The recently decided landmark class action antitrust lawsuit,
House v. NCAA, is expected to restructure the landscape of
collegiate athletics.
On this episode of We get work®, we explore the case, the
settlement and the potential long-term impact on collegiate
athletic departments.
self
Transcript
INTRO
The recently decided landmark class action antitrust
lawsuit, House v. NCAA, is expected to restructure the landscape of
collegiate athletics.
On this episode of We get work®, we explore the case,
the settlement and the potential long-term impact on collegiate
athletic departments.
Today’s hosts are Bernie Dennis, principal in the
Washington D.C. region office of Jackson Lewis, Dani Bland and
Jason Kaner, associates, respectively, in the firm’s Raleigh
and Philadelphia offices.
Bernie, Dani and Jason, the question on everyone’s mind
today is: What changes will collegiate athletics departments be
required to make pursuant to the House settlement, and how will
that impact my business?
CONTENT
Bernie Dennis
Principal, Washington D.C., Region
Welcome everybody to this episode of We get work. We are in
September, students are back on campus, and college sports have
started. What better time to recap what happened this summer in
collegiate athletics with members of our Education and Collegiate
Athletics Group? I’m Bernie Dennis, a principal here in the
Washington, D.C., region office of Jackson Lewis. I’m joined
here by two of our great associates in the Education and Collegiate
Athletics Group, Dani and Jason. I want you guys to go ahead and
introduce yourself really quickly.
Dani Bland
Associate, Raleigh
I’m Dani, and I’m an associate in the Raleigh, North
Carolina, office.
Jason Kaner
Associate, Philadelphia
Hey everyone, Jason Kaner here. I’m an associate in the
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania office.
Dennis
All right, great, everybody. There was a lot of action this
summer on the collegiate athletics front, with what is commonly
called the House Settlement. The House v. NCAA
settlement was accepted by the Courts in early June and led to a
lot of action over the summer with institutions. Why don’t we
just level set for everybody that’s listening in?
Dani, can you tell us what the settlement was about? Who’s
involved with the settlement?
Bland
The House Settlement, as it’s called, consolidates
three antitrust cases that were brought against the NCAA. It
involves currently about 75 institutions that are members of the
ACC, the Big 10, the Big 12, the SEC, and formerly the PAC 12, as
well as the University of Notre Dame. The Power conferences and
then the University of Notre Dame, which is not tied to a
conference. Institutions that will join one of these conferences
during the term of the settlement agreement will be added to that
agreement’s terms as well during the term of the agreement.
Dennis
It’s not just the power conferences, right? Other Division
One institutions had an option to opt in and have an option to opt
in annually as well. The initial deadline is July 1st, and then
March 1st every year. Schools that want to make a move or
participate in the financial portions of this settlement have an
annual option to do so.
Jason, why don’t you tell us a little bit about what the
settlement entailed? What are the details that listeners want to
know?
Kaner
The big number here is $2.78 billion, and that’s the back
pay damages which are going to be paid out over 10 years. The NCAA
is committing this money to current and former D1 athletes. It
comes out to approximately $280 million per year, and the award of
these damages covers the period from June 15th, 2016, through
September 15th of last year. The claims window for current and
former athletes to file a claim is now October 1st, so the
beginning of next month.
The funding for this massive settlement is the NCAA reserve
pools of money, as well as some insurance compensation.
Approximately $1.1 billion is going to come from those two sources.
Then, the remaining $1.6 billion is going to be derived from future
reductions in these annual distributions that are made to the NCAA
member schools.
Dennis
So, you’ve got the NCAA and schools pitching in on this
settlement. Who is receiving the benefit of these? Is the
settlement equally divided amongst athletes, or will there be some
apportionment of the settlement?
Kaner
That’s a great question. Obviously, in NCAA sports, you
think about football and basketball, men’s and women’s, as
the primary earning activities. Within the fund, the payouts are
allocated based on the categories of athlete experience and
what’s categorized as missed NIL opportunities. Some of the
funds are designated explicitly for football and men’s
basketball, women’s basketball, and then other pools for other
sports.
The detailed breakdowns under the plan are in flux, but it looks
like it’s going to be $71.5 million earmarked specifically for
video game NIL compensation for football and men’s basketball.
I know a lot of people love the college football video game. It
came back for the first time last year. This is now the second year
they’ve released it. A men’s basketball game is also
apparently in the works. An additional $1.8 billion is allocated
for broadcast NIL compensation. Again, that is directed towards
football and men’s basketball. $89.5 million is set aside to
cover lost NIL opportunities- that’s cumulatively. Then,
there’s a $600 million pool, which is going to be available for
additional compensation claims.
The distribution framework of all this, I know we just threw a
lot of numbers at you, is 95% of the funds are going to be
dedicated to Power Five Sports, and it’s going to be divided
among football, men’s basketball, women’s basketball, and
the other sports. Three-quarters of it is going to go to football.
