Nate Paul, right, looks on during an auction of one of his former World Class Holdings properties Tuesday at the Travis County Courthouse in Austin.

Nate Paul, right, looks on during an auction of one of his former World Class Holdings properties Tuesday at the Travis County Courthouse in Austin.

Paul FlahiveTrustee for the lienholder Mike Riley, left, conducts an auction for 707 E. Cesar Chavez while embattled developer Nate Paul, right, records the proceedings Tuesday.

Trustee for the lienholder Mike Riley, left, conducts an auction for 707 E. Cesar Chavez while embattled developer Nate Paul, right, records the proceedings Tuesday.

Paul FlahiveNate Paul, left, did not register to bid but looked on as his former property was sold Tuesday.

Nate Paul, left, did not register to bid but looked on as his former property was sold Tuesday.

Paul FlahiveAn Austin developer has acquired the IHOP at 707 E. Cesar Chavez St. following an auction Tuesday at the Travis County Courthouse.

An Austin developer has acquired the IHOP at 707 E. Cesar Chavez St. following an auction Tuesday at the Travis County Courthouse.

Austin American-Statesman

Natin “Nate” Paul’s battle to keep a valuable piece of property on the edge of the high-rise-strewn Rainey Street has ended, as the lot at 707 E. Cesar Chavez was auctioned off Tuesday on the steps of the Travis County Courthouse.

Only three groups competed for the foreclosed property in a slow, low-volume auction that drew more than 100 bids over two hours. Most of the bidding came from Cesar Rainey LLC, which held the defaulted note, and the eventual winner, Austin-based real estate investment firm Travis County Exchange Corp.

Article continues below this ad

The largely undeveloped site, which hosts only an IHOP along Interstate 35, was valued at $27 million by the county appraisal district but sold for just over $12.7 million.

Paul’s World Class Holdings initially took out a $2 million loan on the property in 2017. The troubled real estate investment firm defaulted on the loan in 2021. 

For the past year Paul has struggled to hang on to the site through a series of court room maneuvers, including a bankruptcy that was later dismissed for being filed in “bad faith.” 

He has accused the lienholder, Cesar Rainey Street LLC, which purchased the loan from the original lender, of stonewalling him by failing to provide a final payoff amount, denying him the opportunity to purchase the note outright.

Article continues below this ad

That number was disclosed as more than $5.1 million in court documents. It was also the opening bid Tuesday. 

The claims were repeated as recently as Monday, when a company called Yarrington Exit — managed by Austin real estate investor Jimmy Nassour — asked a state district court for a temporary restraining order, saying it was trying to purchase the property from Paul but that lienholders were intentionally preventing the sale to “capture the substantial excess equity.”

Yarrington Exit alleged in court filings that Cesar Rainey hoped to capture the building at auction as a credit purchase, for the amount of the existing loan. 

Cesar Rainey LLC increased the amount of sale by more than $5 million over dozens of bids. 

Article continues below this ad

The bidding grew so high that it appeared Travis County Exchange Corporation had to have additional $500,000 cashier’s checks rush-delivered to the courthouse.

The auction rules required bidders to prove they had the money on hand. 

Trustee Mark Riley, who was conducting the auction, was also bidding on behalf of Cesar Rainey, to the dismay of other bidders.

Travis County Exchange Corp. representatives protested Cesar Rainey LLC’s participation in the auction, saying it was unfair that the company was allowed to demonstrate it had adequate funds in its bank account rather than present cashier’s checks on site.

Article continues below this ad

Representatives were still arguing the point as the deal was finalized, and their property secured. 

Paul wasn’t the only interested pary to have found himself facing legal woes, the owners of Cesar Rainey Street LLC have also been implicated in unrelated crimes.

It wasn’t immediately clear whether any of the roughly $7 million in surplus proceeds will go to World Class Holdings. According to the original loan documents filed with the court, the company should receive a substantial portion, minus fees.

Paul watched the bidding dressed in blue Nike sneakers, a blue Ralph Lauren button-up shirt and what appeared to be a Richard Mille watch that retails for about $175,000. Once one of Austin’s largest property owners, he recorded the proceedings on his phone as the property was sold. He declined to comment after the sale.

Article continues below this ad

It was not clear earlier Tuesday whether the auction would take place. A Travis County district court set a hearing for May 12 to address the Yarrington Exit claims, and World Class Holdings asked the 3rd District Court of Appeals last week to stay the foreclosure. The court did not act ahead of the sale, allowing the auction to go forward.

Representatives for Travis County Exchange Corp. said the property will, for now, continue operating as an IHOP.