Pride San Antonio’s monthly meetings no longer boil over into near-shouting matches between leaders of the nonprofit and angry crowds.

Lately, the nonprofit’s board members only raise their voices to be heard over the loud square-dancing instructors and community theater troupe that share the Woodlawn Pointe Community Center with Pride San Antonio, one of the city’s most prominent LGBTQ+ advocacy groups.

That’s a far cry from the turmoil that engulfed the organization earlier this year and threatened to detract from the organization’s hallmark Pride Month celebrations, which are slated for Saturday.

Article continues below this ad

The trouble started with the city’s decision to remove rainbow crosswalks on North Main Avenue, complying with a directive from Gov. Greg Abbott banning art work on Texas streets that conveys “political ideologies.” Any city that refused would risk losing its state and federal transportation funding. 

Pride San Antonio unwittingly courted controversy when it joined with the Texas Conservative Liberty Forum’s San Antonio chapter — which has fought gender-affirming care for transgender youth — to sue the city of San Antonio in January. The parties alleged city leaders inappropriately set aside tax dollars to remove the crosswalks and then paint sidewalks on the street with rainbow-colored stripes. They argued that City Council should have voted on the allocation. 

A city worker drills a cylinder out of the sidewalk along North Main Avenue and East Evergreen Street in the Pride Cultural Heritage District on Jan. 12. The City of San Antonio replaced the rainbow crosswalks with standard white striping to comply with Gov. Greg Abbott’s order.

A city worker drills a cylinder out of the sidewalk along North Main Avenue and East Evergreen Street in the Pride Cultural Heritage District on Jan. 12. The City of San Antonio replaced the rainbow crosswalks with standard white striping to comply with Gov. Greg Abbott’s order.

Andrew J. Whitaker/San Antonio Express-NewsCity-contracted construction crews paint rainbow stripes along the sidewalk of North Main Avenue on Feb. 4, just after the rainbow crosswalks were removed in January.

City-contracted construction crews paint rainbow stripes along the sidewalk of North Main Avenue on Feb. 4, just after the rainbow crosswalks were removed in January.

Andrew J. Whitaker/San Antonio Express-News

Anger over the joint lawsuit exploded at Pride San Antonio board meetings in January and February, opening the way for other, long-simmering complaints against the 22-year-old nonprofit. About 70 people showed up to a February meeting that in quieter periods would have attracted no more than a handful. Many of them blasted board members for teaming up with the conservative group and what they saw as unwillingness to listen to criticism.

Article continues below this ad

A couple of people floated the idea of boycotting the organization’s signature Pride Bigger Than Texas Parade and Festival, including drag performer Lyn-Z Andrews.

She spoke up after board members publicly chided her for hosting shows at Pegasus, a North Main Avenue nightclub owned by a trust affiliated with Mauro Garza, a Republican politician who has run for Congress and is currently campaigning for Cameron County judge. Their attack against Andrews seemingly came in response to her online criticism of the group’s handling of the lawsuit.

Six dissidents created a rival organization called Pride210, which got its official nonprofit designation this month. The group collected more than 160 signatures on a petition calling for Pride San Antonio’s board to resign, publicly apologize for partnering with the Texas Conservative Liberty Forum, and once again allow people to publicly comment on the group’s social media posts.

Article continues below this ad

And then the noise died down. 

Detractors stopped crowding into Pride San Antonio meetings and they never mounted a large-scale boycott of the Pride parade and festival, though some groups and individuals are staying away this year.

Saturday’s events will be more smaller than in past years, but organizers say that’s not because of the rupture five months ago.

“I think this was a loud minority of folks and not necessarily reflective of the general overall sentiment,” said Mariah Medina, a spokesperson for Pride San Antonio.

Article continues below this ad

The day-long festival that precedes the parade will take up half of the near-downtown Crockett Park instead of the entire space as in prior years.

People gather along Main Avenue for the 2024 Pride Parade.

People gather along Main Avenue for the 2024 Pride Parade.

Ethan Rocke/Ethan E. Rocke/Contributor

But board secretary James Poindexter boasted at a meeting last week that more volunteers than ever will put in time at the events and nearly 20 dignitaries are slated to attend.

Medina said this year’s downsizing stemmed from rising costs, tighter budgets for Pride San Antonio and other participating organizations, and a wariness among LGBTQ+ groups over the possibility of provoking hostile conservative legislators in Austin.

