatched the $4,000 inheritance from Trent Brewer’s prison account in 2016 and applied it toward his outstanding restitution balance, court records show.

Brewer had been convicted of conspiracy to commit fraud years earlier in Dallas. The victim receiving the restitution was a white-collar victim — an insurance company.

It’s not just white-collar victims who have higher restitution rates. Victims of other violent crimes fare better, even though they also are unlikely to have legal representation, and their offender is seemingly no more likely to have deep pockets.

In North Texas, the restitution rate for victims of robbery was 73%; kidnapping, 40%; and assault, 13%, according to sentencing data.

Judges decide

“

“I’ve never felt so inhuman in my life. I would get beat for being tired, for not making enough money, for standing up for myself when he wanted to be treated like God…I remember he beat me in Houston because I was running through gunshots and made little money while out there. He beat me while I was in a corner shaking, traumatized.”

— Victim statement at 2024 Dallas sentencing about meeting the defendant one month after turning 18.

The decision about restitution ultimately falls to judges, who also have the authority to require prosecutors to follow through with their obligations to collect it for victims.

Many North Texas judges in federal sentencing hearings had harsh words for convicted traffickers, though it hasn’t resulted in restitution orders.

“These sex offenses…to me they are the worst kind of offenses except a murder case, because — even drugs are not as bad, because sex offenses are — they are imprinted on these girls,” U.S. District Judge Jane Boyle said in a 2024 hearing.

Some local federal judges have denied restitution without explanation. Others noted in their sentencing judgments that restitution wasn’t ordered because it wasn’t requested, court records show. A few judges wrote, “There is no victim other than society at large.”

None are valid reasons under the law.

“It is irrelevant whether the victim seeks it, whether the prosecutor requests it, or whether the defendant is likely to have the means on hand to pay it,” according to the Human Trafficking Legal Center.

Attempts to reach North Texas federal judges were unsuccessful. Some declined to comment through their assistants. Others did not respond to inquiries.

The most common reason judges cited nationally and in North Texas for not ordering restitution was “not applicable,” cited in about 80% of local cases, according to sentencing data. That is a general category reported to the Sentencing Commission from which it is impossible to glean a detailed rationale.

After that, the reasons North Texas judges gave were “victim declined participation” (in 13% of cases) and “losses not ascertainable,” which accounted for 3% of cases.

Fort Worth federal courts are particularly stingy with restitution for sex trafficking victims. The News could find only one such case with restitution in that division. Diwone Nobles was given 30 years in prison in 2017 and ordered to pay $153,160 in restitution to his victims. How much they received from him is unclear from the available record.

As the U.S. attorney’s human trafficking coordinator in Dallas, Pierce handled much of the sex trafficking caseload until she left the office. She said many Northern District of Texas judges had a problem with ordering restitution for victims in those cases.

“Some judges were not super comfortable with paying them the money the trafficker got when the victim engaged in commercial sex,” said Pierce, an SMU law professor. “Some people consider it distasteful because prostitution in and of itself is illegal.”

Pierce, who worked from 2008 to 2020 as a federal prosecutor in Dallas, said she was able to convince judges by arguing that when they were trafficked, the girls and women were denied the opportunity to earn a legal living; and that criminals shouldn’t be allowed to profit from that.

New, the former state prosecutor in Rockwall and Dallas Counties, said judges in state court also struggle with providing survivors compensation unless part of a plea agreement.

If the decision to provide restitution comes before a judge at sentencing, New said, it becomes very difficult to convince them victims are entitled to such considerations as lost wages.

“I can’t imagine a judge in our jurisdiction agreeing to that,” she said, even though her argument would be it is forced labor. As she put it, “This person was essentially a slave.”

Conversely, judges can be champions for victims. They have considerable authority to ensure victims are compensated. The News found examples in Washington, D.C., and New York where federal judges not only required prosecutors to account for seized assets but even required them to use those assets to first satisfy restitution orders.

Importance of restitution

“

“You actually broke me. I have been having a lot of flashbacks…I have no motivation to do anything or to talk to anyone. I wake up in the middle of the night upset or crying because I had a dream or a nightmare about you. Jaelind, you took everything from me…I’m this scared, fragile mess. I’m what you made me: a cold, broken girl.”