Men’s basketball will get about 15%. Women’s basketball,
5%. Then, the remaining 5% to the other sports.
Dennis
A lot of this settlement is lumped in with what they commonly
refer to as those revenue-generating sports, football and
basketball. I’m sure there are people who are not happy about
that- some of those other athletes in other sports.
Dani, have there been any challenges to this appeal over the
summer?
Bland
Yes, there are several different avenues that people are going
to take to challenge and have been taking to challenge this
settlement. First, we saw in an executive order from the Trump
administration, “Save College Sports,” that aims to
preserve what is commonly referred to as Olympic sports and
non-revenue-generating sports, but the Executive Order doesn’t
define what revenue-generating sports are. It’s a little
unclear, but we should be getting some guidance later in September
from the Department of Education on how they want some of those
things to be implemented.
We’ll also see some Title IX challenges to this settlement.
The important thing to note regarding Title IX is that the case
this agreement settles, those three cases, have no Title IX claims
underlying them. However, anyone out there who thinks Title IX
isn’t going to come up is wrong. Under the settlement of
antitrust claims, male student athletes who are anticipated to
receive a good majority of the damages, probably over 90%. Female
student athletes are anticipated to receive about 5% of the damages
to resolve the antitrust claims. The important thing to note,
though, for the schools is that again, these are settlements of
antitrust claims and not Title IX claims. These past damage
calculations shouldn’t be used as a tool to calculate future
payments. It’s not listed as a Title IX-compliant model because
it has nothing to do with Title IX. These are just back damages for
antitrust issues. That is something that schools will need to keep
in mind as they figure out how they’re going to make these
revenue-sharing payments going forward.
Then, you also have your antitrust challenges. Some people argue
that the settlement itself, with the cap of $20.5 million for this
upcoming academic year for the revenue sharing, could be an unfair
restriction on trade. Also, you have the common class issues that
you see in class actions, which are whether the class is adequately
represented and whether they’ll receive adequate notice.
Those are some of the issues and challenges that you may see in
appeals to the settlement.
Dennis
Great, thanks, Dani. As Jason mentioned up front, this
settlement really only covers 10 years. A permanent solution is not
yet in place. Each Congressional session, there continues to be
legislation put forward, and this session is no different. It
remains to be seen if anything will ultimately be passed to provide
some surety. I know the NCAA is still pushing for nationwide
guidance on what those structures are going to be.
That covers a lot of the back pay in how former athletes were
harmed, but this settlement also covers some forward-looking relief
to student athletes in the form of injunctive relief. Jason, why
don’t you tell us something about this injunctive component of
the settlement?
Kaner
Looking forward now for the next 10 years, at least, we have
schools paying direct compensation to student athletes via this
revenue sharing. Starting July 1st, 2025, schools may share up to
22% of their average Power Five revenues with student athletes. The
first year, this payout begins at approximately $20.5 million per
school. That’s the cap in essence. That’ll increase
annually through the next decade, projected at around 4% annually
each for the next couple of years. It could potentially reach up to
$33 million by 2035.
We talked earlier, Dani referenced opting in and opting out. A
great analogy I’ve heard is this is like putting an ante in at
the poker table. You don’t know what’s ahead, but you need
to do it so you can see what’s coming over the next decade.
Dennis
Right, opting in will allow each institution to pay student
athletes directly up to $20.5 million. We’ll see how many
schools fully fund their programs to that maximum. Part of the
settlement is also going to restructure how institutions staff and
have athletes in their programs. Right, Dani, what’s some of
the settlement going to address with that?
Bland
First, as of now, we have 319 schools, so 82% of all D1
institutions have opted in. This is something we’re going to
see across the board in all of Division 1. There was some question
at the beginning about how many schools outside of these power
conferences would opt in, but it seems like everyone wants to be
able to stay competitive.
There is this elimination of scholarship limits, so the previous
headcount cap is lifted, and institutions may now offer more
flexible scholarship models. However, the caveat to that is that
there will be some sports-specific roster limits. For example, a
lot of times the roster may cut down below what we’ve seen the
average rosters be in the past, but you can fund all of those
players with full scholarships if you so choose. For example,
football’s roster cap is now 105 athletes, but there are teams
in Division I who carry as many as 180 student-athletes on their
roster. Now, they’re not subject to those prior scholarship
limits that were far below the 180 number. They can now roster only
105 athletes, but if they wanted to, they could fully scholarship
all 105 of them. It is a huge game-changer, especially with those
top athletes.
Dennis
Dani, you mentioned that there are going to be roster limits
that are going to leave out 75 to 80 football players, and other
athletes in other sports are going to have their roster spots cut
by these roster limits. That held up some of the acceptance and led
to the court’s reluctance to accept this settlement. The
settlement ultimately addressed that. What does the settlement do
for those athletes?
