SALT LAKE CITY (KUTV) — Rep. Matt MacPherson said he started the process to impeach the Third-District Court judge who made a ruling on Utah’s congressional maps for the 2026 election.
On Monday night, Judge Diana Gibson determined the map submitted by the Utah State Legislature “fails to abide and conform with the requirements of Proposition 4” – A voter-passed 2018 ballot initiative for redistricting reform. She ruled instead a map submitted by Better Boundaries and the League of Women Voters, the plaintiffs in a lawsuit challenging Utah’s congressional maps, to be adopted for the upcoming midterm elections.
“I have opened a bill to file articles of impeachment against Judge Gibson for gross abuse of power, violating the separation of powers and failing to uphold her oath of office to the Utah Constitution,” said MacPherson.
Rep. Candice Pierucci (R-Herriman), who co-chaired the Legislative Redistricting Committee, called Gibson’s ruling “judicial activism,” claiming she put put her own opinion before the State Constitution.
“We followed her direction every step of the way,” said Pierucci. “Turns out, she was orchestrating it from the start.”
Under Utah State Code, judicial officers are liable for impeachment for high crimes, misdemeanors or wrongdoings while in office.
However, League of Women Voters Utah President Kathy Biele defended Gibson, saying she was just doing her job.
MORE | Utah’s Congressional Redistricting
“This is unbelievable. She’s not doing anything that she shouldn’t do,” said Belie. “This came from the Supreme Court of Utah. I will say Article I Section II gives the people the right to change their form of government. Which is just exactly what we did.”
David Reymann, who represented Better Boundaries and League of Women Voters in the lawsuit, echoed Biele’s comments while speaking on a personal level. He said any calls for impeachment were “irresponsible and unfortunate.”
“(Judge Gibson) is an unbelievably respected judge in the community. She has done a fantastic job in this case whether you agree with her decision or not,” said Reymann. “She has done the role that the Constitution committed to her. And to suggest she should be removed from office because you don’t like politically the result that she has reached, I think is highly irresponsible.”
Any order to impeach Judge Gibson would need to receive the approval of two-thirds of Utah lawmakers in the state’s House of Representatives, according to state law. If adopted, two-thirds of the Utah Senate would need to vote to convict the impeached following a trial.
As of Nov. 11, a bill request for impeachment was not reflected on the Utah State Legislature’s list of bills for 2026.
_____