America’s most influential podcaster appears convinced that James Talarico should be president. First, however, the young Texan Democrat has to convince his own party.
Talarico, 36, a state representative, former teacher and seminarian whose speeches are woven through with references to Scripture, is in a primary battle for a shot at a US Senate seat that Democrats believe could be within reach, especially if Republican voters oust the longstanding incumbent.
Joe Rogan was won over after hearing Talarico say that he sees politics “less as left versus right and more as top versus bottom … We have far more in common than the stuff that divides us and that’s a threat to their power, it’s a threat to their wealth.”
Rogan, who is often credited with persuading disaffected young men to get out and vote for Donald Trump in 2024 through his podcast, exclaimed: “You need to run for president — we need someone who’s actually a good person.”
Talarico has been propelled to national prominence fighting against another rising star of the party: Jasmine Crockett, a second-term congresswoman from the left-wing progressive caucus.
Crockett, 44, a former public defender, has drawn the spotlight for her folksy delivery of sharp attacks on Republicans, making this the most-watched Democratic showdown of the year before polling day on Tuesday.

Jasmine Crockett speaking in Dallas this month
LM OTERO/AP
It presents Texas Democrats with the same moderate versus radical dilemma that the party faces nationally when it comes to picking its candidates. Do they opt for a measured white man who namechecks Jesus or a firebrand black woman known for her unapologetic insults?
Democratic analysts have seized on the large turnout in the primary as a sign of an energised electorate. Democrat turnout is 276 per cent higher than at the same point four years ago, at about 870,000 voters, while Republican turnout is up by 158 per cent to just over 730,000.
“Every time there’s a big competitive primary on the Democratic side, Democrats have won the popular vote,” said Joe Caiazzo, a Democratic operative who worked on Bernie Sanders’s presidential campaign in 2020.
“What this race represents is a preview of the different factions that will be a part of the 2028 presidential primary process,” he said. “Having these two wings that are represented by two compelling candidates shows that when they engage, more people turn out.”
Referring to the last great hope of Texas Democrats, Beto O’Rourke, who lost a Senate challenge to Ted Cruz in 2018 by a margin of 2.6 points, Caiazzo added: “When Beto ran for Senate, there was no primary and he lost. What this presents is the opportunity for ginning up the base ahead of the fall.”
Terry Anderson, a professor of politics at Texas A&M University and a veteran observer of Democrats’ perennially dashed hopes of a state-wide win, believes that only one outcome would give the party any chance of winning the Senate seat.
“I think that it’s a lot better in this state to have a white male,” Anderson said. “I mean, Barack Obama didn’t win Texas, didn’t get that close. I think Crockett would be great as senator but that’s not the point. I don’t think she has as good a chance as Talarico.”

Talarico speaking in Round Rock, Texas, last September
BRANDON BELL/GETTY IMAGES
Crockett is acutely aware of the received wisdom that a left-wing black woman stands no chance in Texas, even as the rather scant polling has her ahead of Talarico. Betting markets make him the favourite by some margin.
“This is bigger than Texas y’all. The entire country is watching us,” Crockett told a rally this week in Killeen, a military town 60 miles north of Austin. “Don’t worry what misogynists think, what racists think because frankly they’re not going to vote for a Democrat anyway … We’ve got to focus on doing what is right.”
She criticises Talarico as a relative unknown but that attack was blunted when he was interviewed by the late-night host Stephen Colbert last week and CBS refused to air it after a threat from the Trump administration to enforce “equal time” rules requiring that all candidates receive the same attention. This has never previously been enforced on late night shows and follows an official inquiry into Talarico’s appearance on ABC’s daytime chat show The View. “I think that Donald Trump is worried that we’re about to flip Texas,” said Talarico. Colbert posted the interview on YouTube and it went viral, gathering nearly nine million views.
Texas watchers say that Democrats’ best chance for the Senate election would be if Talarico were to go up against Ken Paxton, the controversial attorney-general seeking to replace John Cornyn, the senator since 2002. In a Republican primary notable for mud-slinging, the latest attack ad backed by Cornyn opens by declaring: “Crooked Ken Paxton cheated on his wife. She’s divorcing him on biblical grounds. So now Paxton’s wrecking another home sleeping around with a married mother-of-seven.”
Paxton, whose wife filed for divorce last year, hit back with an ad featuring his daughter saying, “My dad is a really good guy — loves God, he loves his family and he loves his country.”
Paxton’s grassroots popularity is driven by his loyalty to President Trump and aggressive legal actions against abortion, gender treatment and immigration. Trump, who was due to hold a rally in Texas on Friday, has so far refused to pick between the rivals, who are polling neck-and-neck.

Ken Paxton
JULIO CORTEZ/AP
Vinny Minchillo, a veteran Republican operative who worked on the 2024 Trump campaign in Texas, said that some conservatives in the wider Texas electorate could give Talarico a look. “He quotes from Scripture all the time,” he said. “He’s very calm. So if you’re that suburban mom who’s not happy about Paxton’s background, you look at James Talarico and go, well, he seems like a nice fella.”
Minchillo believes Trump could be persuaded by the bottom line to help Cornyn. “The president understands money. If he could get Cornyn into the general, that will save them a lot, I think one or two hundred million dollars. I feel folks in Washington are prepared to push $200 million into the state in order to get Ken Paxton over the line in the general. That’s what they think it’s going to take … A lot of this is predicated on Talarico making it. If it’s Crockett, this is a much easier lift for either Republican.”
The presence of a competitive third candidate in the Republican race means it could go to a run-off without a decisive outcome on Tuesday, adding to the costs already incurred — $88 million by Republicans and $22 million for Democrats on advertising alone — making this the most expensive Senate primary in American history.