In response to the alarming rise in workplace violence,
particularly in the retail industry, states have begun implementing
laws requiring employers to actively address this potential threat
via policies and training.

On this episode of We get work®, we unpack the different
state requirements for workplace violence prevention plans, and
what employers can do to help keep their employees safe.

self

Transcript

INTRO

In response to the alarming rise in workplace violence,
particularly in the retail industry, states have begun implementing
laws requiring employers to actively address this potential threat
via policies and training.

On this episode of We get work®, we unpack the different
state requirements for workplace violence prevention plans, and
what employers can do to help keep their employees safe.

Today’s hosts are Tania Mistretta, co-leader of the
Retail Group, and Sierra Vierra, member of the firm’s Workplace
Safety and Health group and principals, respectively, in the New
York City and Salt Lake City offices of Jackson Lewis. They are
joined by Adrienne Wood, an associate in the New Orleans office and
also a member of the Workplace Safety and Health group.

Tania, Sierra, Adrienne, the question on everyone’s mind
today is: What should employers consider when creating a workplace
violence prevention plan, and how will that impact my
business?

CONTENT

Tania Mistretta

Principal, New York City

Happy to be here with Sierra and Adrienne to have an engaging
discussion around workplace violence and some of the challenges
that a lot of our national retail clients are facing.

Just to start off with that in mind, what are some of the
challenges? I know we have a slew of state law developments in the
workplace violence space, specific to retail. What sort of
challenges are you seeing in terms of workplace violence for our
retail clients?

Adrienne M. Wood

Associate, New Orleans

Hey, Tania, thank you so much for joining us. Unfortunately,
workplace violence is a growing issue. We have data from the Bureau
of Labor to back that up, which shows, in particular, in the retail
industry in 2023 alone, there were 306 fatalities, and 30% of those
were homicides. That’s just not acceptable.

Even without that data, more employees are reporting their fears
of violence. Part of that is the rise in weapons – people can
now bring weapons to the grocery store in certain states. That
threat of brandishing a weapon has certainly had an effect on our
employees. There’s been a recent rise in smash-and-grabs in
retail establishments. We’ve also seen folks are just getting
agitated and aggressive lately, and they’ve been taking it out
on retailers. It is a huge problem for many of our clients.

Mistretta

With that in mind, what tools and tricks of the trade can we
advise our clients on in terms of combating workplace violence?

Wood

I’ll chime in on that. I’m really grateful that we have
so many clients who are so concerned about keeping their employees
safe. They come to us and say, what can we do? The first thing we
always ask our clients is do you have a written workplace violence
prevention plan? A lot of times, they say no, what’s that?
Then, we look to our team of subject matter experts to draft those
plans for our clients.

We always say, what good is a plan or a policy if there’s no
training in place? We can also assist our clients with doing that
training, whether we do a nationwide training for the managers, and
then they can go on and train on a store-by-store basis. We’re
happy to come on-site and do that training. It’s very important
that employees not only know their policies, but also be trained on
the procedures and how to put them into action.

Sierra Vierra

Principal, Salt Lake City

To add on to that, Adrienne, one of the best opportunities we
have to prevent violence in the workplace is by cooperating with
our employees and really engaging them to help us identify problems
before they lead to serious issues. We encourage all of our clients
to actively engage with their employees to help identify potential
issues and to help us identify workable solutions so that they can
go to work safely each day and go home in the same condition they
went to work in.

Mistretta

That really is the goal – workplace safety and making sure
that our people are safe. I find a lot of people forget about the
different trainings that are available, like active shooter
trainings, which I know we’ve had more clients reach out to us
requesting. Creativity and communication are so key.

We’ve talked about a few things in terms of workplace
violence prevention plans. What do those really look like? What are
the core pieces that the client should strive to achieve with their
plans? In states, of course, where there are no specific
requirements, which I know we’ll definitely want to talk about
as well.

Vierra

Some states have very specific requirements for what’s in
that program. Really, for me, it comes down to three key issues.
First, we need to identify the hazards and the fixes for them.
Creating the program is one of the best opportunities we have to do
that very deep dive into a business and figure out if there are
active hazards that have not been addressed yet. The next thing is,
do we have procedures for how we respond to an emergency? Workplace
violence can, of course, escalate to an emergency response. Along
with that, what are the channels for how we report a workplace
violence incident, whether or not it’s ongoing or suspected to
occur in the future? Then, the third is, again, how do we
communicate this information to our teammates? How do we train them
on our policies and procedures? How do we get them engaged in
helping us create this program?

Mistretta

You alluded to state requirements. Is there anything at the
federal level that we need to be focusing on or that our clients
need to be focusing on right now for workplace violence?

Wood

At the moment, there is no standard on the federal level.
There’s some guidance material on OSHA’s website, but there
is no actual standard that is binding on any of our clients at the
federal level.

Mistretta

How about just general duty clause issues that we have to be
specific or aware of, or anything there?

Vierra

Wow, good keywords, my friend. Yes.

Mistretta

What little I know about OSHA. I do not feign to be an OSHA
attorney, but is there anything at the federal level we should be
thinking about?

Vierra

Yes, federal OSHA is still using the General Duty Clause to
address workplace violence deficiencies with employers. So, yes,
employers nationally still should be thinking about potential OSHA
enforcement actions arising from workplace violence incidents.

Mistretta

If nothing at the federal level, I know we’ve at least got
New York and California for retail. Can we talk about some of the
differences and similarities, especially for our national employers
who have clients in both states, which, California and New York, I
don’t have to tell you, are challenging.

