
Settled Expectations Considered for Discretionary
Denial: Acting Director Coke Morgan Stewart’s March 26
memorandum introduced the concept of settled expectations without
limiting it to patent owners or petitioners, expanding the scope of
considerations for discretionary denial of inter partes review
petitions.
Initial Settled Expectations Decisions Favored Patent
Owners: Early decisions by the Acting Director often
favored patent owners by denying institution where challenged
patents had been in force for six years or more.
Petitioners Can Also Have Settled
Expectations: Recent PTAB decisions show a new trend in
applying settled expectations, recognizing that petitioners’
arguments regarding long delays in enforcement, expired patents,
prior nonassertion, and successful prior PTAB outcomes can
successfully counter discretionary denial.
Former U.S. Patent and Trademark Office Acting Director Coke
Morgan Stewart’s March 26 memorandum providing interim
processes for Patent Trial and Appeal Board workload management
identified several new factors that the director now considers in
determining whether to discretionarily deny inter partes review
petitions, including “settled expectations of the
parties.”
Stewart, now deputy director of the USPTO, has typically applied
this factor in favor of patent owners, frequently exercising
discretion to deny petitions challenging patents that have been in
force for six or more years due to a patent owner’s settled
expectations.
Recent decisions, however, illustrate that petitioners are
having increased success in asserting that their own settled
expectations are sufficient to avoid discretionary denial of
institution.
Such settled expectations have come in the form of long delays
in a patent owner filing an infringement lawsuit, the patent owner
unexpectedly asserting its patent in new industries or technology
spaces, or when the petitioner has previously succeeded in
challenging a related patent.
This article explores these evolving changes in the PTAB
landscape, including cases such as Apple Inc. v. Ferid
Allani; Home Depot USA Inc. v. H2 Intellect LLC;
DataDome SA v. Arkose Labs Holdings Inc.; and POSCO Co. Ltd. v. ArcelorMittal.
IPR Petitioners Can Have Settled Expectations
Too
Stewart’s March 26 memorandum did not limit the settled
expectations factor to the expectations of either patent owners or
petitioners. Early decisions on discretionary denial, however,
frequently indicated that patent owners may be considered to have
settled expectations tied to the age of the patent.
As more decisions have issued, it has become clear petitioners
too may establish settled expectations in certain circumstances,
supporting referral of their petitions for consideration by the
PTAB on the merits.
Initial Settled Expectation Decisions
In the months immediately following the March 26 memorandum,
Stewart typically applied settled expectations in favor of patent
owners, particularly when patents had been in force for six years
or more.
That approach aligned with prior statements from Stewart tying
the doctrine to Title 35 of the U.S. Code, Section 286, which
imposes a six-year statute of limitations for recovering
infringement damages. In Dabico Airport Solutions Inc. v. AXA
Power APS, decided by the PTAB on June 18, the director
explained:
Although there is no bright-line rule on when expectations
become settled, in general, the longer the patent has been in
force, the more settled expectations should be. This approach
aligns with other approaches to settled expectations and
incentives, for example, for filing infringement lawsuits.
By mid-2025, the settled expectations factor operated primarily
as a shield against IPR institution, favoring patent owners. Recent
director decisions, however, illustrate a shift: Petitioners are
beginning to leverage their own settled expectations successfully,
sometimes even against Fintiv considerations that could otherwise
support discretionary denial.
Petitioners’ Settled Expectations: Recognized, But
Not Always Enough
The director’s recent decisions reflect a willingness to
credit petitioners’ reliance on settled expectations arguments,
even if they are not always dispositive.
In DataDome SA v. Arkose Labs Holdings, Inc., decided Aug. 14, both parties invoked settled
expectations.
The patent owner emphasized that the challenged patents had been
in force for 17 and 10 years. The petitioner argued it had relied
on the prior owner’s failure to assert the patents, pointing to
licensing discussions a year or two earlier where the petitioner
stated that they did not believe they required a license to the
identified patents, indicating they had apparently evaluated the
patents.
