CHICAGO — Another strong outing from Spencer Arrighetti belied the stuff that produced it. The outcome on an overcast afternoon at Wrigley Field perhaps marked another step in a starter’s emergence.
After his five scoreless innings in the Houston Astros’ 4-2 win over the Chicago Cubs, Arrighetti offered a blunt assessment of a start Friday that lowered his major-league ERA this season to 1.32.
“That is the worst that I’ve felt about the way I was throwing the ball all year,” Arrighetti said. “Just didn’t feel like things were coming out the way that I wanted them to. The only answer I had for it was try to make an adjustment in the game and I felt I did a good enough job of that to keep runs off the board.”
Five innings matched the shortest of Arrighetti’s seven starts since the Astros recalled him from Triple-A. Navigating a slew of traffic with suboptimal command against a potent lineup — albeit one sputtering the past two weeks — was still notable.
Just four clubs began Friday with a higher OPS than the Cubs. Just one had drawn more walks. Arrighetti issued four walks and hit two batters, gifting opportunities to an offense built to convert them.
Afterward, Arrighetti said he had trouble gripping his pitches. That led to less “leverage” on his curveball and sweeper, which both averaged 2-3 inches less horizontal break than in his previous seven outings. An issue was most evident in a third inning that threatened to spiral.
Arrighetti missed with four pitches to Nico Hoerner for a leadoff walk. A full-count curveball then clipped Michael Busch. Arrighetti loosed a sinker that ran inside and caught Alex Bregman in the ribs, loading the bases and leading the right-hander to scream into his glove.
Manager Joe Espada said Arrighetti in-game “expressed just having a tough time gripping the baseball.” Arrighetti said he struggled to explain it but “it wasn’t like a grip strength problem, it wasn’t like I felt weak, it wasn’t like I felt pain or anything. Just the balls felt really slick.”
Catcher Christian Vázquez said they stayed with Arrighetti’s breaking pitches anyway, despite the lesser movement, as it seemed the control on them was better. Arrighetti landed a first-pitch curveball up and away for a strike to Ian Happ and another in a similar spot to get a whiff for strike three.
Seiya Suzuki saw three breaking balls, fouled away two and popped up a curveball to shortstop Jeremy Peña. Arrighetti then back-doored a sweeper that Michael Conforto hit to Peña, whose high throw was corralled by first baseman Christian Walker to end an escape.
Arrighetti also stranded two runners in his first inning and worked around back-to-back one-out walks in the fifth. He needed 89 pitches to finish five innings. But he handed a four-run lead to Houston’s bullpen on a day when his arsenal was not at its sharpest.
“Obviously, when I load the bases by walking and hitting people and then don’t let those runs score that feels good, but at the same time the way I got to that position it feels like I’m beating myself a little bit,” Arrighetti said.
“I feel like that’ll be my focus this week is just trying to figure out what the grip problem was. If I need to tweak something, I’ll tweak something. It definitely helps build confidence in a way, but that’s not the way you want to be building confidence more often than not.”
To mark it as a step in Arrighetti’s maturation is still inviting. Another is authoring the kind of consistency he is providing a pitching staff in dire need of it, even if the mid-May sample size remains small.
The Astros are 14-20 since they summoned Arrighetti from the minors on April 15. Arrighetti has started six of those wins, leading a rotation that is still without Hunter Brown and Cristian Javier and just placed Lance McCullers Jr. on the injured list this week.
Arrighetti’s 1.32 ERA is the ninth-lowest in Astros franchise history for a pitcher in his first seven starts of a season. The two to compile a lower one since 2000 are Justin Verlander and Roger Clemens — company that conveys the ballast he is providing a Houston club that is 10 games under .500.
“You can just tell the level of confidence this young man is pitching (with),” Espada said. “He knows that, ‘I could be against the ropes, but I have enough weapons to get me to punch back and get back into this fight.’”
After taking a no-hit bid into the eighth inning in his last outing, Arrighetti allowed two hits across his five innings Friday. Those were back-to-back flares in the first inning by Bregman, a single at 67.8 mph off the bat, and Happ, whose 62.4 mph bloop fell for a double.
The Cubs averaged a 79.4 mph exit velocity on 12 balls put into play against Arrighetti, with just two that reached the 95 mph hard-hit threshold, according to Statcast. That number pleased Arrighetti more than his ERA following another positive outing.
“Even when guys are putting bat to ball, they’re missing it a little bit, and I think those things are a better predictor of how I’m actually doing in terms of throwing it,” Arrighetti said.
“Not every time I’ll load the bases and get out of it scot-free. So I feel like having that is awesome, but at the same time I think there’s other things that go into it in terms of actually measuring how a pitcher is doing. So I’ve still got a lot of stuff to work on. I’m in no way complacent.”