Proskauer Rose LLP are most popular:


within Energy and Natural Resources topic(s)
with readers working within the Banking & Credit industries

For many patent cases, the United States District Court hearing
your patent dispute can have a big impact on case strategy, budget
and management, and even, to some extent, case outcomes. As we
discussed earlier this year, how a patent owner approaches an
alleged infringer can turn into a costly and inconvenient endeavor
if forced to defend their patents in an unexpected
jurisdiction
. A recent case out of the District of Arizona
illustrates the opposite scenario – where the activities of
an accused infringer results in a suboptimal venue for that
defendant.

Evergreen Telemetry LLC (“Evergreen”) is an
Arizona-based company that sells products related to wireless
heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (“HVAC”) tools
and systems. Evergreen filed a patent infringement lawsuit against
Fieldpiece Instruments, Inc. (“Fieldpiece”) in the U.S.
District Court for the District of Arizona. Fieldpiece is a
Southern California-based company that is incorporated in Delaware.
Normally, in a case like this, one would expect the proper venue to
be the Southern District of California or the District of Delaware,
or another district where Fieldpiece has a “regular and
established place of business.” Fieldpiece, accordingly, filed
a Motion to Dismiss for Improper Venue – the Court denied the
motion.

At the heart of this case is Evergreen’s allegation that
“a ‘Fieldpiece Sales Representative’ lives in and
maintains a home-based office in Arizona, stores work-related
materials in their home-based office, accepts orders, makes
business decisions, solicits customers, engages in technician
training, and takes part in industry and community events on behalf
of [Fieldpiece].” The Court agreed with Evergreen after
analyzing the facts in view of the three requirements laid out in
the Federal Circuit decision In re Cray Inc. – for a
defendant to have a “regular and established place of
business” within a district: “(1) there must be a
physical place in the district; (2) it must be a regular and
established place of business; and (3) it must be the place of the
defendant.”

The Court found that the “physical place” requirement
was met because “the products stored in Defendant’s
employees’ homes are used to fulfill their job duties at
locations throughout Arizona.” The Court held that the
“regular and established” requirement was satisfied
because “of the steady, uniform, orderly, and methodical
business that both starts and finishes at the sales
representatives’ homes, with visits to distributors in
between.” Finally, with respect to finding that the
“place of the defendant” requirement was established by
the conduct of a sole employee, the Court placed great weight on
“Fieldpiece’s ‘business specifically depend[ing] on
employees being present’ in Arizona and it[s affirmative]
act[s] to make permanent operations within that district to service
its customers there.'”

Takeaway

The patent venue provides a fair bit of certainty as to where
businesses will defend patent disputes. The Evergreen case
illustrates how this advantage can be undermined or even
eviscerated when employees conducting regular business outside of a
company’s principal places of business. As companies continue
to adjust remote work policies, the Proskauer Intellectual Property
Team can assist in auditing these policies to better prepare for
venue disputes. Our team continually monitors the evolving caselaw
with respect to personal jurisdiction and venue. We welcome
questions about how these considerations may impact your ability to
optimally defend yourself in connection with patent disputes.

Stay Aware: Remote Employees Impact Venue Options
In Patent Litigation

The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.