Dr. Lee C. Rogers, chief of podiatry at UT Health San Antonio, is calling on the American Diabetes Association to apologize for removing scientists from its annual conference for criticizing President Donald Trump.
Facebook UT Health Science Center in San Antonio
A prominent San Antonio diabetes specialist is calling on the American Diabetes Association to apologize after physician-scientists and researchers were removed from its annual conference for distributing an editorial that criticized the Trump administration over proposed cuts to the National Institutes of Health.
Dr. Lee C. Rogers, chief of podiatry and an associate professor of orthopedics at UT Health San Antonio’s Long School of Medicine, said he was “shocked” that the ADA booted the researchers from its Scientific Sessions in New Orleans for handing out copies of an editorial published in Diabetes Care, the association’s own flagship journal.
Article continues below this ad
In a public letter to the association’s CEO and board of directors, Rogers said the ADA owed the diabetes medical and scientific community more than an explanation for Friday’s incident, in which police and security guards confiscated copies of the editorial and forced the researchers to leave the Ernest N. Morial Convention Center.
“It owes an apology and a clear commitment that the Association, and especially the Scientific Sessions, will remain a place where scientific discourse is welcomed, encouraged, and protected,” Rogers wrote.
Rogers’ letter did not mention his position at UT Health San Antonio. He is an ADA volunteer, a former chair of the association’s Foot Interest Group and the current subject-matter expert for the foot-care section of the ADA Standards of Care in Diabetes.
The controversy unfolded during the association’s Scientific Sessions, held June 5-8. The gathering is billed as the world’s largest diabetes meeting, bringing together more than 12,000 physicians, scientists, researchers and health professionals from around the world.
Article continues below this ad
Several ADA members handed out printed copies of the Diabetes Care editorial on Friday morning outside a keynote address by NIH official Richard Woychik. The editorial was written by Dr. Steven E. Kahn, editor in chief of Diabetes Care, and three deputy editors of the journal. The authors said their views were personal and did not represent those of the ADA or their employers.
The editorial said the Trump administration’s proposed $5 billion cut in NIH funding and ongoing staff reductions at the agency threaten biomedical research and diabetes studies. “There is an urgent need for all of us to bring attention to these destructive processes,” the researchers wrote. “Enough is enough!” The NIH is the world’s largest governmental funder of medical research.
Kahn is a professor of medicine at the University of Washington and director of its Diabetes Research Center. Video published by MedPage Today show that a plainclothes security officer took papers out of Kahn’s hand and an officer wearing a local constable’s badge grabbed another researcher by the arm as Louisiana State Police stood nearby.
In a statement to MedPage Today, the ADA said five registrants were removed for violating the conference’s code of conduct, which they agreed to obey when they registered. The association said the attendees were given a chance to stop their behavior and remain at the meeting but chose not to.
Article continues below this ad
Kahn told MedPage Today that the researchers were warned they would be arrested if they returned.
“They physically grabbed us and forced us out of the conference center, and now they’re telling us we no longer can attend this meeting,” Aaron Kelly, a professor of pediatrics at the University of Minnesota and an expert on childhood obesity, said in a video recorded outside the convention center. “Really, it’s come to this in America. Censorship is real.”
The ADA said that as a tax-exempt nonprofit, it must maintain “a strictly nonpartisan environment at all organizational events and functions while engaging across party affiliations to advance our mission.”
“We have always and will continue to welcome scientific inquiry, respectful dialogue and diverse perspectives in the pursuit of better outcomes for people living with diabetes and obesity,” the association said in a statement.
Article continues below this ad
Rogers posted his letter on Facebook on Sunday and said he was publicizing it because academic and scientific discussion must remain open, even on difficult or controversial subjects.
“Progress in science and medicine depends on the ability to ask questions, debate ideas, publish opinions, and disagree respectfully without fear that speech itself will be restricted,” Rogers wrote. “My concern is not about politics, but about protecting the independence of academic and scientific voices so that evidence and reasoned disagreement can continue to guide our work.”
Rogers said the ADA’s actions made him question whether he should continue to volunteer for an organization that “appears willing to censor scientific speech when that speech becomes uncomfortable.”
Article continues below this ad
He urged the ADA to apologize to the individuals removed, permit them to participate fully in the conference, clarify that distributing scientific material from ADA journals is not a violation of professional standards of conduct, and commit that future meetings will protect respectful scientific discourse “even, and especially, when the topic intersects with public policy.”
“I recognize that we live in a politically charged time and that national meetings must maintain standards of professionalism,” Rogers wrote. “However, the conduct at issue, the distribution of an editorial in our scientific journal, was not harassment or intimidation. It was simply advocacy for the protection of biomedical research.”
At UT Health, Rogers leads a podiatry division focused on diabetic foot care, limb preservation and amputation prevention. An estimated 15.5% of adults in Bexar County have been diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes, one of the highest rates in the country.
Rogers recently became president-elect of the International Federation of Podiatrists, a global network representing 40,000 podiatrists in 24 countries.
Article continues below this ad
READ ALSO: ‘A public health emergency’: doctors sound alarm on measles outbreak at Texas ICE center
Dr. K.M. Venkat Narayan, an Emory University diabetes researcher and elected member of the National Academy of Medicine, said the ADA appeared to have engaged in a “heavy-handed overreaction” by stopping researchers from distributing reprints of an editorial that was already online.
Narayan said the ADA also has canceled Diabetes Care editorial and staff meetings, which he said “paralyzed the voice” of the journal and may have delayed publication of one of his own papers.
Article continues below this ad
An open letter and petition posted at Change.org by Dr. David Nathan, director of the Diabetes Center at Massachusetts General Hospital, called the removal of the scientists from the conference “unfathomable” and demanded an apology from the ADA and a commitment to freedom of expression and scientific inquiry.