A Texas appeals court let Sathya Rajendra's lawsuit against Houston proceed after her husband died pursuing a city garbage truck. 

A Texas appeals court let Sathya Rajendra’s lawsuit against Houston proceed after her husband died pursuing a city garbage truck. 

Houston Chronicle/Hearst Newspap/Houston Chronicle via Getty Imag

A Houston widow’s lawsuit over her husband’s fatal fall while chasing a city garbage truck can move forward after an appeals court rejected the city’s attempt to throw out the case.

Rajendra Gudur was trying to get a city garbage truck driver’s attention when he allegedly fell while attempting to flag down and bang on the vehicle. He hit his head and later died from his injuries, according to his widow’s lawsuit. The city argued it shouldn’t have to face the case, but a Texas appeals court ruled that the allegations are enough for the lawsuit to proceed.

Article continues below this ad

The 14th Court of Appeals on Oct. 1 affirmed a lower court’s decision denying Houston’s request to dismiss the lawsuit. The ruling does not determine whether the city is liable for Rajendra Gudur’s death—only that his widow, Sathya Rajendra, alleged enough to keep the case alive.

How the fatal fall happened 

The lawsuit stems from a March 4, 2024, incident in which Gudur was taking out his trash when he saw a Houston garbage truck approaching.

According to his widow’s lawsuit, he tried to flag down the truck and then tried to bang on it to get the driver’s attention. He lost his balance, fell and hit his head. He later died from his injuries.

Article continues below this ad

Houston argued that the allegations weren’t enough to overcome its governmental immunity. The appeals court disagreed, finding the lawsuit sufficiently alleged that Gudur’s injuries arose from the operation or use of a city-owned motor vehicle.

The appeals court said in its October opinion, specifically, Rajendra’s “allegations that the truck failed to stop while Gudur sought collection, that there was a physical interaction with the truck prompting Gudur’s resulting fall were sufficient to support a ‘basis in law’ for Rajendra’s cause of action.”

It also said, “We cannot say the alleged cause—the driver’s failure to stop—was too geographically or temporally attenuated from the alleged effect of Mr. Gudur’s fall.”

A Texas appeals court let Sathya Rajendra's lawsuit against Houston proceed after her husband died pursuing a city garbage truck. (Photo by Brett Coomer/Houston Chronicle via Getty Images)

A Texas appeals court let Sathya Rajendra’s lawsuit against Houston proceed after her husband died pursuing a city garbage truck. (Photo by Brett Coomer/Houston Chronicle via Getty Images)

Houston Chronicle/Hearst Newspap/Houston Chronicle via Getty Imag

Could Gudur share responsibility for the fall? 

Houston personal injury attorney Maverick Ray, who reviewed the case for Chron, said the ruling essentially clears a procedural hurdle, but is not a finding that the city owes the family money.

Article continues below this ad

“The city simply lost a procedural door slam that would have just totally prevented this lawsuit,” Ray said. “But it is going to continue forward.”

That leaves a much stranger question for later in the case: If Gudur chose to chase the garbage truck, how much responsibility does he bear for what happened?

Under Texas’ proportionate-responsibility rules, a jury could ultimately assign percentages of fault to Gudur and the city.

“If they come back and say 60 percent, Mr. Gudur, or 60 percent to the driver of the garbage truck and 40 percent to Mr. Gudur, then the family would recover 60 percent of the damages,” Ray said. “But if the jury puts Mr. Gudur, the plaintiffs, at over 50 percent at fault, they recover nothing.”

Article continues below this ad

The city could still try to get the case dismissed later through summary judgment, after the parties have developed evidence through discovery. Ray said the next phase could involve questions such as how fast the truck was traveling, whether the driver could have prevented the incident and what the driver’s responsibilities were after seeing Gudur.

image

Stay informed, and entertained.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms Of Use and acknowledge that your information will be used as described in our Privacy Policy.

“The law also doesn’t say a city gets a free pass just because the injured person made a bad decision,” Ray said.

The 14th Court of Appeals granted the city’s request on Oct. 9 to extend its deadline to seek a rehearing through Oct. 23.

Article continues below this ad

The City of Houston told Chron in an email it was unable to comment as “this matter is currently in litigation.”