The only thing scarier than joining the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders is quitting the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders.
At the end of Season 3 of “America’s Sweethearts,” the Netflix reality series following the squad through its annual audition process, Reece Weaver decided to hang up her pompoms after just three seasons with DCC.
“It was more scary to leave, because it’s like, ‘Oh gosh, now what do I do?’ I’m jumping into the real world. I don’t know what is next. I think it was more of the unknowns that were scary,” she tells TODAY.com.
Reece Weaver quit the DCC after three seasons.Netflix
For viewers, the move was genuinely surprising. Weaver, who has a classical studio background, was a breakout star for Season 1, which followed the selection for the 2023-2024 football season.
She retired during a conversation with director of the DCC Kelli Finglass and choreographer Judy Trammell shown in Episode 7.
“That was honestly one of the scariest days of my life,” Weaver says. “My biggest fear was, I wanted to eloquently share everything that was on my heart. Right before I walked in, (my husband) Will (Allman) was praying with me, and I just kept saying, ‘Speak through me, Lord. Just speak through me.’ I was scared to not have the words.”
Weaver had been “wrestling” with the decision all season, she says. After three years, cheering with the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders felt “comfortable.” The cheerleaders had pushed to raise their salaries significantly since Weaver signed on and she knows she “would have enjoyed” more time on the squad.
But she says she was ready for more.
“I wanted to encourage others, that if they felt like they were being pulled, to take a leap of faith. I wanted to hopefully inspire them to do so and not be scared of it,” she says.
She expected fear and uncertainty after quitting. What she didn’t expect, however, was the feedback from people who doubted whether the decision was hers at all.
After “America’s Sweethearts” aired, viewers speculated about the reason behind her retirement. Was it the high ankle sprain she suffered during her third season? Or was it pressure from her husband, Will Allman?
“It’s frustrating,” Weaver says of the speculation. “I have the most incredible husband, who is so supportive, and I’m 100% healthy and could totally do another season.”
Reece called quitting the DCC the “scariest day of her life.”Netflix
She emphasizes that Allman would have supported her “no matter what,” which makes the rumors especially “sad.”
“He made it extremely clear to me that it had to be my decision. I’m so grateful for that,” she says. “All he wants to do is support my dreams.”
Since leaving the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders, Weaver and Allman have gone back to their hometown of Tuscaloosa, Alabama. But she hasn’t settled into her new normal yet.
“I wish I could tell you exactly what it looks like, but I have not spent more than three days in our new home at a time,” she says. “Life has been so busy, just in a different way.”
Her plans, though, include “falling back in love” with the type of studio dance she did when she was younger. She’s also taken up singing lessons.
Reece says rumors that her husband encouraged her to quit the DCC are “sad.” Courtesy of Netflix
“I actually put on my dream board for 2026 that I want to do something that is really hard for me, and I want to get good at it. I didn’t know it was going to be singing at the time,” she says.
She says Broadway is a dream of hers, but so is staying grounded in Alabama.
“My friends say, ‘You’re literally living the Hannah Montana life.’ You’re traveling but going back home to your roots. Being centered with your community, while also living this ambitious, fun, kind of glamorized life,” she says.
“I still want to continue to dance and perform and do all the things, while also probably one day building a chicken coop in our backyard. That would be very Hannah Montana.”