The director acknowledged that a concession of noninfringement
could establish petitioner expectations, but concluded that the
petitioner’s argument was not enough to outweigh the patent
owner’s expectations, based on the length of time the patents
had been in force.
The petitioners have also argued that they reasonably expected
nonassertion where their technology was fundamentally different
from the claimed inventions.
In BOE Technology Group Co. v. Optronic Sciences LLC,
decided July 29, the petitioner argued that its
accused products used a top-gate transistor structure, precisely
the opposite of the bottom-gate structure claimed in the challenged
patents, such that it therefore had no reason to expect
assertion.
The director credited this as weighing against discretionary
denial, but ultimately concluded that the patents’ 12-year age
and the earlier district court trial schedule created stronger
settled expectations for the patent owner.
The same line of reasoning surfaced again in Transcend
Information Inc. v. Truesight Communications LLC, decided Aug. 4. Transcend argued it reasonably
expected no infringement allegations because the patent required a
kiosk, which it did not make.
The director acknowledged the argument, citing BOE, but again
found that the patent’s 10-year duration and the earlier
district court trial date overcame Petitioner’s
settled-expectations argument.
When Petitioners’ Settled Expectations Prove
Decisive
Other recent cases demonstrate that the petitioner’s
reliance on settled expectations arguments can be sufficient to
avoid denial. These outcomes highlight circumstances in which
petitioners can invoke settled expectations effectively.
One theme is delay in enforcement. In Apple Inc. v. Ferid
Allani, decided Sept. 5, the patent owner first contacted the
petitioner about a license in 2012.
The petitioner declined, stating that it did not need one, and
the patent was not asserted until eleven years later, after it had
expired. Under these facts, the director found that the petitioner
had sufficient settled expectations of nonenforcement to avoid a
discretionary denial of institution.
Another important consideration concerns industry expectations.
In Home Depot USA Inc. v. H2 Intellect LLC, decided Sept.
4, the patent had been in force for more than 12 years.
The petitioner argued it had no reason to anticipate assertion
in its industry because the patent owner had previously targeted
smartphones, tablets and watches, but never hardware retail. The
director agreed, finding the petitioner’s settled expectations
more persuasive than the patent owner’s and referred the
petition.
Petitioners have also succeeded by invoking prior success in
challenging related patents. In POSCO Co. v.
ArcelorMittal, decided June 25, an ongoing U.S. International
Trade Commission investigation suggested denial.
The ITC trial was set to conclude about nine months before the
PTAB’s projected final written decision date, suggesting that
the board’s decision would not be issued until after the
conclusion of the ITC investigation.
However, the petitioner pointed to its earlier success in
invalidating all claims of a parent patent in a previous case
— also POSCO Co. v. ArcelorMittal — decided Jan. 5,
2021. The director concluded that it was reasonable for the
petitioner to expect the related claims to be vulnerable, and
institution was referred despite the parallel proceeding.
Finally, reliance may be persuasive where a patent has already
expired or lapsed. In Globus Medical Inc. v. Spinelogik
Inc., decided June 12, the patents had been in force for
eight years but expired four years earlier due to nonpayment of
maintenance fees. The director concluded that the petitioner
reasonably expected nonenforcement and referred the petition,
notwithstanding the patent owner’s arguments to the
contrary.
Key Lessons for Practitioners
Taken together, these cases illustrate an evolution in how the
settled expectations factor is applied.
As the director’s decisions show, petitioners that can
demonstrate reliance on license negotiation history, delays in
enforcement, industry norms, prior PTAB outcomes or expired rights
may avoid denial even when other factors might tend to support
denying institution.
No longer the exclusive domain of patent owners, the March 26
memorandum’s settled expectations factor now provides
petitioners with multiple viable pathways to argue reliance on
their own settled expectations to avoid discretionary denial and
have their petitions referred to a PTAB panel for consideration on
the merits.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.