The internet thinks so. I’ve got thoughts.

Let me be honest with you: Courage the Cowardly Dog lives in my bones.

Growing up, I was a scared kid. I mean genuinely, embarrassingly scared of everything. Shadows. Sounds. The dark. The idea of something lurking just outside what I could see. And yet, every time that opening theme hit and that little pink dog showed up on my screen, I was glued. Because something about Courage made sense to me in a way I couldn’t articulate as a kid. Here was a character who was, at all times, completely terrified, and who did what needed to be done anyway. Not because he stopped being afraid. He never stopped being afraid. He just loved Muriel enough that fear wasn’t the final word. Now, “Do it scared.” is my motto.

Looking back now, some of those episodes were genuinely cinematic in a way I didn’t have the language to understand when I was little. Complex, surreal, emotionally layered storytelling that helped me start to fall in love with the cinematography of a story before I even knew what that meant. Courage the Cowardly Dog was an early teacher. It taught me that terror and beauty can live in the same frame.

So when I found out there’s an El Paso connection to this show, even a rumored one, I had to dig in.

The El Paso Urban Legend Of A Missing Couple

The fan theory goes like this: the elderly couple at the center of the show, the warm and gentle Muriel and her grumpy, cold husband Eustace, were inspired by a real couple who vanished from El Paso’s Kern Place neighborhood in 1957. Their names were William and Margaret Patterson.

William and Margaret Patterson disappeared from their Piedmont Drive home on the night of March 5, or early the morning of March 6, 1957. They left behind nearly everything: unwashed dishes in the sink, clothes laid out on the bed, utilities still running, a costly fur coat sitting unclaimed at the cleaners, a Cadillac, a boat, property in Guaymas, Mexico, and Margaret’s cat, Tommy.

Nobody has seen or heard from them since.

The parallels fans draw to Courage are hard to ignore, even if they’re purely circumstantial. A neighbor described Margaret as “a tiny, petite woman” who was kind and sweet, while William consistently came across as mean and unfriendly. Sound like anyone? A sweet, gentle wife. A cold, grumpy husband. A house in the middle of nowhere with something deeply wrong going on just beneath the surface. The theory also leans into one of the wilder explanations that’s floated around the case for decades: UFO abduction. As in, the Pattersons were taken by aliens, which, if you’ve seen more than two episodes of Courage, you know is practically a Tuesday in Nowhere, Kansas.

READ MORE: THE MOST TERRIFYING EL PASO URBAN LEGENDS

The fan theory holds that the show’s creator, John R. Dilworth, either knew of the Patterson case or was directly inspired by it, shaping not just the personalities of Muriel and Eustace, but the very premise of the show: a couple who are inexplicably isolated, surrounded by supernatural threats, and ultimately at the mercy of forces no one fully understands.

The Real El Paso Cold Case That Remains Unsolved

Here’s where we have to pump the brakes a little, because the truth is, Dilworth has never confirmed any of this. There is even a whole theory about Nowhere, Kansas being based on a place in Truth or Consequences, New Mexico but sadly, our Southwest cousin is also not the inspiration.

The actual confirmed inspiration for the iconic Nowhere farmhouse was far more grounded. Dilworth has pointed to his former girlfriend’s family farm and the bleak rural isolation captured in Dorothea Lange’s photography as the visual and emotional source material. The isolation, the vulnerability of an elderly couple in a vast and indifferent landscape, that came from real American imagery, not from a cold case in El Paso.

Maybe Muriel and Eustace were even based off of this specific Dorothea Lange photo!

There’s also a detail that the more skeptical corners of the internet love to point out: the Pattersons left behind a cat named Tommy. Not a dog. If the legend were clean and tidy, Courage would be a cat. He is very much not a cat.

So no, this is not a confirmed origin story. It is, by most honest measures, a piece of internet folklore, the kind that grows because it wants to be true, because the connections feel poetic in a way that’s hard to shake.

But Here Is the Thing About El Paso Urban Legends

The Patterson case is one of the most enduring unsolved mysteries in this city’s history. By the time they slipped from the news cycle, the Pattersons had already slipped into the realm of El Paso urban legend, with theories ranging from UFO abduction to Cold War espionage to foul play.

And the foul play angle is genuinely dark. In 1984, a witness named Reynaldo Nangaray came forward to say he had found blood near the garage water heater and a piece of human scalp on the propeller of William’s boat shortly after the disappearance, but had not come forward sooner due to fear over his immigration status. He died in a car accident just two years later, before that testimony could be fully investigated. The El Paso Sheriff’s Office has kept the case open for nearly 70 years.

There’s even a haunted house angle. The first family to move into the Patterson home on Piedmont Drive, in 1972, reported seeing the ghost of a woman in 1950s clothing and the apparition of a cat, likely Tommy, sitting on the kitchen counter, tail moving, waiting to be fed.

So whether or not Dilworth ever set foot in El Paso, whether or not he ever heard the name Patterson, the mythology fits. A mysteriously vanished couple. A house full of unanswered questions. A pet left behind. Theories wild enough to involve outer space. If you were going to build a show around the dread of unexplained things lurking at the edges of ordinary life, El Paso already wrote that story in 1957.

El Paso Is Still Just As Weird As Nowhere

Is the Patterson connection to Courage the Cowardly Dog confirmed? No. Is it the kind of local legend worth knowing? Absolutely.

Because this city has always had a gift for producing stories that are too strange and too specific to be fiction, yet too unresolved to be fully real. The Pattersons walked out of their house on Piedmont Drive sixty-eight years ago and never came back. El Paso never forgot about them. And if a pink, terrified little dog in Nowhere, Kansas spent a decade facing down monsters to protect the people he loved, well. We’ll claim the inspiration whether the credits say so or not.

READ MORE: THE LEGEND OF DEVIL DAVE AND THE DE SOTO HOTEL

Some of us grew up learning that you do what needs to be done, even when you’re scared. Courage would understand.

Have tips on the Patterson case? The El Paso County Sheriff’s Office still actively takes leads at 915-538-2292.

Haunted El Paso Neighborhoods

The Oasis Outside of El Paso: Cornudas, Texas

This Guy Bought a Whole Texas Town & Turned It Into a Wild West Party Oasis.

Gallery Credit: Courtesy: Jon Jasniak via YouTube

Monteleones Back Alley Stakehouse And Dinner Theater in El Paso!

Gary Monteleone runs a series of themed restaurants here in El Paso and one of them offers an amazing murder mystery dinner theater experience where the audience gets to participate by investigating clues left by the cast, guessing who the killer was, and enjoying a pretty decent meal!

Gallery Credit: Grizz