The 24-team College Football Playoff is going to stink almost as much as my weekly predictions.
College football made it official Monday. In 2027, the field doubles, the first two rounds move to campus sites and the Power 4 title games go away. Win it all without a bye, and you’ll play 17 games. Have you seen an NFL offensive line by Week 18? Those guys do this for a living.
Will I watch? Of course. In a CFP survey reviewed by The Athletic, 71 percent of fans who opposed expansion said they wouldn’t watch fewer games. I’m with them. Give me a Thursday night game on campus and I’ll talk myself into an upset.
Speaking of bad picks, I’m going back to a few old favorites in this week’s stat-stuffers. Yes, I’m still looking for my first W.
Passing
I’ve gone with Oklahoma State’s Drew Mestemaker twice before, and the Cowboys lost both times — at Tulsa and Iowa State. This week’s opponent is 12th-ranked Texas Tech, which can get to the Big 12 Championship Game if it wins out. The 25th-ranked Cowboys, meanwhile, will pull even with Texas Tech with a win and make everybody spend Sunday looking up tiebreakers. Texas Tech, a 3.5-point underdog, gives up 309 passing yards per game in league play. The Red Raiders also lost No. 2 receiver Coy Eakin to a broken hand, so I’m giving Oklahoma State the edge in a game where I expect both quarterbacks to be throwing late.
Mestemaker goes for 412 yards and four touchdowns, the last to Wyatt Young, and Oklahoma State wins 41-38 on a late field goal.
Rushing
Boise State’s Dylan Riley is my rushing pick for the second time this season. The 24th-ranked Broncos can guarantee the Pac-12 Championship Game will be at home with a win over Oregon State. The Beavers can give themselves a shot at making that trip by winning this weekend on the blue turf, but quarterback Braden Atkinson isn’t expected to play due to a hand injury suffered last week. So, I’m taking Boise State, a 13.5-point favorite, because handing the ball to Riley against a defense that gives up 4.6 yards per carry is smart business.
Riley breaks a 50-yarder, finishes with 214 yards and two touchdowns, and Boise State wins 38-23.
Receiving
Jeremiah Smith is my receiving pick for the second week in a row after catching seven passes for 133 yards and a touchdown in Ohio State’s loss to Oregon last week. He needs a big game to impress Heisman Trophy voters, and 20th-ranked Ohio State needs to beat Northwestern to keep its Big Ten title hopes alive. The Buckeyes are 12.5-point favorites against a defense that gives up 251 passing yards per game away from home.
Quarterback Luke Fahey leans on Smith for 10 catches, 188 yards and two touchdowns, the second one in the fourth quarter. Ohio State wins 33-25.
Five big gamesNo. 13 Wake Forest at SMU (-1)
Wake Forest has three games left and a simple deal. Win them all and go to Charlotte for the ACC title game. SMU can hand the Deacons a second ACC loss and keep its own title hopes alive heading into its conference finale at Stanford. Wake expects Gio Lopez back from a leg injury, so the Mustangs will have to keep scoring. I’ll take Kevin Jennings at home, where SMU averages 9.8 yards per pass attempt.
Wake kicks a field goal in overtime, and then Jennings throws the winning touchdown on third down in the Mustangs’ home half of the extra session. SMU wins 43-40.
Duke at No. 7 Miami (-13.5)
Darian Mensah and Cooper Barkate helped Manny Diaz win the ACC championship at Duke last December. Now they can beat their old team and put the Canes one step closer to securing a spot in the 2026 title game. Duke’s best chance is to get Nate Sheppard involved in the passing game, too. Miami allows 64.3 rushing yards per game, the fewest in the country.
Sheppard runs for 76 yards and a touchdown on 19 carries and catches four passes for 38 yards, helping Duke take a 17-10 halftime lead. With Malachi Toney out, Mensah finds Barkate for the go-ahead touchdown in the fourth quarter. The Canes add one more late on a Javian Mallory run and win 34-24.
No. 18 USC at No. 9 Indiana (-10)
Curt Cignetti hasn’t said whether Josh Hoover or Grant Wilson will start at quarterback for the Hoosiers, who did not play last week. Win out and IU will head to the Big Ten title game. USC, meanwhile, can pull even with IU with a win.
Charlie Becker sets up Turbo Richard’s go-ahead touchdown run with a long catch in the fourth quarter. Jayden Maiava gets USC across midfield on the final drive, but Indiana gets pressure on fourth down and forces an incompletion. The Hoosiers win 24-20 but fall to 1-9 against the spread this season.
