SAN ANTONIO – A legal fight over a special property tax break in Bexar County is raising questions about whether a loophole meant to encourage affordable housing is instead shifting the tax burden onto other residents.

Bexar County’s chief appraiser says misuse of the exemption places a greater burden on the tax-paying public. The tax break was designed in 1987 to increase affordable housing, but the chief appraiser says a loophole is allowing 27 large apartment complexes to avoid paying taxes.

The lost revenue totals more than $26 million, money that cannot be used for schools, street repairs and other needs.

“This is unacceptable, unacceptable they need to follow the rules as everyone else,” said Ioana Popa, identified as a taxpayer.

Pete Alanis of the San Antonio Housing Trust said the exemption is being used in a way that does not create new affordable housing. “This was all done under the guise of well we’re creating affordable housing, they’re not creating anything, the properties were already there, they were on the tax rolls, and they were already affordable,” Alanis said.

A News 4 I-Team investigation last year found traveling housing finance corporations established by Maverick County, Cameron County, and small cities of Pleasanton have purchased numerous apartment buildings in Bexar County in the past few years. In a lawsuit, the Bexar County chief appraiser claims those cities and counties are receiving hundreds of thousands of dollars in fees from developers to use their tax exemptions in Bexar County.

When asked by Jaie Avila, “Is what you’re doing an abuse of that tax exemption?” attorney Blake Stribling, identified as representing the housing finance corporations and developers, responded, “No it’s not an abuse of it at all.”

Stribling said the arrangement follows the intent of state lawmakers. “What the legislature saw fit to do was to create an incentive structure for public private partnerships and that’s exactly what my clients are operating under,” he said.

The dispute is now in court on multiple fronts. A coalition of developers is suing to have a new law banning long-distance tax exemptions declared unconstitutional, an effort to keep the tax breaks on apartments they have already purchased. Meanwhile, the Bexar County chief appraiser has filed suit asking a judge to order the 27 apartment complexes be put back on the tax rolls.

The outcome could determine how much taxpayers ultimately pay, whether the properties remain exempt, and what impact the legal battle may have on affordable housing in the area.