Sure, when it comes to save percentage, Pickford is middle of the pack, but that is an entirely predictable consequence of facing far more shots than any other keeper in that time – see above graphic.
In the interests of balance, Pickford has also conceded a lot more goals than any other keeper in that time.
However, as my colleague Chris Bevan pointed out earlier this week, Pickford actually prevented the most goals in the Premier League last season so is continuing to prove his worth.
Things are looking up too. Having broken Gordon Banks’ consecutive clean sheets for England record earlier this week – he has not conceded a goal for his country at all in 2025 – club side Everton are sitting eighth in the early standings.
Eyeing a top-six spot for the first time?
His words on signing his contract extension were notable, stating “we want to be a team that competes in Europe” and “hopefully some silverware as well”.
For one of this grand old club’s most loyal recent servants, that kind of legacy would be fitting.