Bill Hutchinson of Dunhill Partners poses for a photo in the Commons Club of the Virgin Hotels Dallas.

Bill Hutchinson of Dunhill Partners poses for a photo in the Commons Club of the Virgin Hotels Dallas.

Juan Figueroa/Staff photographer

A Dallas jury resumed deliberations Thursday in a civil lawsuit accusing prominent developer and former reality television star Bill Hutchinson of sexually assaulting three women who are seeking nearly $120 million in damages.

In closing arguments, the women’s attorney asked jurors to find Hutchinson liable, saying he preyed on them after they asked him for career advice. His attorney said the women fabricated their allegations in hopes of a multimillion-dollar payout.

Hutchinson, 68, a onetime star of the Lifetime reality show Marrying Millions, testified that the encounters were consensual. He was not criminally charged in any of the incidents but pleaded guilty in 2024 in California to a misdemeanor sexual battery charge involving a 16-year-old girl who was a guest at his home in Laguna Beach.

Article continues below this ad

The trial, which began two and a half weeks ago in state district court, featured testimony from dozens of witnesses, along with hundreds of text messages, videos and photographs.

Most of the alleged assaults occurred between June and August 2020 at two Dallas Design District properties Hutchinson was affiliated with at the time: the Virgin Hotels and Dunkirk apartments. 

The women are seeking roughly $40 million each for counseling, medical care and emotional and physical pain they say resulted from the assaults, lead attorney Michelle Simpson Tuegel told jurors on Wednesday.

“This case is about a rich and powerful man who preyed on young and vulnerable women and thinks the rules shouldn’t apply to him,” Simpson Tuegel said. “It’s not about sex for him. It’s about power. It’s about control. It’s about domination.”

Article continues below this ad

Lead defense attorney Levi McCathern said the women’s accounts contained too many inconsistencies to be believed. He also questioned why all three continued communicating with Hutchinson after the alleged assaults. 

“There’s no one else backing up these stories,” McCathern said.  “And their stories are ever changing based on whatever the evidence is at that time.” 

Related: He’s 62, she’s 22: Dallas couple returns to ‘Marrying Millions’ TV show

McCathern acknowledged Hutchinson may be a womanizer and a playboy, but said he did not assault the women. He called their requests for tens of millions in damages “crazy.”  

Simpson Tuegel rejected the defense’s assertion that the women lied, saying their willingness to admit consensual encounters with Hutchinson bolstered their credibility.

Article continues below this ad

“If the woman were lying, they could have left out some of the difficult parts,” she said. “What they shared was the real, hard, raw, complicated truth.”

Hutchinson is accused of forcing himself on the women after they sought career advice from him. 

Hutchinson was 62 at the time and the women were in their early to late 20s. The Dallas Morning News doesn’t name alleged victims of sexual assault without their consent.

In his testimony, Hutchinson said he pursued sexual relationships with the women but maintained every encounter was consensual. He said one relationship lasted four years, testimony supported by two friends who appeared as defense witnesses.

The case went to the jury late Wednesday. Jurors deliberated for less than an hour before asking State District Judge Bridgett Whitmore to recess for the day.

Article continues below this ad

The first woman to sue was a neuroscience student at Baylor University and a fan of Hutchinson’s reality show when she contacted him on Instagram. She filed her lawsuit a year after she alleged Hutchinson sent a driver to pick her up in Waco two times and then groped her at his corporate apartment during the second visit. 

The other two women sued after the first case became public. Both testified Hutchinson raped them at the hotel and his corporate apartment on two occasions.  

The Baylor student was the only alleged victim who talked to police. She said she didn’t contact authorities until after consulting an attorney about filing a civil lawsuit.

In the California case, Hutchinson was placed on three years’ probation and required to register as a sex offender. The conviction was expunged earlier this year as part of a plea agreement reached with prosecutors, and he is no longer required to be on the sex offender registry.

Article continues below this ad

Hutchinson appeared on both seasons of Marrying Millions, beginning in 2019. The show featured several couples in which one partner had achieved high levels of wealth and success while the other had not.

Hutchinson was 61 when the show began. His girlfriend on the show was 40 years younger and working as a restaurant hostess when she met Hutchinson. The couple is still dating, McCathern said.