Morten A. Lund’s articles from Foley & Lardner are most popular:
with readers working within the Business & Consumer Services industries
Foley & Lardner are most popular:
within Criminal Law, Government, Public Sector and Tax topic(s)
Key Takeaways:
Energy is now a strategic priority: Reshoring
manufacturers must treat energy planning as key to cost,
resilience, and sustainability.
Policy shifts require flexibility: Evolving
federal energy priorities make tailored, jurisdiction-aware
strategies essential.
Plan early and strategically: Each energy
option — RECs, PPAs, or on-site generation — carries
long-term legal and financial implications.
As manufacturers accelerate plans to re-shore operations to the
U.S., energy strategy has become one of the most material and
multidimensional issues in the facility planning process. For
energy-intensive industries, power procurement isn’t just a
line item on the budget or a utility concern — it’s a
strategic input with legal, financial, and operational
implications.
This importance is amplified by today’s political and
regulatory uncertainty. The Trump administration has already made
significant changes to the energy landscape, and has signaled that
more is to come. This could mean different priorities for
decarbonization, incentives for renewables, or permitting rules for
fossil fuel projects and transmission lines.
These shifting priorities directly affect how manufacturers
evaluate energy options — especially when long-term
investments are at stake. Manufacturers must take a more strategic
and tailored approach to energy planning to ensure operational
goals and cost structure for decades.
Features of Energy for Manufacturing
Manufacturers’ energy needs are different than many other
types of commercial operations:
Load Size: Manufacturing operations, in
particular heavy manufacturing, often have relatively large loads.
This opens additional supply avenues to manufacturers, and provides
market leverage.
Load Profile: Manufacturing operations have
relatively consistent and predictable energy needs, particularly
facilities that operate multiple shifts.
Long horizons: Manufacturing facilities are
long-lived assets. This allows manufacturers to make energy
decisions over decades instead of months.
Consistency and uptime: Energy interruptions
mean costly facility downtime. For some manufacturers, energy
interruptions mean damage to inventory or equipment, and protection
against energy interruption is of paramount importance.
Process Steam: Some manufacturing operations
also require thermal energy, process steam, or similar non-electric
energy inputs. Such requirements will substantially limit the
available energy supply options. Here, we will focus on
electric-only load requirements.
For manufacturers, energy supply is on par with labor
availability and similar operational planning. In some sectors,
energy considerations even outweigh traditional factors like real
estate cost or proximity to suppliers. Energy should be an
intentional operational opportunity to align with long-term cost,
sustainability, and resilience goals.
Four Strategic Energy Goals
Manufacturers’ energy strategies balance some combination of
four competing energy goals:
Reducing total energy costs, particularly in
price-sensitive or energy-intensive sectors.
Price predictability, to support long-term
financial planning.
“Greening” the energy supply, for
ESG or regulatory reasons. For some products and jurisdictions, a
sufficiently green energy supply may also extend “green”
benefits to the manufacturer’s products.
Interruption protection, to avoid operational
losses and liabilities.
No energy strategy can perfectly achieve all of these goals
simultaneously, however. Choices and compromises must be made.
Energy Management Approaches
With competing energy goals in play, manufacturers should
evaluate available management approaches which vary in complexity,
commitment, and impact.
Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs). While
technically not energy, RECs are a straightforward tool for
achieving energy greening goals. The manufacturer buys energy from
the grid (or any other source), and separately purchase RECs in the
desired amounts. This allows the manufacturer to offset the
emissions from purchased energy.
Pros: Low cost; limited commitment; easy to
execute; no physical facility required.
Cons: Increases overall energy cost; does not
contribute towards goals other than greening.
Use case: Companies needing quick ESG
reporting solutions or early-stage green targets.
Offsite Power Purchase (Virtual or Physical
Delivery). With this approach, the manufacturer signs an
agreement with the owner of a power plant not co-located with the
manufacturing facility, and the remote power plant supplies energy
to the manufacturing facility. This energy will reduce the amount
of energy purchased from the local utility. These long-term
financial contracts allow manufacturers to lock in their energy
cost long-term.
Pros: May provide overall cost reduction,
price certainty, and energy greening; no local construction
required.
Cons: Potentially long-term commitment;
limited availability in fully-regulated energy markets; does not
provide interruption protection; remote supply may not provide
energy greening in all circumstances.
Use case: Sophisticated buyers with strong
legal/financial teams.
On-Site Energy Facility. An energy facility
constructed at or adjacent to the manufacturing facility can
provide energy generation, energy storage, or both.
Pros: Strong alignment with all four goals;
physical interruption protection available.
Cons: Requires land, capital, and time for
development and construction; long-term commitment.
Use case: Long-term manufacturing facilities
with access to land or favorable permitting regimes; manufacturing
facilities that require interruption protection.
Microgrids. Self-contained energy systems that
can island from the grid offer resilience and autonomy. Microgrids
combine multiple generation and storage solutions to maximize
control of energy supply.
Pros: Resilience; price control; custom
design.
Cons: High operational complexity; regulatory
hurdles; redundancy/oversupply may be required.
Use case: Mission-critical manufacturing;
remote or off-grid locations.
Choosing a Path: Legal and Operational
Considerations
No matter the technology, key decision parameters should guide
manufacturers’ energy planning:
Setup time – Strategies that require
energy plant development/construction generally take longer than
strategies involving only contractual arrangements. Technologies
require differing lead times.
Commitment Duration – Most of the
options discussed require long-term commitment, but the duration of
that commitment can vary significantly depending on technology and
structure selections. Factor those timelines into your choice.
Financial and Contractual Terms – The
contracts involved in energy planning can be complex, and the
specific terms can vary significantly. Evaluation of financial and
contractual details should be considered early in the process.
Regulatory Considerations – Energy
generation and transmission is highly regulated everywhere, but
there is still significant variation across jurisdictions. The
process, structure, terms, and even availability of both on-site
and off-site solutions will be subject to and limited by
local/regional rules.
Siting and Permitting – Local zoning and
environmental rules can change the cost/benefit analysis for
various energy strategies, and in some cases may limit available
on-site options.
Manufacturers planning new or expanded U.S. operations should
take an informed, flexible, and jurisdiction-aware approach to
energy. Navigating energy strategies involves considering long-term
commitments, regulatory landscapes, and financial and operational
considerations. With proper planning, manufacturers can align their
energy strategies with broader business objectives, ensuring
operational efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and sustainability in
an unpredictable energy landscape.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.