Last updated on February 27, 2026
All Will Be One | Illustration by Esau Escorza, Isaac Escorza & Luis Antonio Delgado
Cowabanga, MTG folks! It’s time to take a deep look at another MTG collection and focus on new card values. Whether you’re preparing yourself for the local Prerelease or thinking about getting the new EDH precon or some Play Boosters, it’s important to know the set’s contents in advance, especially if you want to trade stuff you open. Here, I’m considering all the different Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles sets. Before we begin, let’s highlight all the different products:
Oh, and if you haven’t already, check out this video version we just uploaded to YouTube!
These prices were taken from TCGplayer on February 25, 2026 and are subject to significant changes after the set fully releases.
#29. [TMC] Tempestra, Dame of Games – $10.50
This card almost didn’t make the list, as its price has been fluctuating wildly on TCGplayer, so we can’t guarantee anything about its long-term value. Still, Tempestra, Dame of Games is a nice way of throwing copies of creatures at your opponent’s faces while maximizing their attack, enter, and death triggers.
#28. [TMT] The Cloning of Shredder – $10.50
It’s 6 mana, but The Cloning of Shredder can provide a lot of value. You’re basically making three token copies of a creature card from your graveyard, and they’re not legendary, so many cool interactions can happen. Cards that double the number of tokens produced will do a lot of work here.
#27. [TMT] Triceraton Commander – $11.00
MTG players love dinosaurs, creature lords, and X-mana spells that create more stuff. Triceraton Commander is in the center of this crazy Venn diagram, except that it can’t be your commander, so you’ll have to be happy about adding this to your favorite dinosaur deck. This card can be an excellent mana sink that creates many dinosaurs and Jumps them later.
#26. [TMC] Ninja Pizza – $11.00
Making foods you control generate mana of any color is awesome, and each turn you’ll create a Food token for free. Many cards will love the free Food that Ninja Pizza provides, and in a deck that already makes Food, this can be a huge ramp piece. Decks that make infinite Food as a combo can now turn that into infinite mana, too.
#25. [TMT] Donatello, Mutant Mechanic – $11.00
Donatello, Mutant Mechanic can give three +1/+1 counters to any artifact you control, including creatures, with its tap ability. Similar to the modular mechanic, you can transfer these counters between artifacts or creatures after they die. But the real value here is when we can turn vehicles with strong attack abilities into creatures without crewing, or turn indestructible artifact lands into creatures. MTG has some ways to tap and untap infinitely, so this card can be a fun and versatile artifact commander.
Continue? has the making of a future MTG staple. For only 2 mana, you can return up to four creatures that died this turn, and you can use this card to recover from a wrath effect, a bad combat, or just to keep sacrificing creatures and getting more value.
#23. [TMC] City of Brass – $11.50
City of Brass is one of MTG’s classic 5-color lands. It enters untapped, and the downside of being pinged each time you use the land is small next to the benefits, especially in EDH. The last time it was reprinted was in Double Masters 2022. This is usually a $20 card, so this version will be a $10 card for the foreseeable future.
#22. [PZA] Umezawa’s Jitte – $12.00
The classic equipment deemed too strong for many Constructed formats, Umezawa’s Jitte is very similar to Raphael’s classic Sai weapon, and thus it deserved a reprint. This card sees play in Cube, Commander equipment decks, and it turns combat into a nightmare, not to mention the ability to kill low-toughness creatures quickly.
#21. [TMT] Leonardo, Sewer Samurai – $12.00
Sneaking Leonardo, Sewer Samurai in is a way to give a 3/3 double striker “haste” and surprise-hit someone for 6. This card looks well-positioned to see play across formats like Commander and Standard, and the ability to cast creatures with power or toughness 1 for free every turn can’t be overlooked either. Many creatures that enter and make your opponent discard, lose life, or sacrifice creatures have 1 toughness, so there’s plenty of value to be had.
#20. [PZA] Underworld Breach – $14.00
Underworld Breach is a very broken card and it’s easily breakable. If you want to mill your entire deck and win via Thassa’s Oracle, you can do that. You can also cast a lot of spells in a turn or fill your graveyard for value. And that’s just a 2-mana enchantment card. A premium version of this card can easily fetch $20-25 on the market, but I‘m not a huge fan of this specific reprint.
#19. [PZA] Rhythm of the Wild – $14.50
Rhythm of the Wild fits the Turtles’ themes perfectly. While this enchantment is on the battlefield, each nontoken creature you control can enter either with haste or with a +1/+1 counter, depending on your needs. TMNT is really wild, especially when we consider what the Turtles usually fight. It’s a staple card in RG that’s not reprinted enough.
