The Harris County Civil Courts at Law building is seen in Houston, Saturday, April 26, 2025.
Jason Fochtman/Houston Chronicle
Think of the Harris County civil courts at law as the grown-up version of the justices of the peace.
Unlike the wildly underregulated world of JPs, here litigants can’t pick who hears their case and judges are actually required to have a law degree. These courts give Houstonians a chance to have a licensed attorney hear their JP disputes from scratch — such as eviction appeals — in addition to statutory eminent domain, debt claims and mid-sized lawsuits up to $325,000.
Judge, County Civil Court at Law No. 1: Jamie King
Jamie King ★★★1/2 — An experienced attorney, this Republican challenger wants to simplify court processes for self-represented litigants.
Sonia Lopez ★★1/2 — This recently appointed Democratic incumbent has an underwhelming resume and lacks ambition to improve court practices.
Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 2: Ebony N. Williams
Ebony N. Williams ★★★ — This Democratic lawyer’s compelling personal history won us over in a close-call endorsement.
Mark Montgomery ★★★ — A former Houston police officer, this experienced lawyer would make for a fine judge.
Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 3: LaShawn Williams
LaShawn Williams ★★★★ — This Democratic incumbent judge has more than earned another term.
Israel Garcia ★1/2 — A former justice of the peace, this Democrat-turned-Republican seems to care more about showmanship than justice.
Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 4: M. Monica Singh
M. Monica Singh ★★★★1/2 — This Democratic incumbent led the charge at Commissioners Court and in the Texas Legislature to address the backlog in Harris County civil courts at law.
John Donovan ★★★1/2 — A former trial judge and justice on the 14th court of appeals, this Republican challenger is certainly qualified but there’s no reason to remove the incumbent.
For Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 5: Jermaine Thomas
Jermaine Thomas ★★★ — Appointed to this newly created court by Commissioners Court, this Democratic judge has performed well on the bench.
Richard Lanier Fason ★★★ — This Republican challenger is a seasoned trial attorney and didn’t give us a reason to remove the incumbent.
We don’t need judges who add to the drama of these cases. We need adults.
Article continues below this ad
Good judges can handle an unwieldy caseload and balance efficiency with fairness. The best go above and beyond in making sure the people who land in their court — often without legal representation — are treated with dignity.
For Judge, County Civil Court at Law No. 1: Jamie King
Judge Sonia Lopez has only presided over this court for about eight months. County commissioners unanimously appointed the Democrat after Audrie Lawton-Evans stepped down to run against Abbie Kamin in the county attorney primary. Before that, Lopez served a short stint as an associate judge juggling evictions. That was also an appointed position.
So her nerves, then, might be understandable. But her defensiveness disappointed us.
Article continues below this ad
Republican challenger Jamie King was picked to run just two months ago, after primary winner Paul Coselli sadly passed away. She came to our screening remarkably prepared and wasted no time putting Lopez on the back foot.
King wants to simplify the process for self-represented litigants. This means removing nitpicky document submission rules, explaining things in plain English and using Zoom more to cut down on time-consuming, costly hearings where possible. She’d work to bring legal aid nonprofits to this courtroom and move away from serving attorneys through snail mail, notifying them electronically instead.
Lopez’s response? That’s the county clerk’s job. It is, but we’ve seen other more motivated judges use their position to nudge their court into the 21st century.
King is a civil litigator of 22 years, with hundreds of federal cases — including appellate work — and about 175 Harris County civil cases under her belt. She’s handled cases dealing with breach of fiduciary duty, secured transactions, construction and lien law. All the sort of stuff a civil court at law judge might be asked to rule on.
Lopez has never litigated a civil case in Harris County, though she did serve as in-house counsel for Lone Star College and for the Houston Federation of Teachers — work Lopez quickly asserted wasn’t political. But the rest of her resume is: She started her career as an intern to then-County Commissioner Sylvia Garcia and later served as chief of staff for state Rep. Ana Hernandez.
Article continues below this ad
Her thin legal resume left us wanting more. We recommend voters give King a shot.
For Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 2: Ebony N. Williams
Outgoing Judge Jim Kovach set a high bar, but voters have two solid choices to replace him.
On the Democratic side, Ebony Williams brings 15 years of legal experience, from managing thousands of cases and a staff of over 20 at the Texas Attorney General’s Office to running her own boutique firm. Her civil litigation background is on the light side, though she was recently appointed to serve on a civil court at law panel to offer her expertise on eminent domain disputes.
Her Republican opponent, Mark Montgomery, is a former Houston Police Department veteran of 25 years who worked in internal affairs and on the chief’s legal staff. He’s done civil law, but also family law, criminal work and mediation. He’s also represented families in excessive force discipline cases against school districts.
Article continues below this ad
Both Williams and Montgomery stressed fairness, efficiency and treating litigants respectfully. Both supported making court proceedings publicly accessible when possible and said they would perform weddings for same-sex couples.
Voters can’t go wrong with either candidate, but Williams won us over with her personal experience. Having gone through eviction herself, and lived out of her car as a newly graduated lawyer, she’s fiercely committed to giving litigants a voice, expanding legal-aid resources and spreading court appointments fairly instead of playing favorites.
Williams will do right by Houstonians from all walks of life. Voters should send her to the bench.
For Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 3: LaShawn Williams
We gotta give former Justice of the Peace Israel Garcia some credit. The former Democrat-turned-Republican is a total showman — entering rooms with a flourish of his signature cowboy hat and a flash of his gold watch. He’s also brazen: As JP, he flouted emergency eviction protections during COVID, booted Lone Star Legal Aid lawyers from his courtroom and stacked cases by the hundreds. (Eviction attorneys still shudder at the memory of his infamous 444-case eviction docket, or “the Valentine’s Day massacre.”)
