Edward Pinto, Co-Director and Senior Fellow ([email protected])
Tobias Peter, Co-Director and Senior Fellow ([email protected])
AEI.org/housing | April 28, 2023, Revised December 15, 2023
Link to AEI HMIs: https://www.aei.org/housing/housing-market-indicators/
Link to AEI Housing & Economic Analysis Toolkit (HEAT)t: https://heat.aeihousingcenter.org/toolkit
Link to AEI GOOD NEIGHBORS Housing Displacement Toolkit (draft): https://aeihousinggoodneighborstoolkit/
We grant permission to reuse this presentation, as long as you cite as the source: AEI Housing Center, www.aei.org/housing.
Disclosure: Pinto and Peter have a financial relationship with Places Platform LLC, which is interested in meeting housing supply shortages through walkable oriented development and in the development of metrics for all types of real estate.
Houston: why by-right light-touch density works
“Houston’s urban redevelopment mainly can be attributed to its distinctly liberal approach to land use, a stark departure from cities with single-use zoning and large lot requirements, which constrain development of higher density housing types and act as barriers to housing supply.”1
In 1998, Houston policymakers reduced the minimum lot size requirement from 5,000 square feet to effectively 1,400 square feet within the city’s I-610 Inner Loop. In 2013, the reform was expanded to the rest of the city.
The Inner Loop contains 5% of the land area of Harris County (including all of downtown Houston).
From 2005-2018 nearly 75,000 new units were added.
This is two times that of San Francisco and Oakland combined, which together had a similar land area as the Inner Loop, but have housing regulations that discourage housing development.
Harris County also had more than San Diego’s and twice Atlanta’s city-wide housing production since 2010.2
This reform has permitted 3 townhouses or 3 small-lot detached houses to be built vs. only 1 previously.
From 2005-2018, 28,000 small lot SF 1-4 infill units have been built, comprising more than one-third of the housing construction within Houston’s Inner Loop.3
During this time period, Houston’s combined standard detached single-family development and multifamily construction per capita have also exceeded the national rate of construction for these housing typologies.
On Houston map on the right which frames the Inner Loop), a substantial amount of post-1998 1-4 unit construction (including condos) is visible.
These policies have contributed to the city’s housing affordability. In spite of decades of rapid growth, the median house price in Houston remains below the national median, and rents in Houston are about 1/2 those in Los Angeles.4
1 John Park et al., “Re-Taking Stock: Understanding How Trends in the Housing Stock and Gentrification are connected in Houston and Harris County,” Kinder Institute at Rice University, April 6, 2021.
2 Ibid.
3 Ibid.
Source: AEI Housing Center, www.AEI.org/housing.
Houston: By-right light touch density in the form of reduced minimum lot size unleashed American ingenuity by swarms of property owners, small businesses, and workers
We analyzed about 17,000 in-fill townhomes built from 2000 onward largely a result of the reduced minimum lot size requirement implemented in 1998.
This small scale development was undertaken by a total of about 3,000 unique builders/developers.
Over the period 2012-2022, the nation’s 19 largest builders accounted for 41% of Houston metro’s new home construction, yet they only accounted for 8% of the 2000-2022 in-fill townhome construction (much of which was on larger vacant parcels).
While 17 of the 19 largest builders were active in Houston, only 7 were active in building LTD in-fill townhomes, with one large national builder (David Weekley) accounting for a 3.4 ppt. share.
Top 5 Builders/Developers
# of Townhomes
Share
Intown Builders
1838
10.5%
Perry Homes
1247
7.1%
CMC Enterprises Inc
899
5.2%
Contemporary Garden Homes LTD LLP
766
4.4%
Cityside Homes LLC
758
4.3%
Takeaway: Government just needs to get out of the way. The market will take care of the rest.
Housing abundance with Light-Touch Density + Keep It Simple Stupid (KISS) = unleash the swarms!
Tale of two cities: Houston and Los Angeles – housing abundance is the key to reducing displacement
In spite of decades of rapid growth, the median house price in Houston remains below the national median, with home prices and rents being about 1/3 and 1/2 of those in Los Angeles (LA).1
Cost of living compared to national average: NYC +126%, SF:+ 70%, LA: +49%, and Houston: -6%.
Since 2012, Houston’s regional response to homelessness known as ‘The Way Home’ is credited with housing over 28,000 individuals and families, with 90% still housed to this day, with an overall reduction in homelessness of 62% since 2011.2 LA’s already extreme 2012 rate doubled over a similar time period.
2012-2022: in 2012 Houston started with low displacement pressure and rate; in 2022 displacement pressure is moderate, and its already low displacement had dropped by 62%. Recent homeless counts increased 3% from 2022 to 2023.
2012-2022: in 2012 Los Angeles (LA) already had extreme displacement pressure (DP) and severe displacement rate (DR). In 2022 both are extreme, with DR having doubled. We estimate that 60%-75% of the increase in LA’s DR due to increase in DP. LA’s DR in 2022 was 14 times Houston’s, up from 2.5 times in 2012. Recent homeless counts worsened, increasing 9% from 2022 to 2023.
1 “Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI)” and “Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI)“ https://www.zillow.com/research/data/ accessed on 4/26/2022
2 https://www.thewayhomehouston.org/, https://www.houstontx.gov/homeless/, www.AEIHousin.org