One Disney movie series is almost perfect, but it also includes one flawed $226 million film that is easily its weakest link. Some of the most incredible and widely popular movie series of all time come under the Disney tag. From the MCU to the Pirates of the Caribbean movies, Disney boasts a staggering range of blockbuster franchises that have shaped modern cinema in more ways than one.
Especially when it comes to animation, Pixar has stood as Disney’s crown jewel by delivering one critical and commercial hit after another. Among all the incredible Pixar movie series out there, though, there is one that is known for never experiencing any dips in quality. The Toy Story movies have consistently done well at the box office and even earned massive feats during awards seasons.
However, one film in the Toy Story series, Lightyear, remains a weak link. Lightyear, by no means, was a critical failure, considering how it still earned a decent Rotten Tomatoes score of 74%. However, compared to most other Pixar movies and films in the Toy Story franchise, Lightyear is clearly the subpar addition.
Why Lightyear Couldn’t Capture That Toy Story Magic
Sox and Buzz Lightyear in Lightyear
Lightyear’s underwhelming box office can partly be attributed to the fact that many viewers avoided seeing it in the theaters and waited for its streaming release. While Chris Evans did a great job at voicing Buzz Lightyear in the film, Tim Allen’s absence as his voice actor just felt off in the movie. More than these aspects, though, it is Lightyear’s significant shift from some of the best elements of the Toy Story franchise that made it seem relatively subpar.
The movie attempted to present sky-high stakes for the titular character by unfolding his origin story as an epic space adventure. As a standalone film, Lightyear seems to work quite well as a fun, animated space opera. However, since it is an extension of Toy Story, many expected it to lean into the same heartfelt simplicity that defined all previous Toy Story films.
Lightyear, too, has a fair share of feel-good moments, especially in scenes that focus on SOX. However, the completely different setting of its storytelling and its desire to come off more as a high-spectacle sci-fi movie made it seem disconnected from the main franchise. Most stories in the main movies also focus on the dual lives of the central toys.
Buzz Lightyear, too, has been an active part of the same narrative in all the Toy Story movies where he pretends an inanimate toy in front of humans. Yet, Lightyear seems to humanize him to a point where he no longer feels like the same delusional-yet-endearing toy who once believed he was a real space ranger.
The movies’ playful duality and meta-storytelling have always been a massive part of their appeal. These aspects even make the Toy Story films a lot more thought-provoking than many other mainstream animated flicks. Lightyear, however, seems to diminish these elements, explaining why many viewers struggled to see it as a worthy extension of the Toy Story universe.
Lightyear’s Biggest Problem Was Its Confusing Connection To Toy Story
Buzz Lightyear and Woody in Toy Story 5
It is hard not to question why Lightyear was even made because Toy Story had already walked through his origin story. In Toy Story 2, it was already revealed that the evil Emperor Zurg was Buzz’s father, which even served as a fun homage to Star Wars. Lightyear surprisingly retconned many aspects of his origin story, creating a gap between its own narrative and the Toy Story movies.
Owing to this, even its place in the overarching franchise remains ambiguous and ruins the narrative consistency the previous movies had established.
Lightyear still comes off as a heartfelt take on Buzz’s origins and even makes him seem more rootable by adding several bittersweet aspects to his overarching story. However, without Woody, Lightyear just seems incomplete. The film lacks the emotional counterbalance that Woody and Lightyear’s dynamic brings to the Toy Story movies.
Fortunately, Toy Story 5 seems to be nothing like Lightyear. The Disney movie will return to all the ingredients that previously made the franchise so fascinating, and, hopefully, perform a lot better than Lightyear.