Article continues below this ad
But at the very least, the guy is honest.
Even seasoned Democratic incumbent LaShawn Williams couldn’t believe it when Garcia candidly revealed he pocketed an extra $250,000 to $300,000 a year just from officiating weddings. As Garcia happily admitted, that side hustle blew his actual public salary out of the water. JPs, like other judges, can charge whatever they want for weddings and are allowed to keep the cash off the public record.
We like that it hadn’t even occurred to Williams what big business it can be. She said she charges a modest $125 and officiates only about two dozen a year.
In just about every way, Williams is the better candidate. A Conroe native and the daughter of a Vietnam War vet, she has 23 years of legal experience, including stints as a former prosecutor, in-house counsel to a national restaurant chain as well as various non-profits and co-founder of a civil litigation firm. She’s practiced across state, federal and appellate courts and earned solid marks from the Houston Bar Association.
Williams is evenhanded and poised under pressure. More importantly, she’s actually a grown-up — unlike Garcia, who threw a lame-duck tantrum after losing his reelection bid to James Lombardino in 2024. He reset hundreds of cases for when Lombardino would take the bench, leaving his successor with an administrative mess and a record-shattering 800-case eviction megadocket.
Garcia’s defense? Lombardino should have called the court staff in advance and just reset the cases further.
Struggling renters and landlords don’t deserve to be caught in the middle of Garcia’s petty games. Williams was first elected to this bench in 2018 and again in 2022. She has more than earned another term.
For Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 4: M. Monica Singh
Some judges are so good, they make endorsements easy. M. Monica Singh is one of those incumbents.
A first-generation immigrant born and raised in Houston, Singh has more than two decades of legal experience, specializing in trial advocacy and serving as lead counsel in over 100 jury trials. After she edged out her Republican opponent by a slim margin in 2022, becoming Harris County’s first elected Sikh judge, she got straight to work.
Singh has streamlined her docket to resolve 98% of her cases within a year, earning her the most ballots of all five civil court at law judges in a recent Houston Bar Association judicial preference poll. She’s made smart use of Zoom, early mediation and plain-language communication to simplify hearings and help self-represented litigants navigate the system better.
Dismayed by how heavily the housing crisis was crushing the civil courts, Singh led the charge on lobbying Harris County Commissioners Court for a dedicated associate judge position to handle evictions. She also worked with state legislators on a bipartisan basis to help establish a fifth county court at law to combat the chronic backlog. And she’s kept the lobbying up, making sure funding for that associate judge position was baked in permanently in this year’s county budget.
Her Republican opponent John Donovan spent decades as a trial judge on civil district benches and served on the 14th Court of Appeals before losing his seat in 2018. Now working as a mediator, Donovan brings plenty of judicial mileage, but fellow lawyers have historically given his performance a lukewarm rating and his resume simply doesn’t match Singh’s drive.
She deserves another term.
For Judge, Civil Court at Law No. 5: Jermaine Thomas
Last year, Commissioners Court unanimously appointed Jermaine Thomas to this newly created court and voters should keep him there.
This county court at law is so fresh it’s still without a permanent physical courtroom, but Thomas has hit the ground running. He has maintained an efficient docket, with most cases resolved within a year.
Before that, he was appointed as Harris County’s first-ever associate judge to juggle evictions — a tough task, but one he seems to have handled deftly. Out of over 12,000 eviction appeals that landed before him, only 2% were then re-appealed — and none were ultimately overturned, he told us.
Thomas clearly cares about the cases he handles and the lives they represent. Raised in Sunnyside by a single mom on public housing and SNAP benefits, he knows what it’s like to do homework by candlelight. “It wasn’t because we were trying to set a mood,” he joked, “it’s because the lights were off.”
He credits former Mayor Sylvester Turner for pushing him to finish law school and giving him a 22-year home at his law firm. Thomas earned scrutiny for his involvement in an affordable housing project that Turner’s own housing director alleged was being guided to a politically connected developer. While Turner ultimately nixed the deal to avoid even the appearance of impropriety, Thomas stands by it. He says the public housing project was sorely needed and stood on its own merits.
“I’m not ashamed of my participation,” he said. “I think we were doing good work.”
He’s a stickler for the law, but he also knows people are human. That includes himself. Thomas is up front about two public reprimands on his record from years ago: one involving a self-represented bankruptcy matter during a family and financial crisis, and another involving a missed medical bill in a client settlement. He took full responsibility and said he learned hard lessons from both.
Republican opponent Richard Lanier Fason is a seasoned trial attorney with nearly three decades of civil experience and sharp ideas for speeding up dockets. But Fason didn’t give us a reason to boot an incumbent who, despite his imperfect past, is already proving he knows how to handle the job.
Thomas has earned a full term.
Who are you voting for in this race?
Did the editorial board get it right? Let us know.
Most RecentTop Responses
Fred E. K
Houston, TX
10/16/26
Not to follow your endorsements on any race
Mark S
Beaumont, TX
10/16/26
FLORES
Becky T
Conroe, TX
10/15/26
Hinojosa
Anastassios T
Houston, TX
10/14/26
Himojosa
Sheryl P
Houston, TX
10/14/26
Gina Hinajosa is my choice! I voted for Greg Abbott and believed in him in his first term. Unfortunately, now he is bought and paid for by billionaires. He had his chance to help texas and he sold us out. It’s time to give someone else a chance.
See More Responses