#18. [PZA] Arcbound Ravager – $14.50
If you want to sacrifice artifacts for free, Arcbound Ravager has you covered. Transfer all counters from a ground creature to an evasive flier, possibly with infect? Ditto. It’s a classic creature that sees play in many formats, different contexts, and this art is really sick. Easily worth $10+.
#17. [PZA] Waves of Aggression – $14.50
I think this reprint’s art is spot on because, for me, nothing screams TMNT more than beat-‘em-up games, and those are well-known for having Waves of Aggression. It’s a $20 card that’s very solid in Commander, and with retrace you can take an extra combat step whenever you draw and discard a land. One of the better cards for aggressive strategies gets a cool reprint with nice, thematic art, and I’m very okay with that.
#16. [TMC] Michelangelo, the Heart – $16.50
Michelangelo, the Heart is a 2-drop creature that’s a real glue card since it fits a lot of strategies. Food tokens mean lifegain, while Mikey has trample, so you can put the +1/+1 counters on it, too. This card also works well with Mutagen tokens. It’s a cool and versatile card, but I’m not feeling $16.50 on this one.
#15. [TMC] Splinter, the Mentor – $18.00
Splinter, the Mentor takes the turtles deck in another direction, focusing on the sneak ability at first, but you can throw in some sacrifice effects. I can see this creature being very valuable in a wide range of decks, including those that merge aristocrats with artifact sacrifice – it’s a payoff for sacrificing creatures, and it generates sac fodder artifacts as well.
#14. [TMT] Dark Leo & Shredder – $19.00
Dark Leo & Shredder is a very cool new ninja from the Standard-legal set. Showing off the new sneak mechanic, this card gives you the incentive to run ninjas: It grants deathtouch when they attack, and with enough ninjas around, it’s a possible win condition. And it’s hard to block a 1/3 deathtoucher profitably. This card has very cool art, too.
#13. [TMT] North Wind Avatar – $19.00
Some things never change. Every new MTG set has a nice, big dragon at mythic rarity, often a 5/5 for 5 mana that’s one of the most expensive cards of the set. North Wind Avatar is an interesting variation on your average dragon, giving you a sideboard card for free. If there’s something MTG Arena taught me, it’s that cards with learn, or cards like Fae of Wishes do see play, and I have high hopes for this dragon. Excellent combo with airbend as well.
#12. [PZA] Undercity Sewers – $19.00
Undercity Sewers, like the other surveil lands, is very expensive. They’re legal in Standard and playable in many other formats due to fetch land synergies. That said, a critique I’ve seen about this card is that a turtle sleeping in the sewers hardly reminds us of a blue and black land. This may, in fact, tank this specific version, and other versions of this land usually sell for $25-30.
#11. [TMC] Raphael, the Muscle – $19.50
Raphael, the Muscle has an immediate impact on the board, if you’re playing with +1/+1 counters. And if you aren’t, well, here’s your Mutagen token. It’s a nice aggressive pair with Leonardo, the Balance, because of the one-two punch – create a token, spread counters, double the damage.
#10. [TMC] Donatello, the Brains – $20.00
A partner commander, Donatello, the Brains produces a lot of Mutagen tokens over the course of a game. Many MTG cards synergize with +1/+1 counters, either when you put them on a creature or when they’re doubled.
#9. [TMC] Leonardo, the Balance – $23.00
Leonardo, the Balance is the main 5-color commander of the Turtle Power! Commander precon, and it’s fairly easy to build around it. MTG’s never had a 5-color commander that cares about any kinds of tokens, and putting a +1/+1 counter on each creature opens up plenty of synergies around colors. Plus, with partner select, you can have different commander combinations to skew the deck towards a certain style. It’s going to be a popular commander, but I don’t think the card price will stay as high as it is right now.
#8. [TMT] Krang, Utrom Warlord – $28.00
Krang, Utrom Warlord looks like a big Darksteel Forge on legs, while granting other artifact creatures strong abilities. It can be a powerful commander, but its most likely home is in a Standard/Pioneer reanimator deck. This card can be a nice surprise threat with an immediate impact on the board and an excellent colorless ramp payoff at the level of the Eldrazi titans.
#7. [TMC] Heroes in a Half-Shell – $30.00
The alternate 5-color commander for the precon, Heroes in a Half Shell can do a lot of work. You’ll probably have to build around this card, at least around one of the creature types, but just attacking with this creature and getting a +1/+1 counter and a card is solid, and really good if you’re giving this bonus to your whole squad.
