A federal lawsuit that had been filed against VIA Transit related to an incident between one of its police officers and a woman waiting in a Whataburger drive-thru line has been dropped.
Christopher Lee/Staff Photographer
A San Antonio woman has dropped a federal civil rights lawsuit she filed last year against VIA Metropolitan Transit’s police force, alleging that an officer hit her in the ribs and twisted her arm in a Whataburger drive-thru because he falsely believed she was driving a stolen vehicle.
The woman, Valerie Elizondo, filed a notice of nonsuit in February and terminated her representation by attorney Cal Mundell of El Paso, according to court documents.
Article continues below this ad
VIA did not reach any kind of settlement or agreement with Elizondo, said Josh Baugh, a spokesman for the transit agency.
ALSO READ: VIA has started building its Green Line. That means lots of road closures.
According to a letter from Mundell to Elizondo attached to the notice of nonsuit, Mundell advised her to “seek the opinion of an additional lawyer” but she opted instead to dismiss the lawsuit. Mundell did not respond to messages left seeking comment. Elizondo could not be reached for comment.
The VIA officer, Brandon Tamayo, was also a defendant in the lawsuit, which was filed in September in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas. Tamayo is no longer a VIA employee.
Article continues below this ad
Elizondo’s lawsuit alleged that Tamayo violated her rights under the Fourth and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Constitution by placing her under arrest without probable cause.
The incident occurred on Sept. 5, 2023, when Tamayo pulled in behind Elizondo while she was waiting in the drive-thru of a Whataburger at Cypress Street and San Pedro Avenue, just north of downtown. Tamayo ordered her to pull aside, she stated in the lawsuit. When she asked for his identification and why he was making the order, he “refused to provide any information,” according to the lawsuit.
Tamayo then opened Elizondo’s passenger-side door, shifted her car into park and removed her seat belt, the lawsuit stated. He “struck (her) in the ribs, twisted her arm and violently pulled her out of the vehicle,” the lawsuit alleged.
Another officer, whom the lawsuit did not name, arrived as Elizondo was being escorted away and shoved her against the patrol vehicle, injuring her back, the lawsuit stated.
Article continues below this ad
Later, a VIA police supervisor came to the scene and ordered that Elizondo be released. The vehicle belonged to Elizondo’s partner, and was thought stolen because a dealership had put on the wrong license plates, according to the lawsuit.
In November 2023, Tamayo received a two-day suspension without pay as a result of the incident, according to disciplinary records obtained by the Express-News through an open records request.
In her original complaint with VIA, Elizondo described Tamayo’s behavior that night as “aggressive and extremely unprofessional,” according to the disciplinary records. She was left with bruises on her arms and wrists, she said.
Elizondo’s lawsuit accused VIA’s police force of breach of duty, saying that it failed to properly train and supervise Tamayo and that it should have known about his “dangerous character” after a “documented history of misconduct.”
Article continues below this ad
During his time with VIA, Tamayo received four written reprimands and was recommended for three suspensions, including the one for the incident with Elizondo, according to the records received from VIA.
In October 2022, Tamayo was reprimanded for “several violations of safe driving practices.” In January of that year, while en route to an assignment, driving northbound on Interstate 10 on the Northwest Side, he decided instead to pursue a vehicle that passed him, according to VIA records. Tamayo estimated the vehicle was traveling faster than 110 miles per hour, according to several reports included in the records.
Mistakenly believing the vehicle was stolen — according to Tamayo’s own account, he misread a “partial hit” of the vehicle identification number — he followed the driver to a home on the Northwest Side, according to the records. After administering sobriety tests, he arrested the man who had been driving the vehicle on a charge of driving while intoxicated.
A supervisor later found that Tamayo violated several of the department’s policies, including by driving at an unsafe speed. The department prohibits its officers from making traffic pursuits, according to a memo included in the records.
Article continues below this ad
VIA’s fiscal year 2026 budget includes 49 full-time officer positions, up from 42 in the prior year, Baugh said. The agency also has 106 security positions.
The agency hired its first officers in 2002, according to its website. The department patrols about 98% of Bexar County — everywhere VIA’s routes go — and its officers are authorized to enforce all federal, state and local laws.
The officers are certified by the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement and are trained in “de-escalation and mental health crisis intervention,” VIA’s website states.
Article continues below this ad
A 2021 Express-News investigation found that VIA’s police officers had ticketed thousands of motorists for violations unrelated to riding on the agency’s buses. At least 70% of the 3,470 tickets VIA officers wrote between 2016 and 2020 were for traffic or parking violations, the investigation found.