Dallas Stars left wing Jason Robertson (21) and right wing Mikko Rantanen (96) prepare for a face off during the first period in Game 5 of a first-round NHL hockey playoff series against the Minnesota Wild at American Airlines Center on Tuesday, April 28, 2026, in Dallas.
Smiley N. Pool/The Dallas Morning News
It was during my brief but memorable time as a San Francisco Giants beat writer in the late ’80s that I made the late-night postgame watering hole pronouncement that Darryl Strawberry and John F. Kennedy were the two most simultaneously overrated and underrated people of the past 30 years.
Without dissecting the number of beers involved or the qualities and deficiencies I ascribed to either gentleman, let’s just move into the present where I would like to add Jason Robertson to the list.
The greatest scorer in the 30-year-plus history of the local hockey club is now systematically destroying the team’s future.
Article continues below this ad
Something like that, anyway.
Let’s start with the good. Two days into the NHL’s free agency period, Robertson remains unsigned. But as a restricted free agent, which basically means no one else can afford to pay him due to the first-round picks price tag, he becomes more likely a future Dallas Star with each passing hour. He declined a trade that would have sent him to Seattle last weekend after he had turned down the Stars’ offer to pay him, reportedly, the same as their highest paid player, Mikko Rantanen.
So, barring a surprising turn, Robertson should keep scoring goals for Dallas at which he has been extremely successful. Robertson’s 109 points in 2022-23 is the club record since the move from Minnesota. His 96 points this past season is second best for Dallas. In his five full seasons, Robertson has scored 444 points. The guy with the statue out front never did better in a five-year run than 427, and that’s including his last two years in Minnesota and it’s also eliminating a strike-shortened 1995 season.
Is Robertson as beloved as Mike Modano? No, he’s not. Modano was the face of the new franchise, not to mention the most prominent center on back-to-back Finals teams including the ‘99 Cup winner. (Yes, I realize center Joe Nieuwendyk won the Conn Smythe back then, but go check the opponents, see who Buffalo’s great defender Michael Peca was checking the entire time).
Article continues below this ad
Related: In ‘cap compliant’ world, Stars learning challenge of keeping their young core together
However, if Robertson falls short of Modano in the embrace of the fans, it’s not as if his status didn’t grow exponentially this past season through none of his own work. When Minnesota GM Bill Guerin put together a U.S. Olympic team that did not include Robertson, fans adopted Robo as their personal cause. Everyone wants a reason to be mad these days, legit or not, and every Robertson goal (he tied Wyatt Johnston for the team lead) became a message delivered personally to Guerin.
Never mind the fact that USA won gold without Robo.
Now we get to the hard part. It has been ingrained among sportswriters and columnists going back to my darker-haired days in the ‘80s that the players’ side is to be taken at all times in contract negotiations. Never ever side with management, no matter how preposterous the player demand.
It actually made sense to view things that way at the time. When I first covered the Cowboys in 1986, free agency did not exist in the NFL. The early days of “Plan B’’ signings offered mostly a chance to add retreads to one’s roster, even if the Cowboys grabbed Jay Novacek that way. When I covered the Stars a decade later, the team flew commercial and coach. Watching the Hatcher brothers fold their way into seats on Row 32, I felt like surely these guys deserved better.
Article continues below this ad
But we shouldn’t be afraid to acknowledge that times have changed, that college quarterbacks make more money than some professional coaches. More significant, a salary cap world creates a quid pro quo, and if players don’t like salary caps or franchise tags, etc., sorry, it’s their player associations who signed them up for it.
So when Robertson decides he deserves more money than Rantanen, it has a decided impact on the Stars. In this case, Mavrik Bourque, a good young forward, was sacrificed to Nashville along with veteran defenseman Ilya Lyubushkin for draft picks. It’s all to make room for a little more money for Robertson.
As a result, GM Jim Nill is basically being forced to send a retread team — not quite as deep on paper, no one confuses the return of Joel Kiviranta as equaling the loss of Bourque — into action next year. It’s hard enough to compete at the top of the Western Conference where almost all of the league’s top salaried scorers can be found, where two desperate teams have changed coaches (Vegas and Edmonton) more recently than the Stars dismissed Pete DeBoer.
It all leaves Glen Gulutzan with an increasingly large challenge on his hands in the fall of 2026. Assuming that Robertson does, in fact, stay in Dallas, will there be any difference in how fans greet the team’s leading scorer?
Article continues below this ad
Keep in mind that by making more money, Robertson won’t become a better player. And he’s not someone seeking more responsibility within the team. Assuming the Stars get around to ripping the C off Jamie Benn’s sweater before his 50th birthday, the soft-spoken Robertson will not be a successor candidate.
Yes, players deserve the right to chase top dollar in their reasonably short-lived careers. They are also, collectively, quite good at passing the buck, saying things like “I let my agent do all of that,’’ conveniently forgetting in the equation just who works for whom.
Never think their modern dollar pursuits don’t come at a cost. For the Stars, it has already shown up on the depth chart for this October.