SAN ANTONIO – A former San Antonio police officer fired after giving a homeless man a dog feces sandwich has been promoted to police chief in South Texas, reigniting questions about police accountability and hiring standards.
Matthew Luckhurst’s promotion has renewed scrutiny of his law enforcement career, which includes disciplinary cases involving a homeless man and allegations of inappropriate conduct at a police substation.
The former San Antonio Police Department officer was terminated after a series of incidents that led city leaders and police officials to question his fitness for duty. Despite those controversies, he continued working in law enforcement after leaving SAPD.
Timeline: Matthew Luckhurst’s career and disciplinary history
2016: Fired over ‘feces sandwich’ incident
Luckhurst was fired by SAPD after an internal investigation found he had placed dog feces between two slices of bread and left the sandwich near a homeless man while on patrol.
RELATED: SAPD documents state officer admitted giving homeless man feces sandwich
The homeless man did not consume the sandwich, but then-San Antonio Police Chief William McManus condemned the act, calling it “vile” and “disgusting.”
Luckhurst claimed he did not intend for the homeless man to eat the sandwich.
2016: Second misconduct investigation
During a separate internal affairs investigation, SAPD accused Luckhurst and another officer of misconduct involving a women’s restroom at a bike patrol substation.
According to disciplinary records, officers allegedly defecated in the restroom, with feces-like material later found smeared on a toilet seat and wall. The allegations became the basis for a second disciplinary case against Luckhurst.
RELATED: Officer who used feces as prank says ‘never meant to be interpreted as harassing’
2019: Returns to SAPD after appeal
An arbitrator ruled Luckhurst’s firing in the sandwich case should be overturned because SAPD missed a disciplinary deadline.
The decision allowed him to return to the department and receive back pay.
2020: Permanently removed from SAPD
Luckhurst’s return was short-lived.
A separate arbitrator upheld SAPD’s decision to terminate him in connection with the restroom misconduct investigation. The ruling permanently ended his employment with the department.
RELATED: Police Chief McManus testifies in feces prank arbitration hearing
2022: Hired by Floresville Police Department
Luckhurst returned to law enforcement as a reserve officer with the Floresville Police Department.
Later that year, Floresville officials announced Luckhurst was no longer employed by the department.
2023: Hired by Benavides Police Department
The City of Benavides hired Luckhurst as a police officer.
City officials said they were aware of his history and conducted a background investigation before hiring him.
2026: Promoted to police chief
In June 2026, records show Luckhurst was promoted to chief of the Benavides Police Department.
“Despite past allegations, Officer Luckhurst’s record since joining the department in April 2023 has been exemplary, with no complaints or issues reported. A thorough background check was conducted before he was sworn in as a peace officer, ensuring that all aspects of his history were carefully considered,” said the department in a statement.
RELATED: Former ‘feces sandwich’ officer hired by Benavides Police Department
Luckhurst’s rise to police chief has reignited debate about police accountability and the standards governing officer certification and hiring in Texas.