A tasting menu can be one of the most exciting experiences you’ll have at a restaurant—and one of the most expensive. It’s hard enough deciding where to eat on a random Tuesday. Toss a $500 check into the mix, and the stakes become paralyzing. We’re here to help. We made our way through almost all of Austin’s tasting menus to let you know which ones are worth your time. Some of these restaurants serve that format exclusively, whereas others offer the option to sit back and let the chef make the decisions. Food is, obviously, the biggest factor in our rankings, but we also considered service, atmosphere, and value.

For this list, we left off sushi omakases—they’re too important not to have their own guide.