NHL free agency is underway, and the Stars still do not have a deal in place with Jason Robertson. That’s nothing new. Neither is this: Robertson is driving these negotiations, just he and his representatives have for the past nine months as the star winger approached restricted free agency. 

That’s the only way to read Dallas’ decision to trade away promising 24-year-old forward Mavrik Bourque and veteran defenseman Ilya Lyubushkin to the Nashville Predators on Wednesday for a pair of draft picks. That was about creating cap space for a potential Robertson deal, and nothing more. 

Lyubushkin’s departure felt inevitable; he had fallen down the Stars’ defensive depth chart. But the Bourque trade stings a bit for a franchise that has prided itself on nurturing homegrown talent. At one point, the trio of Bourque, Wyatt Johnston, and Logan Stankoven seemed like the Stars’ next foundational bedrocks. Johnston has lived up to the billing and become perhaps the most terrifying power-play weapon in hockey. Stankoven was traded for Mikko Rantanen; that’s a deal the Stars can certainly live with. But the next few months will determine if moving Bourque was truly worth it. 

“You picked Jason Robertson by trading Bourque—that’s pretty clear to me,” one Eastern Conference executive told D Magazine. “That’s not the worst thing, to be clear. But when you make that decision, you need to make sure you get something done now with Robertson.”

The Stars-Robertson saga dates back to the summer of 2022, when Robertson held out for all of training camp before signing a four-year deal worth $7.75 million per season. Robertson has since delivered and then some on that value. He hasn’t missed a regular-season game on this deal and chipped in 365 points over those 328 games, highlighted by two seasons of 45 goals or more. While there have been some playoff narratives about him, the reality is Robertson was the Stars’ only forward who had any offensive success in this season’s first-round exit to the Minnesota Wild. 

Robertson’s camp knows this; his agent, Andy Scott, has brought it up. It’s why they are requesting close to $14 million per season for him to stay in Dallas, a sharp increase over the reported $12 million number that Dallas proposed, which would match Rantanen for the highest salary on the team. 

Now Stars general manager Jim Nill is in an odd spot, two of his biggest values as a general manager fighting against each other. 

Nill is incredibly loyal, sometimes to a fault. To him, Robertson represents more than a premier goal scorer. He’s a home-grown product whom the Stars have heavily invested in, and with a new deal comes a chance to rewrite some franchise-scoring records. At just 26, Robertson already ranks 14th in franchise history for points with 490. Another average season by his standards should jump him all the way up to sixth. Nill would like little more than to see Robertson create one of the great careers in franchise history. 

Nill is also responsible for the cap sheet. He’s big on not over-spending on one player, and Roberton’s ask of $14 million per season—to say nothing of the $15 million that the Kraken were willing to offer Robertson had he accepted a trade to Seattle last week—goes against everything Nill believes about team building. 

It’s sentiment versus pragmatism, and after letting the latter win out for much of June, Nill seemingly flipped back to the former on Wednesday, even at the cost of a different young jewel. The Bourque deal feels like a concession to the Stars being out of options, after Robertson vetoed the Seattle deal and Norris Trophy winner Zach Werenski nixed a reported trade to Dallas earlier this week in a trade that would have involved Thomas Harley going to Columbus. Had that move happened, Nill would have created requisite cap space to meet Robertson’s asking price and upgraded his blue line in one swoop. Instead, Bourque was sacrificed, and extending Robertson has once again become the team’s greatest priority, even if it requires an arbitration hearing in August. 

“I think [a deal is] going to happen, truthfully,” one Stars’ source said. “Jim has done his work to look at all options—he’s good at that—but the reality is deep down I don’t think he ever wanted to move on from Jason.”

The Stars better get this right. Because committing to Robertson is committing to running it back after a playoff series where the Stars were outmatched. What’s more, the commitment to run this back made Dallas’ roster worse than it was in April. Everything hinges on this being the right choice. Too much has already been sacrificed.

Author Sean Shapiro Sean Shapiro View Profile

Sean Shapiro covers the Stars for StrongSide. He is a national NHL reporter and writer who previously covered the Dallas Stars organization as a beat writer for various publications between 2012 and 2020.