Article continues below this ad

Pride San Antonio was originally called Gay Pride SA when it formed in 2004 and began organizing an annual festival to celebrate the LGBTQ+ rights movement, according to the nonprofit’s website. Its events raise money for a slew of nonprofits each year.

Moving ahead

But Pride San Antonio’s opponents haven’t gone away.

Pride210 turned its attention away from Pride San Antonio in recent months to help other organizations host and organize LGBTQ+ events for Pride Month, including a Pride river parade, a drag show at Bombay Bicycle Club at Hemisfair, and a pageant. 

Article continues below this ad

Drag Queen Maria G performs at a Pride210 fundraiser at Bombay Bicycle Club on June 12.

Drag Queen Maria G performs at a Pride210 fundraiser at Bombay Bicycle Club on June 12.

Isaiah Moseley/Contributor

Daniel Pacheco, a co-founder and chair of the fledgling group, said its leaders decided to “steer clear” of the older organization after its board members allegedly brushed off Pride210’s concerns.

In the heat of the brawl, Pride San Antonio moved to take control of the name Pride210. Poindexter filed paperwork with the Texas Secretary of State to use the name. A large poster of a cease-and-desist letter was on display at Pride San Antonio’s February meeting threatening legal action if Pride210 didn’t stop using the moniker. 

Medina said Pride San Antonio never sent the letter, and Pride210 has since trademarked its name.

Article continues below this ad

“We did our due diligence, we made our attempt, and I think the community was able to see their response,” Pacheco said.

“We’ve been able to really connect with the community on a different level,” he added. 

Pacheco and others in Pride210 plan to skip Pride San Antonio’s festival and parade. But Pacheco said that’s largely because of a scheduling conflict — they’ll be attending Pride on the Eastside, an event not affiliated with Pride San Antonio.

San Antonio Area LGBTQ+ Community Coalition doesn’t have plans to attend Pride San Antonio’s event either, said Lex Loro, executive director of the Pride Center, a coalition member. 

Article continues below this ad

That’s largely because of the high number of other Pride events that members will be involved in, including Pride on the Eastside.

The coalition — made up of five nonprofits —  started meeting last fall to help support each other’s efforts in the LGBTQ+ community.

Portrait of Daniel Pacheco, co-founder and chair of the new group Pride210, at Bombay Bicycle Club on June 12.

Portrait of Daniel Pacheco, co-founder and chair of the new group Pride210, at Bombay Bicycle Club on June 12.

Isaiah Moseley/Contributor

The group oversees a group of people interested in recasting Pride events in San Antonio, potentially by having more year-round programming.

Article continues below this ad

Earlier this year, some members approached Pride San Antonio to relay concerns they heard from transgender people who worried about the nonprofit’s joint lawsuit with the Texas Conservative Liberty Forum. Loro said some members felt the Pride San Antonio board needed new leadership.

The Gender & Sexuality Alliance, a student organization at San Antonio College, called in February for Pride San Antonio’s board to step down. The organization took to Instagram on Friday to express their continued dissatisfaction with Pride San Antonio, noting the group’s use of San Antonio College property as a staging area for Saturday’s event does not represent endorsement from the alliance.

Another group, called the Gay Agenda Coalition, has launched a small boycott of the Pride festival and parade — but for reasons other than the joint lawsuit earlier this year.

The Gay Agenda Coalition objects to Pride San Antonio’s corporate sponsorships and perceived friendliness toward police. Founding coalition member Robert Hernandez said there was uproar last year when Pride San Antonio co-hosted a forum with San Antonio Police Department after openly gay actor Jonathan Joss was murdered on the South Side. 

Article continues below this ad

The Gay Agenda Coalition has held protests of about 30 people outside of the Pride festival in the last two years.

The group, made up of three organizations, is hosting its second annual “Reclaim Pride” event in August. Last year, it drew 100 people and featured a resource fair, live music and a drag show. 

Cities across the country hold similar “Reclaim Pride” events largely to protest the commercialization of the LGBTQ+ celebrations.

“We definitely supported the movement and organizing against Pride Bigger Than Texas, but we believe that we needed to take the politics a lot further than just against the collaborations with this conservative group,” Hernandez said. “We wanted to see more political agitation when it comes to what Pride needs to be.” 

