Chart House is the rotating restaurant at the top of the Tower of the Americas at Hemisfair in San Antonio. For a review by Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Chart House at the top of the Tower of the Americas at Hemisfair is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/San Antonio Express-News

As it’s done with the River Walk and burgers and margaritas, my search for San Antonio’s Top 10 downtown restaurants also uncovered the worst examples of that very same thing. One’s been here forever, one just opened this spring, three sit by the River Walk and three give Mexican food a bad reputation. Welcome to our first-ever ranking of the 10 worst restaurants in downtown San Antonio.

Oak & Amber at The Monarch San Antonio hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Oak & Amber at The Monarch San Antonio hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/San Antonio Express-News

10. Oak & Amber

The flagship steakhouse at Hemisfair’s new Monarch hotel could be most any posh hotel restaurant most anywhere. Except for the noise level like a shot bar, the decor like a Star Wars condo and the prices like Uber in full surge mode. It’s the same ride; you’re just paying a lot more. The seafood Tower of Babel, the dead-eyed duck à l’orange, the rib-eye Frisbee. The highest bill I’ve yet paid for a table of four in this town. And I didn’t even get into the more serious big-ticket things. Caviar, foie gras, Lobster Thermidor, a $130 visit from the Prime Rib Trolley. Oak & Amber is 100% a downtown restaurant. We’re still working out which downtown that might be. 222 S. Alamo St. at The Monarch San Antonio hotel, 210-714-8200, themonarchsa.com/oak-amber

Article continues below this ad

Schilo's is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Schilo’s is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/San Antonio Express-News

9. Schilo’s

Schilo’s has been around since 1917. The dining room feels like a museum, a thoroughly updated and clean museum, but it genuinely feels like a saloon from the old days, and the hexagonal Teutonic mosaic tile floor is worth the trip all by itself. Schilo’s is known best for three things: split-pea soup, Reuben sandwiches and frosty cold root beer. That third thing is the best of its kind I’ve ever had, brought to the table in glass beer mugs with ice chips gliding along the top like a dark brown polar ocean. But for way too long, we’ve been pretending like that soup and that sandwich are the ne plus ultra of German food in San Antonio. They are not. The boggy chartreuse soup tastes like the earth it came from, like the peas already split for brighter, greener pastures. And that Reuben might have been a looker back in the day, but now it just sits on the porch and rambles on about how great it used to be. I decided long ago not to be a hostage to nostalgia. And I won’t surrender that resolve to Schilo’s. 424 E. Commerce St., 210-223-6692, schilos.com 

SUCCESS AND THE CITY: Top 10 downtown

Article continues below this ad

La Mexicana Mexican Restaurant is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

La Mexicana Mexican Restaurant is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/San Antonio Express-News

8. La Mexicana Mexican Restaurant

With its captive perch next to the Bexar County Courthouse, La Mexicana is exactly the kind of clump-and-dump Tex-Mex that makes people wonder why San Antonio loves Tex-Mex so much. The cheese enchiladas on the cafe’s Mexican Plate glow and churn with a gurgled intensity that dissolves the scuba-suit orange slickness of the red tortillas underneath. Is it gravy or is it just oil and flour and bad ideas? I’ll go with the second one on a plate that looks like every cheese enchilada plate with a crispy taco that ever haunted your digestive system at 4 in the morning. Except that it’s 2 in the afternoon, and you’ve got no one to blame but yourself. And please don’t tell me what’s in this chilaquiles breakfast taco that tastes as bitter as a bad day in the courthouse next door. Which is about the only way I can figure you’d be tempted, forced or persuaded to spend an afternoon at La Mexicana. Because as the signs say: They won’t hold your contraband for you while you go to court, and they don’t sell locks to put on the Kallison Love Lock Bridge on the River Walk outside. 130 Main Plaza, 210-265-3422

Oro at The Emily Morgan Hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Oro at The Emily Morgan Hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/Staff

7. Oro at The Emily Morgan Hotel

The towering spire of The Emily Morgan Hotel suggests a kind of Goth-meets-“The Shining” intrigue, maybe a turn-of-the-last-century elegance. The hotel? I don’t know; never stayed there. But I’ve haunted the scuffed-up bar and grill called Oro in the lobby, and it’s more like Chili’s-meets-Drury, just a few letters shy of dreary. From an everyday (but please not today) burger to a mismatched tour-bus pan of shrimp and grits to a margarita sad enough to make my “10 worst” list, Oro is everything you don’t want in a downtown restaurant. And less. 705 E. Houston St. at The Emily Morgan Hotel, 210-244-0146, emilymorganhotel.com 

Article continues below this ad

Mengerita Tacos at the Menger Hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mengerita Tacos at the Menger Hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/San Antonio Express-News

6. Mengerita Tacos

The locals already know that San Antonio has one of the best taco scenes in the country. The tourists don’t necessarily know that, or at least they don’t if this taco shop wedged into the Menger Hotel next to the Alamo has anything to say about it. Overpriced and understuffed, at least it’s fast. But the thing about waiting for your food at a restaurant is that sometimes you want to wait, because preparing real food from scratch takes a minute. When your taco order comes out faster than it takes to grill chicken or fry an egg, you can assume they were scooping it from steam pans in the back. And that describes the grilled chicken in the $5.75 De Zavala taco at Mengerita, as dry and bitter as a burned-out tour guide. And no amount of black bean salsa nor avocado crema could take it to a happy place. The same with the sticky barbacoa at the heart of the presumptuously branded San Antonio Taco ($7.50). They’re just two of the clown cars in the sad taco parade representing San Antonio’s second-most-sacred thing next door to its first-most-sacred thing. 216 Alamo Plaza at the Menger Hotel, mengerhotel.com/san-antonio-restaurants/mengerita-tacos

Guadalajara Grill at La Villita is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Guadalajara Grill at La Villita is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/San Antonio Express-News

5. Guadalajara Grill

When they harvested the fieldstone to build the F.W. McAllister building at La Villita, I’m guessing they never imagined that this grand old Texas-Mexican colonial structure would house a tacky tourist Mexican restaurant like the Guadalajara Grill. From the beat-up saloon floors to the beat-up carnival-barker decor to the beat-up loteria card ceilings, Guadalajara Grill is the gateway to La Villita, the curious little village at the mouth of the downtown stretch of the River Walk. It’s a walk-through for tourists that the locals don’t think much about, so I’ve always seen it as a silent spokesperson for the San Antonio experience on the way to the Alamo or the River Walk. And I don’t want Guadalajara Grill speaking for the Mexican or Tex-Mex experience in San Antonio. It’s tacky, it’s overpriced and it’s not good. The $20 Mexican combo plate represented three or four shades on the earth-tone color wheel, but it all tasted like it was squeezed from the same mold, from the sad fold-over of the beef enchilada to the sadder cardboard shred of the chicken enchilada to the sadder-est bean tostada. It’s the reason people make fun of Tex-Mex behind its back. Among the sparse crowd on a Friday, I saw only tourists. Because the locals wouldn’t put up with this, not more than once. 301 S. Alamo St. at La Villita, 210-222-1992, guadalajaragrill.us

Article continues below this ad

ALL WET: 10 worst River Walk restaurants

Crockett Tavern at the Crockett Hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Crockett Tavern at the Crockett Hotel is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/San Antonio Express-News

4. Crockett Tavern at the Crockett Hotel

The memorial portrait framed in the rose window print at Crockett Tavern says it all: “David Crockett: 1786 to 1836. Pioneer, soldier, hunter, legislator, colonel of militia, congressman, Alamo, defender, the Lion of the West.” That’s right, this man was a real person, a man who died at the Alamo. And he deserves better than having his name, his image and his legacy used to sell baby-back ribs at a tourist hotel in downtown San Antonio. But here I am, eating a terrible brisket grilled cheese sandwich and a sad Fredericksburg peach salad with exactly three peach fragments underneath a giant framed painting of the Alamo on fire. I resent the Crockett Tavern for that, almost as much as I resent it for the sloppy “Bowie Beast Burger” and for the images of jean shorts and Evinrudes that “Rio Grande Shrimp Scampi” plants in my head. Have some more respect for Davy Crockett, for the Alamo, and for yourself. 320 Bonham, Suite 2, at the Crockett Hotel, 210-890-2224, crocketttavern.com 

Article continues below this ad

Sugar Factory on the River Walk is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Sugar Factory on the River Walk is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter/Staff

3. Sugar Factory

Mark Wahlberg, Bruno Mars, Kevin Hart, Pitbull, Kendall Jenner. These are the names the Sugar Factory lined up to “design and taste” $41 cocktails when the chain invaded the River Walk six years ago. In defiance of bad reviews and recognition as the worst of the River Walk, they’re still at it, with Rainbow Sliders and rubber duckies, with Cookie Monsters and $21 milkshakes, with Snoop Dogg and $28 cheeseburgers. Imagine a celebrity-themed bar and grill multiplied by a factor of two: twice as flashy, twice as sweet, twice as ready for its TikTok glow-up. But what’s that mathematical law? When you multiply by zero, you still get zero. A zillion times zero is still zero. Nothing can change that. Not gold leaf, not dry ice, not 50 shades of slider buns, not 50 Cent. That goes double at Sugar Factory. 849 E. Commerce St., Suite 109, on the River Walk, 726-204-2020, sanantonio.sugarfactory.com

Margaritaville on the River Walk is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Margaritaville on the River Walk is one of the 10 worst downtown restaurants in San Antonio, according to Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter.

Mike Sutter /Staff

2. Margaritaville

The tourists come here when they’re on the River Walk, because they’ve heard of Jimmy Buffett and they’ve sung “Margaritaville” in a bar, and maybe they went to the one in Orlando or Pigeon Forge. And wouldn’t it be so funny if we really did have a cheeseburger in paradise lol? But this isn’t paradise. Let’s call it purgatory, with a side of fries and the Walmart answer to margaritas. Please let me help you find better ways to spend your money downtown than paying tribute to an American music legend by eating bad pop-radio versions of fast food in his name. 849 E. Commerce St. on the River Walk, 210-973-5911, margaritavillesanantonio.com

Article continues below this ad

Chart House at the top of the Tower of the Americas at Hemisfair is one of is one of Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter's Top 10 Romantic Restaurants in San Antonio for 2025.

Chart House at the top of the Tower of the Americas at Hemisfair is one of is one of Express-News restaurant critic Mike Sutter’s Top 10 Romantic Restaurants in San Antonio for 2025.

Mike Sutter/Staff

1. Chart House

The best of times, the worst of times. The most romantic, the least romantic. A dream, a nightmare. The restaurant doing its slow spin inside the Tower of the Americas 750 feet above San Antonio’s downtown sprawl is a study in potential and the failure to live up (or down) to that potential. Ask yourself: “What if we put something like Applebee’s in the clouds, charged a lot more and made you feel the way you feel when you’re stopped at a light and the car next to you starts easing forward?” Neither the steak and lobster nor the mango shrimp stack nor the yin-yang of spiced ahi tuna live up to the view. But neither does the view, given that it’s the view of a downtown skyline mostly defined by the building in which you’re already sitting. 739 E. Cesar E. Chavez Blvd. at the Tower of the Americas, 210-223-3101, chart-house.com