“I know how I felt when I listened to a Beatles song. Something about connecting to the music that made me feel great,” he added. “And when I started writing songs that people connected to as well, God, it was such a beautiful feeling for me.”
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
However, Grohl’s persona — which includes being a proud “girl dad,” even bringing oldest daughter Violet Grohl onstage to perform with him — was put to the test when he revealed on Instagram in 2024 that he fathered a child outside of his marriage.
“I plan to be a loving and supportive parent to her,” Grohl stated in an online post. “I love my wife and my children, and I am doing everything I can to regain their trust and earn their forgiveness.”
The backlash was fast and brutal. Violet and her sister Harper Grohl temporarily deactivated their Instagram accounts after news of the scandal broke. A subsequent Foo Fighters tour was canceled. Fans were left wondering: Could Grohl reclaim his likability?
On the band’s 12th studio album, “Your Favorite Toy,” the answer is clear: He doesn’t really care.
The new project is raucous, loud, sometimes morose, and intentionally unpolished. “Your Favorite Toy” traded the sheen of extravagant studios and prominent producer Greg Kurstin for the simplicity of Grohl’s home studio.
The untimely death of Foo Fighters drummer Taylor Hawkins in 2022 cracked Grohl’s heart wide open on the album “But Here We Are,” which arrived in 2023 and became the group’s most noteworthy work in years. However, vulnerability comes in a different form on “Your Favorite Toy.” (The project also serves as the group’s first album with new drummer Ilan Rubin, who took over for Josh Freese — Hawkins’s original replacement — in 2025.)
On the opening track, “Caught in the Echo,” Grohl seems to be at war with himself, as his garbled screams convey levels of uncertainty when it comes to making decisions. Grohl confessed to The Guardian last month that he’s completed more than 400 therapy sessions over the last year in an effort to navigate his own rash behavior.
“Here comes the crash/ I move in two directions/ I move in complication/ Waiting for intersection,” he sings. “I wanna take it back/ Nobody here is truly free/ Consider this an emancipation from all of my confusion.”
“Caught in the Echo” represents Grohl’s pensiveness and how the “Best of You” singer doesn’t always possess the confidence fans assume he has. Self-doubt is tortuous, he asserts, regardless of status.
The adrenaline-inducing and jagged nature of “Of All People” is about cheating death. Grohl previously explained it’s about an infamous drug dealer he knew who managed to sober up, but the song also finds Grohl battling the internal guilt of surviving tragedies that many people couldn’t.
One of the album’s highlights is the title track, which pokes fun at Grohl’s wholesome image. His gritty and distorted vocals give way to an unexpected gusto in which he slickly croons: “Your pretty face in a mirror/ One hand to spin the lens/ But it ain’t getting clearer/ Dead gardens from bad seeds.”
He continues: “But nice guys grow on trees/ Big smile, try not to choke on the glitter.”
Not only is Grohl throwing cold water on a widely held opinion of him, he’s also reminding listeners that being “nice” isn’t all that it’s cracked up to be — and that it’s a title that can be stripped from you at any second.
The cerebral “Child Actor” gives fans a more intense look into Grohl’s relationship with perfectionism and how he can never outrun his need for external approval. A sauntering lyrical introduction leads to questioning his self-worth, before a blistering chorus of “Turn the cameras off” is repeated into what feels like oblivion.
Grohl’s career is frequently presented as mythical, making him seemingly impenetrable to criticism. Despite the saintliness the public has bestowed upon him, life isn’t that simple — Grohl is wholly aware of that fact.
Ultimately, “Your Favorite Toy” isn’t a plea for redemption; it’s a striking reiteration of humanity.