Critics have said that the fee would be a disproportionate burden on low-income families and the elderly.

HOUSTON — Houston City Council is nearing a vote on Mayor John Whitmire’s proposed $7.5 billion budget, which includes a controversial new $5 monthly trash fee that has sparked debate among city leaders, residents and advocacy groups.

The proposed fee would be added to residents’ water bills and is intended to help fund improvements to the city’s solid waste services.

Supporters argue the measure is necessary to address Houston’s financial challenges, while critics warn it could disproportionately affect low-income households and elderly folks and eventually cost residents more than initially advertised.

Tensions flared during Wednesday’s City Council meeting as residents voiced opposition to the proposal.

“You ignore it! Ignore it! Ignore it! Ignore it!” one speaker shouted during public comment.

Several labor unions and business organizations expressed support for the budget.

“Our union is fully in support of the budget,” one supporter told council members.

But many residents and community advocates pushed back against the proposed fee.

“That’s not the same sacrifice for everyone,” one resident said during public testimony.

Critics argue the additional charge would place a heavier burden on families already struggling with rising costs.

“The fees are going to hit low-income families a lot harder right now, and this is just not a time for them to be hit with such fees. And that’s not to say that the city doesn’t need revenue. We do need a revenue source, but maybe we should just rethink how that should be done in such a way that does not hit low-income families so hard,” Lindsay Williams, president of Super Neighborhoods 64 and 88, said. “At least, bare minimum, have an out for residents that are in need, that just cannot take that cost right now.”

In response to concerns about affordability, Council Member Alejandra Salinas has proposed an amendment to be proposed budget that would allow qualifying residents to receive assistance paying the fee through the city’s Water Fund Assistance Program.

“The city currently has what’s known as a Water Fund which is totally donation based and is a means by which people can get relief assistance on their utility bills. Our ordinance, sort of amendment, all it does is add to the existing water fund, the administrative fee, so if people are seeking relief on the other utility bills, which are all going to be on the same water bill, they can also seek relief for the administrative fee,” Salinas said “It’s a way to streamline the process, provide immediate relief to Houstonians now, and it doesn’t cost the city anything because the Water Fund is specifically funded just by donations.”

Houston City Controller Chris Hollins, who has criticized the mayor’s budget proposal for weeks, said residents should expect costs to rise beyond the initial $5 fee.

“Houstonians will pay more than what’s being promised, both in this trash fee and in their water bills. The mayor has stated that if we’re smart, the garbage fee may not ever have to go beyond five dollars. That statement is patently absurd,” Hollins said.

City council members have acknowledged the fee is expected to increase over time but said it would be capped at $25 per month.

Still, some officials questioned whether the cap will be enough to cover future costs.

“If the cost-of-service costs more than 25 dollars, then you’ll pay the 25 dollars for the garbage fee, and then the balance will have to come from somewhere else,” Council Member Edward Pollard said.

Houston City Council is expected to vote on the proposed budget next week.

Got a news tip or story idea? Email us at newstips@khou.com or call 713-521-4310 and include your name and the best way to reach you.