Courtine Walker, 22, was charged with capital murder for a double homicide. His public defender thanked the judge for her “courage” in dismissing the case.

DALLAS — A Dallas County Judge threw out a capital murder case last week, finding the defendant’s right to a speedy trial was violated following a court hearing last month in which she made clear her frustration at the conduct of the prosecutor in the case.

“This case and the actions of the state can be defined with the adjectives of apathy, languid and insolent,” Judge Nancy Mulder said at the hearing on May 28. “Such a dereliction of prosecutorial duty is so contrary to the rule of law that says a prosecutor’s duty is to seek justice.”



This story continues below.

Defense attorneys for Courtine Walker, 22, said the District Attorney’s office refused to test ballistics or cell phone data until ordered to do so by the court, mistakenly told the defense they did not have one of the guns used in the shooting when they in fact did, and could not tell the court when they last spoke to the pivotal eyewitness in the case. 

“The math isn’t mathing. Evidence is missing,” said Walker’s public defender Joe Patton during a May 28 hearing on the motion to dismiss. “The state can not rely on their own negligence and misconduct to justify their own delays.”

Mulder agreed — and last week granted a defense motion to dismiss the capital murder case against Walker, which had been pending since 2023. He remains in jail on a pending aggravated robbery charge and the district attorney’s office has filed a motion to appeal the judge’s dismissal of the murder charge. 

“We are deeply grateful to Judge Mulder for her courage and integrity in making the correct ruling after years of vigorous pretrial litigation,” Patton said in a statement to WFAA on Monday. “Courtine Walker spent over three years in Dallas County Jail — from the age of nineteen — on a charge the evidence did not support. Courtine‘s patience, determination, and commitment to his own defense was an inspiration to the team.”

A spokesperson for the Dallas County District Attorney’s office declined to comment, citing the pending appeal. 

In court, prosecutor James Worley said he was incorrect in saying there was no murder weapon recovered by authorities. “It was provided in a much larger file,” he said. “It was one page in that file, and I missed the page.”

Mulder responded, “You had a duty to know what was in your file,” and added, “The frustration of the Court is beyond.” 

When asked by Judge Mulder when he last spoke to the eyewitness in the case, Worley could not give a definitive answer. Instead, saying it was sometime last year at a McDonald’s in Arlington, prompting this retort from the judge: “You are the lead prosecutor on this multiple capital murder case. He is the only eyewitness and you cannot tell the court the last time you spoke to him?”

In his argument against the dismissal, Worley agreed the case had dragged on, but said the defense was attempting to have the judge rule on the merits of the case, which is the responsibility of the jury. He said it is not the state’s duty to test material like the gun ballistics and cell phone data on behalf of the defense. “It’s not the state’s job to prepare their case for them,” he said. 

Walker was arrested in 2023 in connection with a double homicide during a gun purchase gone wrong behind a Party City near Interstate 30 and Cockrell Hill Road in Far West Oak Cliff. 

Walker’s two co-defendants in the case, who have both since reached plea deals with prosecutors, initially said Walker shot and killed Juan Carlos Sierra-Garcia, Jr., 19, and his girlfriend, 18-year-old Ruby Gonzalez — leaving them to die in the parking lot — and took the guns from the scene.

Instead, prosecutors later disclosed, the co-defendants conspired to shift blame in an effort to get lesser sentences for themselves. Defense attorneys say evidence in the case shows they still had the guns — and the weapons they stole from the victim — and later sold them online. Walker, his attorneys say, never had possession of the guns in the case nor used them.

Walker’s defense concedes he was at the scene in the co-defendant’s vehicle at the time of the shooting — but claims Walker had no idea it was going to happen and said he “froze until the first opportunity to flee in the SUV and avoid becoming a victim.”

Contact reporter Cole Sullivan at csullivan@wfaa.com for story ideas and tips.