Article continues below this ad

New leaders, old problems

Attorney Justin Nichols, who filed the lawsuit over city funding for the crosswalks’ removal, has done pro bono work for both the Texas Conservative Liberty Forum and Pride San Antonio.

He said the two parties didn’t collaborate on the lawsuit. They approached him separately about suing the city, and he decided to draft a single lawsuit because they were seeking similar remedies — for a judge to at least temporarily stop the city’s work and to require the City Council to vote on funding.

Critics were not only upset that Pride San Antonio filed the lawsuit with a right-wing nonprofit, but that a Republican attorney handled the case.

Article continues below this ad

Nichols was elected this month to serve on the Republican Party of Texas’ executive committee. The news renewed old frustrations. Pride210 took to social media, rehashing concerns about Pride San Antonio’s ties to Nichols, who is openly gay.

“The issue was never whether LGBTQ+ people can be Republicans,” the post reads. “The issue was whether Pride San Antonio’s board exercised sound judgement when it chose to align itself with organizations and individuals connected to a political movement that has repeatedly advanced legislation targeting LGBTQ+ Texans.”

Pride San Antonio President Phillip Barcena, left, and board member Autumn Summers speak at the Fiesta Frenzy event at Woodlawn Pointe on April 22.

Pride San Antonio President Phillip Barcena, left, and board member Autumn Summers speak at the Fiesta Frenzy event at Woodlawn Pointe on April 22.

Newly appointed Pride San Antonio board member Jazmine Blake performs at the Fiesta Frenzy event at Woodlawn Pointe on April 22.

Newly appointed Pride San Antonio board member Jazmine Blake performs at the Fiesta Frenzy event at Woodlawn Pointe on April 22.

Clint Datchuk/Contributor

Pride San Antonio was hit with another barrage of harsh comments on social media this month after news broke about Nichols’ new party position, Poindexter said at a membership meeting last week. The nonprofit removed Nichols’ name and contact information from its website, Poindexter told members.

Article continues below this ad

He repeatedly scoffed at criticism of the organization during the meeting, saying people are “trying to attack us for things we did not do and spread lies about us.”

Still, Medina said the situation has improved significantly since February.

“There’s no tension, at least on our end,” Medina said. “Are there other individuals with personal disputes against other individuals? Sure. This is a volunteer space dominated by people that are very passionate.”

At the height of the controversy last winter, the group’s board decided to slowly hand over control to new leaders, which they are hand-selecting. Many of the sitting members have led the organization for the past 20 years. 

Article continues below this ad

Four new board members were publicly announced at a monthly meeting and on Facebook in March. 

Poindexter previously said new members would take the reins by June 2027, but that deadline is fluid and could shift, Medina said.

‘Room for everybody’

The Pride Center and other groups hosted a forum in February to talk about future Pride events, but it often got sidetracked with complaints about Pride San Antonio.

Article continues below this ad

A few participants claimed they weren’t paid for performances in past festivals. Others said they worried about police presence at the annual festivities. The complaints were similar to those expressed at Pride San Antonio’s board meetings, where attendees complained about entrance and water fees and a lack of transgender representation on the board, in addition to the lawsuit.

“I don’t think that the conversations are over and I don’t think the work and the growth is over,” said Loro, the Pride Center executive director. “I don’t think we got to a point where everything that we need to do in order to ensure Pride events in San Antonio are inclusive has happened. I think there are lingering frustrations. I think there are lingering concerns. 

Executive Director of Pride Center San Antonio Lex Loro, left, assists Jose Morales with information regarding the Rainbow Ride shuttle to NIOSA on April 21.

Executive Director of Pride Center San Antonio Lex Loro, left, assists Jose Morales with information regarding the Rainbow Ride shuttle to NIOSA on April 21.

Clint Datchuk/Contributor

“And also, there’s a lot of amazing work that communities have done to make sure that we still have a really awesome Pride Month this year,” she said. 

Article continues below this ad

Pacheco believes Pride San Antonio and Pride210 will be able to coexist moving forward — even though his organization was formed to push back on the older group.

“I think there is room for everybody,” Pacheco said. “If there are people in our community who support both of us, then great. I think that benefits the community because they’re getting programming and events from two different organizations. The more, the better.”