No. 2 Utah (-3) at No. 23 Arizona
Arizona can give itself a shot at the Big 12 Championship Game, while the Utes can clinch a spot with a win and losses by Houston and BYU. Noah Fifita finds Isaiah Mizell deep early, but Utah takes over up front and punishes the Cats at the line of scrimmage. With Wayshawn Parker expected to play through a bruised heel, Devon Dampier does more of the running and scores twice on the ground.
The Utes score touchdowns on their first two drives after halftime, and Arizona spends the fourth quarter trying to get the ball back. Utah wins 35-20.
North Texas (-2) at UTSA
UTSA got run out of Boca Raton, Fla., by FAU last week but can still pull even with North Texas atop the American with a win. The Mean Green are the league’s last unbeaten team in conference play, but they give up 244.8 rushing yards per game away from home.
Will Henderson III gives UTSA enough on the ground to open things up for Owen McCown. Tayven Jackson throws for more than 300 yards and finds Justin Stevenson late to force overtime. But UTSA gets the stop it couldn’t get at the end of regulation, and McCown throws the winner on third down as UTSA wins 44-38 in overtime.
Upset alertNo. 6 Texas at No. 21 LSU (-4)
Texas can stay in the SEC title race and give the Playoff committee another road win to chew on and add to its one-point victory over Ohio State. LSU already has three league losses and needs a win and help to get to Atlanta. With left tackle Trevor Goosby out for the season, Texas will need its defense to keep this close.
The Longhorns, who average 4.7 sacks per game away from home, get a big one late in the fourth on Sam Leavitt that pushes LSU out of field goal range. Arch Manning gets Texas close enough for a 46-yarder as time expires. Texas wins 27-24.
Reader predictions
Thanks again for sharing your Week 10 predictions. Some of you envisioned Notre Dame beating Miami. One of you had already invented a bowl game for the Irish in case it went the other way.
These fans were mostly right:
Liam: “The biggest week of the season is a dud. Utah, Texas, Alabama, Ohio State, Tennessee, Georgia, and Notre Dame each win by double digits.”
ND Mikey: “Irish beat Hurricanes 31-21”
Jimmer: “Nebraska will lose again this week at Illinois, but will not hold a lead in the fourth quarter so the pain of Nebraska fans will be less than normal.”
David: “Oklahoma goes into the Swamp and throttles the Gators 27-3, taking some pressure off Brent Venables (for now).”
Asher A.: “Alabama exposes LSU as a poser and throws a haymaker to their playoff hopes.”
These fans missed badly:
Dan: “Ohio State blows out Oregon because Dan Lanning is great at motivational speeches but not coaching, apparently, and gets fired this week”
Steve B.: “The higher-ranked team (UGA/ Bama/ Kentucky/ Texas) loses in all 4 of the SEC ranked match-ups.”
Andy: “BYU by 36 points”
Week 10 report card
I went 4-5 picking winners and 4-4-1 against the spread, bringing me to 52-38 straight up and 41-45-4 ATS for the season. Insert vomit emoji here. Miami’s 31-24 loss at Notre Dame dropped my upset alerts to 2-8. The Irish won by exactly seven, so at least I got a push out of South Bend.
The good: Utah beat BYU by the 8 points I predicted, and Dampier ran for two touchdowns, including the fourth-quarter score that made it 28-20. He threw for two more. Georgia covered with 32 points to spare in a 42-7 win over Ole Miss. I also got Louisville to win and cover against Georgia Tech, which was the part of the Isaac Brown prediction that didn’t require Isaac Brown.
The bad: I feel like a jinx every time I pick an Oregon State Beaver to blow up statistically. Atkinson hurt his throwing hand and threw for only 192 yards and zero touchdowns instead of 425 and four, and Oregon State lost 42-21 to Texas State. Brown ran for 38 yards and a touchdown instead of 175 and three in Louisville’s big win. And Miami’s Somourian Wingo caught one pass for 2 yards. I asked for nine catches, 118 yards and two touchdowns. Leavitt threw for 380 yards and Jackson Harris caught 11 passes for 166. They accounted for zero touchdowns in LSU’s 31-13 loss.
Just missed: Missouri QB Austin Simmons threw for 252 yards and two touchdowns, 2 yards off my prediction, but Texas won 34-20. DeSean Bishop ran for 109 yards and two scores, both in the fourth quarter, when Tennessee was already up 20-6. I got the Tennessee win and somehow still managed to give Kentucky too much credit.