The Harris County Civil Courts at Law building is seen in Houston, Saturday, April 26, 2025.

The Harris County Civil Courts at Law building is seen in Houston, Saturday, April 26, 2025.

Jason Fochtman/Houston Chronicle

A high school math teacher is suing Houston ISD and seeking a pause to district contract nonrenewals after he reported educator misconduct to the state and was proposed for contract nonrenewal himself.

If a Harris County judge rules in the teacher’s favor, it could pause a process that led hundreds of teachers being terminated or resigning under HISD’s state-appointed leadership.

It is unclear how many teachers this school year were proposed for contract nonrenewal, but in previous years HISD has recommended ending contracts for between about 700 and 1,400 teachers.

Article continues below this ad

The district typically asks the board of managers not to renew contracts for teachers with low evaluation ratings or those who fail to meet professional standards.

The Chavez High School math teacher, Chidiebere Ochi-Okorie, was removed from class and presented with a proposed nonrenewal a day after he reported educator misconduct to the state, according to documents filed in Harris County Civil Court. Judge Erica Hughes will consider a request for a temporary injunction at a Wednesday hearing.

“We’re not asking for money. We’re not asking for reinstatement. We’re not asking not to go through with the norenewal process. We’re just asking (for) a pause,” his attorney, Omer Khwaja, said in an interview.

Article continues below this ad

Alleged firings as retaliation

Ochi-Okorie reported April 29 that Chavez’s principal, Karol Galindo, and assistant principal, Juliana Ingram, had engaged in “unlawful workload directives, appraisal manipulation, and personnel-record violations,” court records show.

The next day, at 5:20 a.m., Ochi-Okorie sent “a written anti-retaliation notice to HISD,” according to the lawsuit. About five hours later, Galindo removed Ochi-Okorie from class and presented a nonrenewal memorandum dated April 29.

The memo appears to quote Ochi-Okorie’s complaint to the state, according to his attorney, Khwaja.

“The memorandum was predated — it was drafted on April 30 in Plaintiff’s presence, establishing that the adverse outcome was predetermined,” the court filing says.

Article continues below this ad

COURT FILING: Teacher union leader files federal civil rights lawsuit against Houston ISD

State rules

State law forbids retaliation against a public employee who reports legal violations, and the case argues that the Texas Education Agency is an appropriate authority to report violations to. The state’s code of ethics for educators also forbids retaliation against someone who files a complaint with the State Board for Educator Certification.

HISD has denied “each and every allegation” in a court filing. The district also argued that the teacher did not comply with the district’s grievance process before filing in court, as required by state law.

Khwaja, who represents the certified math teacher among other teacher clients, said Ochi-Okorie’s complaint to the state was related to instructional time and teachers’ planning periods. The teacher is seeking a districtwide moratorium on nonrenewals until the court determines whether retaliation is driving administrator to fire educators through nonrenewals.

Article continues below this ad

Other Chavez educators reported “anticipating retaliation for raising legitimate compliance concerns, demonstrating that the harm to the workforce extends beyond Plaintiff and is occurring now,” according to Ochi-Okorie’s court filing. Those concerns relate to student welfare, special education compliance, health and safety, curriculum and workload.

A judge denied the teacher’s request for a temporary restraining order in May. Ochi-Okorie has previously filed grievances within the district, including a grievance with HISD that was denied in May. 

TAKEOVER: HISD reaches the 3rd anniversary of the state takeover. What’s been lost, gained since 2023?

A high-performing teacher

At least one of Ochi-Okorie’s grievances came before HISD’s state-appointed board of managers in 2025. Ochi-Okorie scored high on classroom observations and was a “distinguished teacher” according to his representative and the district’s outside attorney in the hearing. However, he filed a grievance over the district’s evaluation process.

Article continues below this ad

The district’s outside counsel, Myra Chickering, said the teacher had one low classroom observation score during the 2023-24 school year — an outlier among his otherwise high marks.

Both the Houston Federation of Teachers representative Kimbal Urrutia and Chickering were “a little confused” at first by that grievance, Urrutia said at that 2025 hearing.

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: 3 years into the takeover, HISD is embracing AI, evolving its signature NES reform model

“So I find myself wondering, as I did during the level two hearing, what relief could be affected here?” Chickering said then, after noting Ochi-Okorie was rated distinguished in every category on his end-of-year appraisal. “He received the top rating, and the objections he has with regard to the way the spots were conducted ultimately had no impact, no negative impact whatsoever on his final appraisal.”

But Urrutia with the union said he understood the teacher’s point: a five-minute classroom spot observation was not enough time to evaluate a teacher, and a lower spot score reflects poorly on that teacher’s character. (Chickering said in her arguments that HISD’s spot observations were 15 to 20 minutes.)

“But your distinguished teacher, your best, has raised a concern: the defamation of character. Defamation of your professional skill in the classroom. (It) takes five minutes to harm you. And in those five minutes, a principal can walk in — you can have amazing scores as Chidi has had all year — but within five minutes, that can harm you,” Urrutia said in 2025.

In a rare move, the board of managers did not rule against Ochi-Okorie in 2025, instead they acknowledged the grievance and took no action.