The NHL preseason can be a pretty fun experience. Seeing players you don’t normally see in your favorite team’s jersey, to wish on for the future, to be able to hold onto hope that what we saw in one single game is actually them and they will truly reach a potential we think about often. That’s the nice and positive part of the preseason.

There’s also the kind of preseason that can end a player’s NHL career and we may have just seen that on Saturday night.

The Philadelphia Flyers hosted the Washington Capitals for the final game of their preseason. They iced almost a full NHL lineup. Everyone was present and in their normal spots except the fact that Garrett Wilson got in a game before he was sent back down to Lehigh Valley Phantoms training camp and to be a leader down in the AHL all season long. And goaltender Aleksei Kolosov was in between the pipes for all 60 minutes.

Despite having all of this going for them, just two total players who are not NHL regulars, they suffered a disheartening 5-1 loss to the Capitals. It is just the preseason so of course the loss itself doesn’t matter at all, but the aforementioned Kolosov played so poorly that he should really never be considered for any NHL role whatsoever for a very long time.

Aleksei Kolosov’s terrible, terrible night for the Flyers

The Flyers were in control for the vast majority of Saturday’s preseason finale. They were running up the shot counter like it was nothing, appearing so far removed from the defensively focused Rick Tocchet team we saw last year. Matvei Michkov was continuing his return to form, Jamie Drysdale looked great in a bigger role, and even some players who had a quiet preseason like Owen Tippett, were popping off ever so slightly.

But then the game completely unraveled due to a terrible goal to give the Capitals the lead in the second period.

Yeah, we will lay most of the blame on David Jiricek to that one, for just sending a blind no-look pass in his own end. Even if Christian Dvorak may have taken an unexpected route, you have to look to where you’re passing the puck. But it was also Kolosov who was just simply unable to make a fairly normal save. The Capitals player just skated into the puck and one-timed it for what would end up being a goal. The Flyers netminder didn’t lose track of the puck or anything like that. He remained focus on it but was just unable to physically make that needed save.

If he ever wants to remain in the NHL for more than just an extreme emergency, he should be making those saves like they are nothing.

That’s not even the worst of it, though.

On the Capitals’ third goal it is another fairly predictable play that ends up with the puck phasing through Kolosov and into the back of the net. Washington wins the faceoff, the pointman gets some open ice after two forwards commit to being a little too aggressive, and then he just lays it off to 28-year-old Ethen Frank (who has 16 career NHL goals at 28 years old).

The pass to Frank was even intercepted by Noah Cates to slow it down and give Kolosov that extra half a second to set himself up for the save. But it didn’t matter. It is a shot that he ended up not getting to in time, even if he was given a bit of help. Up and over his shoulder like it was nothing.

We have already seen bad experiences with Kolosov in net. His last appearance in an actual NHL game that mattered was the time that he gave up three goals on three shots to the New York Rangers. But since then, he’s been given another opportunity to re-establish his position in the organization and looked half-decent in his other appearance where he saved 14 of 17 shots against Boston earlier this week.

But now it is clear that Kolosov has no place in the NHL. He has no business being someone who is just one minor injury away from being an actual possibility of playing in the NHL. That’s just it.

There needs to be a different No. 3 goalie

Ideally, Kolosov should be somehow wheeled out of the organization since it’s not like he was a good AHL goalie last season either (an .895 save percentage in 38 games for the Phantoms). So, can he actually be a third-string option for a team that is hoping to make the playoffs?

We know all too well how the goalies behind your starting goalie can affect a season. Dan Vladar can put in an immense amount of work and effort to become the best player he can be — and then the entire season can unravel just because the backup or No. 3 goalie has to have a larger role for a week or two.

Kolosov has proven with his performance on Saturday night that he cannot be depended on by the Flyers. He simply cannot be an actual player who the Flyers recall in the middle of the season due to injury. We’ve already been scared with a Dan Vladar injury and the season hasn’t started yet. Imagine if one of Vladar or Joseph Woll had to miss a month and Kolosov was the answer, putting in performances like Saturday night’s exhibition game during every one of his starts.

It doesn’t even matter if it means messing up the goaltending depth in the AHL. It’s Kolosov and prospect Carson Bjarnason locked in as the Phantoms tandem and there is no way the latter is getting an NHL chance at just 21 years old in case of an injury. How the Flyers are set up right now is extremely insecure in the goaltending position.

If there is ever an absence that stretches beyond one week, general manager Danny Briere will need to start working the phones. Letting Kolosov get that opportunity is just going to lead to more losses and more misery, to put it really simple. Whether it’s some aging veteran who has been a regular backup, or someone in their mid-20s and has at least some solid NHL experience; it is a better option than Kolosov and it could mean the difference between another playoff appearance and having an early end to their season.

A different third-string goalie has to be found. It feels impossible for Kolosov to potentially get another key NHL opportunity after the performance he just had against the Capitals. He can now just hangout in the AHL and maybe eventually return to the KHL. Sure, that’s fine. Best wishes, Aleksei.

He was once full of promise and potential but it’s so clear that he just does not have it, and the Flyers need to lose elsewhere if needed.