Vierra

Let’s talk just quickly about California’s program.
California was ahead of the game. Its workplace violence prevention
program went into effect in July 2024. We’re well past the
one-year mark of that law being in effect. We’re still waiting
for regulations to be issued to enforce that new law. California is
a little unique. It applies to pretty much every employer in the
state. There are some exceptions. That’s very common for
teleworking employees, but it has a huge application to retail
employers in the state.

Some key elements for California’s requirement are that we
have to have a written workplace violence prevention program. It
really needs to be customized to each location. Employees have to
be involved in developing it, and we have to review it regularly at
least once a year. Employees are required to be trained on that
program, and then retraining is required at least annually after
that. We also have some record-keeping obligations in California.
Workplace violence incidents need to be logged. We need to keep
records of our investigations, hazard assessments, corrective
actions, and training. There are a lot of record-keeping
requirements that employers need to follow. It’s a lot of
fun.

Adrienne can tell us a little bit about New York’s
requirements.

Wood

Fortunately, the New York requirements are not very different
than the California ones. They definitely overlap in some areas.
One of the biggest areas where they do not overlap is who has to
have these plans in place. Unlike California’s where it’s
broad—pretty much all the employers need these plans
–in New York, it’s very specific to retailers. That
definition is actually a very interesting one. It only applies to
establishments with 10 or more employees, and they have to
basically sell goods.

Some of the key requirements are like Sierra alluded to earlier,
the written workplace violence prevention policy needs to be
written. An employer cannot just go speak to their employees and
tell them what to do if somebody breaks into the store. It needs to
be written down, and the employees need to be able to access
it.

Included in that plan, we need to have the workplace violence
risk factors. Sierra mentioned earlier that it’s going to be
very different with each brick-and-mortar store. One might be in a
neighborhood that might have higher crime rates; therefore,
that’s going to be a factor. One might open really early in the
morning or stay open really late at night; that’s going to be a
factor. The plan also must have prevention methods. It needs to
cite the local law. It also importantly needs an anti-retaliation
statement to be clear that employees, if they report any incidents
or any complaints about their safety they will not be retaliated
against.

New York, like California, also has a model plan, but these
items can be very confusing for employees, so they come to us to
help them draft these plans. Also, the New York plan has training
requirements, and this training is pretty thorough. It needs to be
done during working hours. It needs to do an overview of the Retail
Worker Safety Act requirements, the tactics for protecting against
and de-escalating workplace violence, the role of supervisors and
managers in the reporting and response to that, as well as active
shooter procedures. The training must be upon hire as well as
annually or every two years, depending on the size of the
business.

Interestingly enough, the one way that these two plans do differ
is beginning January 1st, 2027, silent response buttons must be
installed in New York retailers. There is an alternative that is
installing some type of applications on an employee’s phone, or
they can use personal wearable panic buttons. However, New York is
giving their employers about a year and a half head start to get
those in place because they are complicated and not as simple as
they sound.

Mistretta

We’ve seen states issue model plans. I know a lot of clients
struggle with this, where they just take the model plan and they
go, there I have it, right? Really, those model plans are just a
base template, which you have to go through and fill out. I know a
lot of our Jackson Lewis attorneys are supporting that
endeavor.

We’ve talked about some of the similarities and some of the
differences. Anything else in terms of the differences between
California and New York that we want to cover, or do you have any
other practical takeaways before we end?

Vierra

A couple of the key differences really are the scope of
who’s covered by these rules. Again, California is very broad,
and general industry is included in these new laws’
requirements. Then, in New York, we’re looking at retail
employers. Arguably, that law is better crafted and tailored for
the challenges that retail employers are facing. Whereas in
California, employers of all shapes and sizes are being forced to
fit into one standard that really does not apply very well to
different types of organizations.

Another difference, California is very big on stressing the
requirement of having active employee involvement in developing and
implementing the program. New York does not have that same emphasis
in the current version of its program. Whether that changes in the
future, we don’t know, but that is a very unique distinction
about how the program gets developed.

To Adrienne’s point, California doesn’t require the
panic buttons that are going to be required in New York for retail
employers. Whether employers in California voluntarily adopt that
system will be up to each employer and what makes sense for their
establishment. We’ll give New York’s requirements a test
drive and see how that works.

Mistretta

That’s the challenge with all of this evolving. As new
measures and technologies come into place, it raises the question
of whether that falls under the general duty. Is that something
that we need to add a minimum due to keep our employees safe?

Thank you both. This was very helpful in terms of final
takeaways for our listeners. Any practical advice that you would
recommend to employers who are concerned about workplace safety,
who want to take measures to keep staff safe? Any final thoughts
before we wrap up?

Vierra

To go back to some of the critical elements of a workplace
violence prevention program, conduct your risk assessments and
address the hazards that you find. Look at your current safety
protocols and think about how they can be improved. For me, safety
programs are never finished. They’re something that we can
constantly reevaluate and improve to keep employees safe. Then,
make sure you’re doing your regular training and keeping good
documentation of your training.

Adrienne, what else do you think?

Wood

Employers, if you are operating in more than one state, you need
to be vigilant in monitoring the legislation on this. We’ve
seen a rise in workplace violence requirements in the healthcare
sector, and the retail sector is going to be next. We need to be
monitoring that on a state-by-state basis.

Mistretta

Fantastic. Thank you, Sierra and Adrienne. For any of our
listeners who are looking for more information, please stay tuned
and reach out to the Jackson Lewis attorney with whom you regularly
work. Thanks, everyone.

OUTRO

Thank you for joining us on We get work®. Please tune
into our next program where we will continue to tell you not only
what’s legal, but what is effective. We get work® is
available to stream and subscribe to on Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
For more information on today’s topic, our presenters and other
Jackson Lewis resources, visit jacksonlewis.com.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.