SAN ANTONIO — Nearly three months after a tornado damaged a student apartment complex near the University of Texas at San Antonio, some students say they are still paying full rent without access to several amenities they expected when signing their leases.
An EF-1 tornado struck The Oasis San Antonio apartments at 6023 UTSA Boulevard on July 15, damaging buildings and displacing approximately 150 students and other tenants.
The tornado caused extensive roof and structural damage, forcing some people into temporary housing while crews worked to repair the property.
Now, students who moved into the complex for the fall semester say they are frustrated that several advertised amenities remain closed, including the swimming pool, fitness center, clubhouse, study rooms and business center.
Kenzy Ibrahim, a UTSA freshman who moved into the complex in August, said she expected the apartment to offer opportunities to meet other students and enjoy her first year of college.
“Of course, because I think where you meet people is not from just the apartment. You should be meeting people at the gym and the pool, so I’m missing out on all those experiences that everyone else that’s not living at Oasis is having,” Ibrahim said.
Ibrahim said she pays approximately $825 per month before electricity and believes students should receive some type of rent reduction while the amenities remain unavailable.
“Well, I want a decrease in my rent. That’s what I want the most,” Ibrahim said.
She said she has also been frustrated by what she describes as limited communication from apartment management about when the facilities will reopen.
“I would say little to none, honestly,” Ibrahim said. “I feel like they’ve just been sending out emails regarding maintenance and water, but nothing regarding amenities or even any updates about when they’ll be fixed.”
Another UTSA freshman, Kisa Kazmi, said she signed her lease before the tornado and moved into the complex in August.
Kazmi said she was aware of the tornado before moving in but did not recall receiving specific information about how long the amenities would remain closed.
“I don’t think so,” Kazmi said when asked whether management notified her about the closures. “I think they just said that a tornado hit Building A and they’ll keep updating us.”
Kazmi said she and her roommates had planned to use the apartment’s fitness center and pool regularly.
“I was really excited for the gym specifically because me and my roommates actually had a plan to go to the gym every day and go swimming, but all of that is closed, so we can’t do any of that. It’s really frustrating,” Kazmi said.
She said she would also like to see a reduction in rent.
“I’d love a lower rent because I got this apartment because I thought the amenities were really nice,” Kazmi said. “Since I don’t have that, I feel like my rent should be cheaper.”
Students also report water interruptions
In addition to the closed amenities, students say they have experienced two emergency water shutoffs since moving into the complex.
The most recent interruption occurred Monday, Oct. 12, leaving some tenants without running water for several hours.
Kazmi said the interruptions have been particularly frustrating because students do not always receive advance notice.
“They don’t warn you in advance. They tell you when it starts, and then it could be shut off for like three hours, but you don’t know about it in advance, so you can’t prepare for it,” Kazmi said.
A parent of a student living at the complex also contacted us, raising concerns about the unavailable amenities, water interruptions and communication from management.
The parent said her daughter has approximately nine months remaining on her lease, representing nearly $7,000 in additional housing costs.
She questioned why students were not provided more information about the damage before moving in and why the property continues to advertise amenities that remain unavailable.
We contacted The Oasis San Antonio for a response to the students’ concerns.
In a statement, a representative for the apartment complex said incoming residents were notified of the storm damage and amenity closures before moving in.
The complex also said it is working with engineers and the City of San Antonio to determine the next steps for restoring the damaged facilities.
The apartment complex provided the following full statement:
“The safety of our residents remains our top priority as we work through recovery from the tornado. The pool, gym, clubhouse, and study rooms and business center remain closed while our engineering teams and the City of San Antonio evaluate next steps; our team is meeting with the city before the end of the month and hope to have more clarity on timing soon after. We are exploring alternatives for residents in the meantime.
“Incoming residents were notified of the storm-related damage and amenity closures prior to move-in.
“The water interruption on October 12 was caused by a leak in one of the building’s fire closets. We notified the full property and completed repairs the same day. This was an isolated incident and we have no reason to expect a recurrence.
“We are in regular communication with residents and encourage anyone with questions to reach out to our leasing office. We remain committed clear and responsive communication throughout the restoration process.
“Amenities are expected to be fully restored ahead of the next leasing cycle, which is reflected in how they’re currently presented to prospective residents.”
The apartment complex says it expects to have more information after meeting with city officials before the end of October.
Management did not address whether it would offer rent reductions or compensation to students in its statement.
For Ibrahim, the request is simple.
“We should get money back. I don’t know, just something,” she said.