#6. [TMT] Super Shredder – $35.00
Super Shredder is the most expensive card from the regular TMNT set, and a very hyped mythic. It’s a card that can hold its value pretty easily: It’s a 2-drop that can become a staple in singleton formats, and almost everything that happens in a game of MTG can grow this creature, from removal to fetch lands and sacrificing creatures. Or Treasure. Or blinking creatures.
#5. [PZA] All Will Be One – $35.50
All Will Be One is a damage machine in any counter-based strategy. Be it with planeswalkers, creatures with +1/+1 counters, spreading -1/-1 counters around, this card does some work. It’s a winning strategy to put +1/+1 counters on your creature and damage their smallest creatures at the same time. And if you’re consistently doubling counters, some players might go down, too.
#4. [PZA] Shadowspear – $45.00
Shadowspear is a heavily played equipment in formats like Commander, Cube, and 60-card formats. Giving lifelink and trample to a creature for such a small amount of mana is premium, and the card is easily fetchable with Urza’s Saga or Trinket Mage. Besides, it’s nice to override common protection cards like Swiftfoot Boots and Heroic Intervention. I enjoy this reprint as Donnie’s Bo, and the art is gorgeous. Totally worth the admission price.
#3. [PZA] Trouble in Pairs – $46.50
Ever since its only printing in Murders at Karlov Manor Commander, Trouble in Pairs quickly became a white staple in Commander, and it’s currently a $30 card. It rewards you for so much stuff your opponents might play, while stopping extra turns. It slows the game down for everybody but you, similar to other staples like Smothering Tithe and Rhystic Study. This version has nice, premium art, so I expect it to be heavily played and maintain its value in the long run.
#2. [PZA] Doubling Season – $47.50
I remember when I first built a token EDH deck and searched for this card online, only to find out that well… it’s very expensive. Maybe I should settle on something else…. Doubling Season has been reprinted a lot lately on many bonus sheets, but the price won’t go down at all. It’s even Standard legal thanks to Foundations. It seems like every other green Commander deck these days either makes tokens or piles up counters on creatures, so you can get why this card is heavily played.
#1. [PZA] Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm – $50.00
Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm is an incredible card to build around, and one of the best incentives to build a rat typal deck. This card has a short supply, having only been printed in a Jumpstart product, Jumpstart 2022, and it’s a $70+ card. Well, now you can play your Splinter of the Shadow Swarm, with beautiful art. This card will probably hold its value in the $30-40 range, and it’s one of the clear chase cards this set has to offer.
Oh, and if you haven’t already, check out this video version we just uploaded to YouTube!
Promos, Alternate Art, and More
Now that we’ve covered the main cards from the Standard and Commander offerings, let’s take a deeper look at the special treatment cards we can find in TMNT.
Turtles Team-Up Exclusive Cards
Turtles Team-Up is a specific product that has exclusive cards in its preconstructed decks. Once more, we have one version of each turtle, and all of these are simple designs but actually pretty good. They remind me of Limited bombs from core sets of old. And since they’re not found in regular boosters, their price may vary. Some of these are already being sold on the secondary market in the $15-25 range.
These cards are found only in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Pizza Bundle, and each bundle has two of these six promo cards.
As of now, Dark Ritual is the most expensive card from these, ranging from $100-120, so consider yourself lucky if you open one of these.
As expected, we have a special treatment for each of the four main turtles. You’ll find these cards drawn and signed by Kevin Eastman (TMNT co-creator) only in Collector Boosters.
All MTG sets these days have a fun, different frame style on select cards. TMNT is no exception, and we have some funky, Saturday morning cartoon-style cards that might not be suited to everybody. Thirty of these are available. Both Collector and Play Boosters have them in foil and nonfoil versions.
Eight cards have the special silhouette treatment, and this shows the more sneaky and hidden aspect of the ninja turtles. Both Collector and Play Boosters have Silhouette cards in foil and nonfoil treatment.
This is a Japanese art take on the turtles, all in borderless, gorgeous art. Ten cards have this Japan Showcase special treatment, but you can only find them in Collector Boosters.
Michelangelo, the Heart | Illustration by Nestor Ossandon
MTG TMNT looks fun, and there’s definitely value to be had in the various quality reprints and powerful mythics. Compared to previous sets, there isn’t that specific crazy card everybody’s talking about, like The Soul Stone, Bitterbloom Bearer, or the golden Traveling Chocobos. And that’s fine in many ways. Card price isn’t the end-all-be-all. When Aetherdrift was spoiled, Stock Up didn’t make this list at all, and it’s a hell of a card.
What do you think about the more expensive cards from this set? Are you enjoying this lighter and funnier take on MTG that the Turtles provide? Let me know in the comments section below, or let’s take the discussion to Draftsim Discord.
Thanks for reading, and stay safe!
Follow Draftsim for awesome articles and set updates: