Composite image of incumbent Dallas District Attorney John Creuzot and former Dallas County District Judge Amber Givens, who beat Creuzot in Tuesday's Democratic primary for DA.

Dallas County District Attorney John Creuzot and Amber Givens, a former state district judge who beat Creuzot in the March Democratic primary for DA.

Shelby Tauber/Special Contibutor and Elías Valverde II/Staff Photographer

The transition to Dallas County’s next district attorney is turning into a public feud over how the handoff is being managed.

Amber Givens says she has encountered delays, silence and resistance from incumbent John Creuzot. His office disputes that, saying it has been working steadily to answer her requests and prepare for an orderly transition.

The disagreement between the two Democrats escalated last week when Givens complained on Facebook about what she called delays obtaining information about the office, and she released an email detailing her concerns.

Article continues below this ad

A county commissioner who has been copied on emails between Givens and the district attorney’s office said he believes the dispute stems more from miscommunication than a lack of cooperation.

Givens, who began preparing for a possible January 2027 transition months earlier than is typical, said she has resorted to filing public information requests to obtain records from the district attorney’s office.

A spokesperson for Creuzot said the office is working to respond to her requests while balancing its regular workload. 

Givens recently turned to social media to air her frustrations, posting an email she sent to a top official in Creuzot’s office in which she complained she’s had to wait a month or more for some documents. 

Article continues below this ad

“I am sharing this May 29, 2026, email I sent to Mr. Paul Hamilton because I have tremendous respect for the truth,” Givens wrote in a June 16 Facebook post. “For the people of Dallas County, transparency matters. This email reflects my experience with the current administration regarding transition-related matters and outlines the concerns I raised after nearly two months of attempting to obtain information necessary for a successful transition, beginning on April 1, 2026.”

The Dallas Morning News reviewed email exchanges between Givens and the DA’s office from late April through June 15 through a public information request. 

Related: John Creuzot concedes to Amber Givens in Dallas County district attorney primary

The correspondence often shows much more cordial communication, with First Assistant District Attorney Paul Hamilton, a top official in Creuzot’s office tasked with overseeing the transition process, pledging to get information to her “as soon as practicable” and Givens thanking him for his efforts and cooperation.

On June 12, five days before her Facebook post, Givens thanked Hamilton for meeting with her earlier that day and providing information concerning human resources and personnel structure she had requested at least a month before. 

Article continues below this ad

She also thanked him for proposing regular monthly transition meetings, which he had suggested in previous emails. 

The communications show that the DA’s office often responded to Givens’ emails the same or next day, though often not with the information she requested. 

In some messages, the DA’s office asked for clarification on what Givens was seeking, with Hamilton writing in one exchange that the “terminology” she used didn’t correspond with the office’s.

Givens said the material The News received didn’t capture all the correspondence between her and Creuzot’s office.

“Based on the dates you identified, along with your description of the records you received and some of your comments, it appears that some of the responsive communications were not included in the records provided to you,” she wrote in a text to The News.

Article continues below this ad

The former felony court judge became the county’s presumptive new chief prosecutor in March when she defeated Creuzot in the Democratic primary. Since no Republicans or other party candidates entered the race, she will be unopposed in the general election and should office in January. 

Givens began preparing for her new role after her win, seeking input from the community, judges and other elected officials in the weeks that followed. 

She also began reaching out to Creuzot’s office to gather “basic personnel, organizational, and operational information,” according to a statement she gave to The Dallas Morning News and CBS News Texas, which first reported on the issue. 

Givens wrote that, beginning in May, she became so frustrated with the lack of communication that she began filing Public Information Act requests to ensure she got the information she said she needed. 

In its statement, Creuzot’s office said it has been communicating regularly with Givens and had been attempting to set up in-person meetings with her. 

Article continues below this ad

One that had been scheduled for April 3 was postponed by Givens because she wanted to receive relevant documents first. 

A meeting last week was attended by Givens, Hamilton, an office administrator and Creuzot’s spokesperson, Claire Crouch, Crouch said. Creuzot was not there. Another meeting is expected next month, Crouch said.

“During that meeting, we outlined additional materials that will be provided and proposed a regular monthly meeting schedule throughout the remainder of the transition period to ensure a consistent and efficient flow of information,” the office’s statement said.

Dallas County District 2 Commissioner Andrew Sommerman, a Democrat who endorsed Creuzot in the primary, said Monday he and several other commissioners have been included in the email traffic between Givens and Creuzot’s office. 

Sommerman said he has met with Givens on multiple occasions and has assured her she will get the materials she needs. But he also said that he questions her view that the district attorney’s office is not cooperating with her. 

Article continues below this ad

“I’m not seeing that at all,” he said. “What I’m seeing is sometimes some honest miscommunication, but that’s it.”

And while Givens and the commissioners have been at odds before – including last year when they withheld a $25,000 judicial pay supplement from her then reversed after she sued – the commissioners want her to be successful in her new role and will do whatever they can to help, Sommerman said.