With Monday’s gritty 115-111 win over the Knicks in Game 3 of the NBA finals, the Spurs have guaranteed y’all are coming back to San Antonio at least one more time.
And trust me, you won’t want to miss out on a little extracurricular dining time before tip-off.
Article continues below this ad
A few weeks ago, I muscled through a dozen or so dishes at Frost Bank Center. The arena really is doing an impressive job of slinging unique nibbles and sips, including a solid range of specialty items tailored to each series of games the Spurs have battled through in their playoff run.
But they’re not the only game in town.
Whether you call San Antonio home full-time or you’re catching a red-eye from LaGuardia and sidling up courtside to Spike Lee, the Alamo City has an impressive array of restaurants serving up food inspired by the Big Apple. But we also have a unique way of making those dishes our own. And this week, we’re celebrating five spots where you can eat like a New Yorker, San Antonio-style.
Article continues below this ad
RACE FOR SEIS: Celebrate the Spurs’ pursuit of a 6th NBA title with this commemorative edition of the Express-News
First of all, let’s call a few fouls. None of these restaurants or dishes are catering to some kind of gimmicky fusion-fare trend. Each one has taken an interesting approach to melding New York staples with favorite local flavors to create dishes that are just plain good, not good because they look cool on Instagram. You’ve seen plenty of that at fast-food chains over the years. All of these dishes honor their multimetropolitan roots with quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation. Quite a few of them have been on the court longer than most of the starting Spurs lineup has been playing professionally.
Whether you’re craving pizza, hot dogs or other iconic New York dishes with a Texas twist, here’s where to get started.
The Chop Cheese sandwich at Pullman Market is a fairly faithful recreation of the New York City bodega staple.
Paul Stephen/San Antonio Express-News
Chop Cheese at Pullman Market
San Antonio has plenty of corner stores, but very little of New York’s bodega culture, where a convenience shop doubles as everyone’s favorite sandwich spot. A staple of those particular haunts is the chopped cheese sandwich, essentially a hamburger reconfigured on a hero roll. Pullman Market’s Burgers by the Butcher food stall produces a fairly faithful rendition, starting with Texas-raised Waygu beef and American cheese slices. The patties and cheese hit a hot griddle and, like the name implies, are chopped into a gooey mince and finished with lettuce, tomato, onion and garlic aioli on a fresh-baked hoagie roll. 221 Newell Ave., 210-759-0086, pullmanmarket.com.
Article continues below this ad
BIG CHEESE: Chef and Pullman Market founder Kevin Fink helps shape San Antonio’s dining scene
The Elote hot dog at The Dogfather is dressed with roasted corn, two types of cheese and crushed Takis.
Chuck Blount/San Antonio Express-News file photo
The Elote at Dogfather
You don’t have to leave Frost Bank Center to see how San Antonio does a hot dog. The Wembanyama-inspired Alien Dog available at the arena is topped with brisket burnt-end bourguignon and jalapeño aioli, and plenty out-of-this-world. But for a true taste of San Antonio, head over to The Dogfather where franks (including several vegan options) are always a slam-dunk. The Elote, named one of the Top 10 hot dogs in the city by Express-News dining critic Mike Sutter, is puro Mexican street-corn swagger. The all-beef dog is dressed with roasted corn, mayonnaise, queso fresco and Parmesan cheese along with crushed Takis and a bright hit of lime. 6211 San Pedro Ave., 210-481-4272, sadogfather.com.
Article continues below this ad
The Mexican Pizza at Cosa Nostra Pizzeria features seasoned beef, bacon and jalapeño chiles.
Chuck Blount/San Antonio Express-News file photo
Mexican Pizza at Cosa Nostra Pizzeria
Disclaimer: You do have to stomach this restaurant’s nod to organized crime in its name. But if you can navigate past that, you’ll find a solid lineup of pies on nicely blistered crust that walks something of a tight rope between New York and Naples in spirit. The Mexican Pizza is more restrained than one might expect from its name. Forget those novelties served at Taco Bell and Taco Cabana.There’s no salsa, crema or cilantro. But there is nicely seasoned beef, bacon, red onions and jalapeños. Cosa Nostra has one of the more robust selections of vegan options among San Antonio pizzerias, using cashew cream in its take on Alfredo sauce, and a mixture of mushrooms and walnuts mimicking a hearty beef-based ragu. 16607 Huebner Road, 210-492-1141, cosanostrapizzeria.com.
NACHO PROBLEM: How San Antonio-born Ricos Products changed the way the world eats nachos
Article continues below this ad
The Texas Lasagna at Guillermo’s features two types of tomato sauce, oodles of beef, grilled jalapeño chiles and red onions.
Paul Stephen/San Antonio Express-News
Texas Lasagna at Guillermo’s
This downtown staple along McCullough Avenue has more than 30 years of history in its spacious converted home and sprawling patio space. It bills itself as an “authentic Italian restaurant,” but that doesn’t really tell the whole story. You’ll find plenty of earnest interpretations of pizza and pasta dishes, but dig a little deeper into the menu for a savory taste of San Antonio. This lasagna is seriously meaty, and the pasta retains a toothsome bite. On a recent visit, it was dressed with both classic marinara and creamy tomato sauce, oodles of grilled onions and jalapeño slices. It’s sweet, savory and full of spice. Best enjoyed outdoors with a frozen margarita on the side. 618 McCullough Ave., 210-223-5587, guillermosdowntown.com.
Article continues below this ad
Smoke Shop Delicatexan serves a Reuben sandwich made with house-smoked pastrami and tangy coleslaw.
Paul Stephen/San Antonio Express-News
Texas Reuben Sandwich at Delicatexan
I have a soft spot for a classic Reuben sandwich. So much so that I noshed through more than 20 of them in a recent ranking of the city’s Top 10 Reubens. This particular sandwich is something different, but hits plenty of the hallmark notes. You get a generous base of house-smoked pastrami. Where you’d normally find sauerkraut, Delicatexan goes in with a tangy layer of cole slaw. The whole affair is punched up with roasted jalapeño chiles and Thousand Island dressing. It’s not what you might think of as “traditional” or “authentic” in any way (not that those words mean much in the food world), but it is full of Lone Star spirit. 3710 Broadway, 210-549-1090, delicatexansa.com.