TCU will implement a new mid-semester grade policy beginning in Spring 2027, Provost Floyd Wormley announced Monday. 

Wormley is moving forward with a measure the Faculty Senate unanimously rejected earlier this month over concerns about shared governance.

In an email to faculty and staff, Wormley said the policy will require mid‑semester letter grades of A–F for all first‑year students, all first‑semester transfer students and any student earning a C‑ or below at the time grades are submitted. The change will replace the current U‑grade system.

TCU Provost Floyd L. Wormley, Jr. speaks to the class of 2028 at the Frogs First Chancellor Assembly, August 17th, 2024. The assembly officially welcomes the newest members of the TCU community. (TCU360/Tyler Chan) (Tyler Chan)

“Letter grades at mid‑term will help our newest students navigate their TCU academic experience and consider, seek, and utilize TCU’s Student Success strategies, if needed,” Wormley said in the email. 

The university will wait until 2027 to implement the policy so it can develop and pilot a grade pass‑through from D2L to PeopleSoft, giving faculty “additional time to prepare for the policy’s implementation,” he said.

The policy was developed after nearly three years of discussion and input was received from the Provost Council, deans, the Faculty Senate Executive Committee, the Faculty Senate and the Student Government Association, according to the email. 

“The framework for this policy underwent multiple revisions in response to their suggestions and concerns,” Wormley said in the email.

But some faculty members dispute that process.

Earlier this month, the TCU Faculty Senate voted unanimously to reject mandatory midterm grade reporting, saying the proposal appeared to have been developed without meaningful faculty input. 

The Student Government Association had requested full midterm grades for all students in 10000‑ and 20000‑level courses, including first‑year transfer students, with upper‑division students receiving grades only if their performance was unsatisfactory.

The proposal reached the Provost’s office without following established shared governance procedures, Dr. Brandon Manning, an associate professor of English and president of TCU’s chapter of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP), wrote in an email to faculty.

Manning said the concerns extend beyond the grading policy. 

“The past two years have signaled a shift in shared governance with the upper administration using edicts and workarounds as their approach to the faculty and shared governance,” he said in the email to faculty.

“The Faculty Senate and other committees go through painstaking detail and outreach to make sure that changes and policies are warranted and benefit both students and faculty,” Manning added. “When this process is cut short, plans and policies are hastily decided upon that either require immediate change or yield unsatisfactory results.”

Concerns about the process are not new. In a 2024 letter to faculty, the Faculty Senate’s Faculty Relations Committee said a University Council vote initiated by Wormley “seems to have been an intentional process to circumvent the faculty,” citing procedural violations and a lack of consultation on academic proposals previously rejected by the Senate. 

The committee unanimously called the vote invalid and requested that it be rescinded.