— Victim Statement at 2024 sentencing in Lubbock, about being trafficked at age 17.  

The need for court-ordered restitution for child sexual abuse victims is becoming increasingly more urgent for several disparate reasons related to policy, law and criminal behavior.

The Trump administration has cut millions of dollars in federal grants dedicated for victims of sexual abuse, and redirected Homeland Security resources to immigration enforcement. Nonprofit agencies that rely on the grants to provide services to trafficking victims are running out of money. They are cutting staff and shutting down programs, advocates say.

Victim lawsuits against social media companies for enabling human trafficking are being thrown out in courts across the country due to a federal immunity law.

Federal sexual abuse offenses have jumped 62% nationwide since 2020, according to the Sentencing Commission. Production of child pornography is the most common of those crimes, the agency has reported.

The number of people prosecuted for human trafficking in the U.S. more than doubled between 2012 and 2022 — from 805 to 1,656 people, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Juwan James Davis was one of those abusers. He was convicted of sex trafficking in 2023 and is serving a 25-year prison sentence.

Davis met Madison Spottswood, known as “Maddie,” on Snapchat when she was 13 years old, court records show.

Maddie’s mother, Tanja, recalls that back then, her daughter spent her time studying and participating in various pre-teen pursuits: cheerleading, figure skating and dancing — ballet and hip-hop.

Soon, Davis was selling Maddie to men online, for sex in Houston hotels, prosecutors said.

“He sent her pictures of money, and he sent her pictures of drugs,” prosecutor Kimberly Leo told the judge at sentencing. “That’s how he manipulated and preyed upon this seventh-grader. He then hooked her and got her to start working for him, and that’s when the control started.”

Davis branded her on the buttocks with a tattoo of his initials, Leo said, to show other pimps “she belonged to him.”

“She should have been enjoying middle school pep rallies and soccer games and cheerleading and instead,” Leo told the judge, “she’s having random sex with random men for money.”

Davis introduced Maddie to methamphetamine and heroin so she would have sex with men, court records said. When Davis felt the need to punish her, he raped her.

Maddie was rescued when Davis was arrested in 2018. At Davis’ sentencing, Maddie’s mom testified about the damage done, about how her daughter’s life quickly spiraled downward, and about multiple suicide attempts.

“My daughter was an all-A honor roll student,” Tanja Spottswood said at the sentencing.

After her ordeal, Maddie tried to get her life back. She was seven months pregnant, her mother told the judge, “and excited to be a mom.”

Maddie never made it. She was 18 when she died from a fentanyl overdose, just a little over a month before she was to give birth and three months after Davis pleaded guilty to sex trafficking.

“This is what I have left of her,” Tanja Spottswood said at his sentencing, clutching an urn. “One container of ashes.”

In the months before she died, Maddie’s mother and grandmother said they tried to save Maddie. They put her in drug treatment facilities, burning through their savings and retirement money.

Restitution would have provided at least some financial relief. In the event of death, compensation is paid to the estate.

Angela Dodge, spokeswoman for the U.S. attorney’s office in Houston, did not provide specifics about the case, citing privacy rules. She said her office tries to “ascertain losses and provide opportunities and seek resources in support of our victims, regularly communicating with them and their families.”

Maddie’s mother recalled a prosecutor mentioning something about restitution. But the family received no relief. The prosecutor never formally sought restitution.

How We Reported This Story

This project required downloading 25.4 GB of crime data from the U.S. Sentencing Commission covering the period from 2015 to 2024. Data journalist José Luis Adriano filtered nearly 24,000 cases from all 94 federal judicial districts in the U.S. involving child pornography and sex trafficking offenses.

Texas accounted for about 2,400 cases of these crimes during that period, including nearly 800 cases within the Northern District of Texas. Interpreting a database containing nearly 20,000 variables required hundreds of lines of Python code.

The analysis focused on restitution determinations to identify which victims received restitution orders and which did not, the reasons courts provided for granting or denying restitution, and the amounts awarded in each case. Some child sex trafficking cases in North Texas did not involve victims because they originated from law enforcement sting operations using undercover federal agents posing as traffickers. Those cases were statistically small and not included in the calculation.