Bexar County commissioners voted to hire a shared court coordinator for two judges who had threatened legal action over staffing — but the judges reacted to the move very differently.

The five-member Commissioners Court unanimously approved Rodriguez’s plan on Tuesday. 

The vote followed months of tension after Nieto and Hortick withdrew from Bexar County’s longstanding centralized system for assigning civil cases to judges. The two judges demanded funding for court coordinators to operate their independent dockets. 

The judges have argued that cases should remain with the judges to whom they were originally assigned in order to not waste time — to avoid wasting the time of plaintiffs, defendants, attorneys and judges.

Nieto welcomed the compromise.

“While I did not receive my own dedicated coordinator, this decision reflects a shared commitment to working together in the best interest of our community,” Nieto, who presides in the 285th District Court, said in an email.

Hortick took the opposite view.

“The Court’s decision today to once again refuse to properly fund the local judicial system is appalling but not at all unexpected. Delay is the name of the game,” Hortick, who presides in the 225th District Court, said in an email. “The entire process to evaluate the needs of local judiciary has been a farce from start to finish.”

She said she would “explore all options” in response to commissioners’ decision.

A court coordinator essentially serves as a scheduling manager and case-flow organizer. 

Before Tuesday’s vote, the county manager’s office reviewed the judges’ operational and staffing needs and concluded the courts’s workloads did not justify separate coordinator positions.

Deputy County Manager Thomas Guevara said the review found “insufficient workload to justify creating an additional coordinator role for each” court compared with staffing in the county’s other civil district courts.

Guevara noted that the 12 civil district judges who remain in the central system share two court coordinators — one assigned to the docket and another responsible for jury trial settings.

As of May, the docket coordinator managed a load of about 67,000 cases, or more than 4,700 for each of the 14 judges, he said. About 100 to 200 hearings are set each day. Meanwhile, the trial settings coordinator handles about 800 settings each month.

Rodriguez said he made his proposal “in the spirit of compromise,” as a way to reach a solution “we can all live with.”

The new coordinator position will pay up to $81,986 in salary and benefits.

Nieto, in requesting funding, said her court clerk has been doing the job of a court coordinator.

“She’s been working overtime, in the evening and on the weekend, and she does this out of loyalty to my court,” Nieto told commissioners.