Houston Independent School District Superintendent Mike Miles talks to a Audrey H. Lawson Middle School student while visiting classes Wednesday, Sept. 6, 2023 in Houston.
Yi-Chin Lee/Staff photographer
Three years ago, some parents welcomed the news that the state would be taking over its largest school district. The felony corruption, the shouting matches on the board, the schools failing generations of kids. Perhaps it takes a takeover to get these things right.
This editorial board was hopeful for positive change at Houston ISD. The takeover came with three clear exit criteria: no schools failing year after year, no board dysfunction and full special education compliance.
After three years, we wish we could be talking about success in meeting those criteria, and about the transition back to local control. Instead, the district is under federal investigation for disability discrimination. So much for it taking a takeover.
Article continues below this ad
Last week, after HISD unveiled plans to consolidate some special education services, parents waited anxiously to see if their children were among those reassigned to new schools. News of the change trickled out in leaked documents and hush hush meetings.
Then, late Friday, news broke that the federal government launched an investigation into the district for special education violations.
“Placement decisions must be made individually, based on each student’s needs, rather than by blanket policies that segregate students by disability category,” said Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights Kimberly Richey in a statement. “The allegations described here are alarming. The Trump administration will fully investigate this situation and fight to ensure every child with a disability receives the education and support guaranteed under the law.”
Leah Binkovitz, a columnist and member of this editorial board, spoke with panicked parents. One Heights mom explained that her son started at his current school with physical restraints but now has friends and communicates with a special device. He’ll have to start over at a new school.
Article continues below this ad
A dad of a high schooler is waiting to break the news to his “not-quite non-verbal” son that he’ll have to leave Bellaire High School where a swim coach he’s known since elementary school lets him practice with the team. The dad fears a sudden switch could lead to a harmful developmental regression.
What happened to the Texas ideal of school choice? Do the parental rights Texas voters enshrined in the state constitution not apply to families with disabled children?
Even the most ardent takeover supporters of the state takeover have to wonder what the heck is going on here.
This editorial board is cautiously optimistic that the federal investigation will protect these families. But this is the same presidential administration that wanted to do away with the Department of Education altogether, so we are heavy on the caution. Meanwhile, the state education agency has encouraged families to submit individual complaints if they have concerns.
It’s not all bad news. HISD has made progress on two of the three criteria for the takeover to end. Fans of Mike Miles, the state-appointed superintendent, will note that test scores and state accountability ratings have risen. We’ve worried about how those gains have been achieved, but the trend holds.
Article continues below this ad
As for HISD board dysfunction, you would think the state’s hand-picked board of managers wouldn’t squabble. And that’s been mostly the case. But even there, the state has intervened and abruptly kicked off managers who, perhaps coincidentally, dared to question the administration’s decisions.
That brings us back to special education compliance.
We thought there was really nowhere to go but up. Not too long ago, the state was in hot water with the feds after a Houston Chronicle investigation revealed it had been artificially capping the number of students who could qualify for special education services. And HISD has had a state conservator overseeing special education since before the takeover. So after the first year of the takeover, when it looked like the district was at least holding more compliance meetings with those students, there was reason to cheer.
Article continues below this ad
It’s possible that, as the district has argued, consolidating students with some of the most intense needs will actually help give them a better learning environment. Teachers can collaborate and share resources, for example. But to implement a change with such short notice for our most vulnerable students and with essentially no input from parents means any “trust me” goodwill HISD may have had remaining is going, going, gone.
We certainly didn’t think the alarm would be sounding from the Trump administration. But we’re grateful it has.