A state judicial conduct commission has warned State District Judge Stephanie Boyd that she violated judicial standards through her handling of two cases and her use of a YouTube channel to stream hearings and host a book club.
The Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct issued the warning on June 3 to Boyd, who presides over the 187th District Court. The warning stated that Boyd improperly inserted herself into plea negotiations during a 2023 hearing, made degrading comments to a defendant during a livestreamed hearing and improperly used her court’s YouTube channel.
One of the complaints centers on an October 2024 hearing involving Thomas Henson, who was facing up to 20 years in prison.
Boyd told the court reporter to go “off the record,” but the livestream continued. She went on to warn Henson that when he goes to prison, he could be “passed around for cigarettes or dessert” because he is “young” and fellow prisoners will think he is “attractive.”
“And no matter the commissary money that your parents and grandparents can put on the books for you is gonna save you from being passed around at the prison,” she said.
“Do you want to be passed around for ramen noodle? Because that’s what’s going to happen,” Boyd added.
The commission cited the comments as evidence of Boyd’s failure to be “patient, dignified, and courteous.” Boyd told the commission that Henson “was not taking the charges or the potential probation seriously.”
The warning also referenced another incident in July 2023 after Boyd rejected a plea agreement. Boyd asked the defendant, Willberth Villamil, if he was “willing to accept the 20 years in prison offered by the court.” She later said his case was “life sentence-worthy.” Villamil was facing charges of aggravated sexual assault of a child.
The commission said Boyd improperly inserted herself into the plea bargaining process, in violation of the state’s code of criminal procedure.
Boyd’s decision to livestream daily court hearings on YouTube, a practice that originated during the pandemic, became an issue in that race.
The commission said that Boyd engaged in “extrajudicial activity” with viewers of the channel by allowing them to leave comments in real time about court proceedings. Boyd told the commission that she has never considered those comments and that her decisions are “based solely on evidence presented and the law.”
The commission also took issue with Boyd’s use of the channel to host a book club, a practice Boyd said she has since discontinued.
The public warning becomes part of Boyd’s permanent disciplinary record. However, it does not remove her from the bench, affect her salary or prevent her from continuing to preside over cases.