Bland
Right. The settlement kept in mind the fact that there would be
this shift in rosters. Rosters are having to shrink, which would
obviously impact student-athletes who are currently playing their
sport and potentially losing their spot. The deadline was back in
July to designate a student athlete. The idea was that you would
essentially mark the athletes who are going to be cut if you were
limited to the roster cap that is now in place. But that athlete is
allowed to participate for the rest of their eligibility and
doesn’t count against your cap. Then, moving forward, it gives
some leeway for a few years for this settlement and new roster
sizes to go into effect so that you’re not really upending
these student athletes’ academic and athletic careers by
suddenly just dropping the settlement on them. It gives a nice
transition period.
These athletes who were rostered or recruited by April 7th,
2025, and were designated as of the deadline are exempt from
counting against the new roster limits for the rest of their
eligibility. Whether they have four years remaining of eligibility
or one year remaining, the timeline follows the athlete as opposed
to the school.
Dennis
That designation will follow the athlete, not just in their
careers at their current institutions, but should they transfer,
they wouldn’t count against their new institution’s roster
limits, too. That designation was important for schools to get in
by the deadline over the summer.
With these changes, roster limits, and direct payments to
student athletes, there have still been grumblings about concerns
about competition and pay for play. How is this settlement going to
be enforced, Jason?
Kaner
The shiny new oversight committee that’s being rolled out is
the College Sports Commission, the CSC. It’s brand new.
It’s an independent enforcement body for all these
settlement-related terms. The CSC was created and reports to the
Power Five commissioners, rather than the NCAA itself, in
Indianapolis. The NCAA will still handle enforcement for rules
outside the settlement scope. Bryan Seeley, who’s a former
Department of Justice attorney and MLB compliance chief, is now the
CEO of this new commission. He’s being tasked with oversight
and making sure that oversight is meaningful. The CSC is going to
provide compliance guidance, NIL deals, and reporting requirements
via NIL Go. They’re going to administer the revenue sharing
under this CAPS, College Athlete Payment System model, manage
roster assignments, and enforce the arbitration protocols that are
going to be in place. Overall, it’s a comprehensive enforcement
body that’s going to hopefully bring some clarity to this
system.
Now, I mentioned NIL Go. That’s a big piece of this. NIL
payments for deals that are going to be over $600 need to be
reported now via this NIL Go portal. It’s going to be operated
by the CSC and Deloitte, a Big Four accounting firm. It’s to
confirm the market value of these deals and make sure that
there’s some transparency. There are major enforcement
questions here, so we’ll see. This is the first year it’s
going to be rolled out.
There are also some questions about how arbitration is going to
look under the CSC model. The arbitration they’re trying to
roll out is mandatory expedited arbitration in a very short
timeline. We’re all litigators here, so we know that’s not
always easy. We’ll see how that goes, but there’s a valiant
effort via the CSC to oversee this whole process.
Dennis
With the CSC reporting to the conferences, they’re trying to
build in a little bit of flexibility and ability to respond swiftly
to institutions’ and Power Conference concerns. We did see a
little bit of that already over the summer. At the beginning of
July, the CSC has been rolling out guidance about how it’s
going to evaluate these deals. It seemed to indicate that they
weren’t going to look too favorably upon the use of collectives
by institutions. Those Power Conferences said, hold up, we’ve
got this system in place. Within a couple of weeks, the CSC
guidance changed. We’ll see if that’s an initial function
of this new governing body that is so flexible, as its guidance is
new, or if that’s going to continue to be something where
they’re going to be at the whim of what the Power Conferences
want to do in how they adjust and go through things. Certainly, as
any challenges to deals, rosters, or anything like that come up,
and we have these arbitration hearings in place, how quickly they
can resolve that to everybody’s satisfaction is certainly going
to be an ongoing issue.
Then, like you said, Jason, the NCAA is still going to cover
things outside of this settlement. Anything about eligibility
issues and things like that. We’ve continued to see over this
summer, just putting a bow on everything, that there continue to be
those challenges. Does junior college eligibility count against
your time to compete under NCAA rules? Circuits seem to start
splitting on that issue. Just recently, actually just last night, I
believe there was a challenge to the “four-and-five
rule,” and whether that’s an antitrust violation. As busy
a summer as it was, it’s going to continue to be interesting to
follow sports this fall as our competition ramps up. We’ve got
one weekend of college football in the books with some exciting
games and some exciting new athletes.
Thanks for joining us. Feel free to reach out to us or a member
of the Jackson Lewis Education and Collegiate Athletics Group with
any questions you may have. We look forward to assisting any
institution with questions they might have as these things
progress, and we keep an eye on everything.
OUTRO
Thank you for joining us on We get work®. Please tune
into our next program where we will continue to tell you not only
what’s legal, but what is effective. We get work® is
available to stream and subscribe to on Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
For more information on today’s topic, our presenters and other
Jackson Lewis resources, visit jacksonlewis.com.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.